If the Federal Statistical Office (FSO) is to be believed, households experienced negative inflation this year (-1%), i.e. an overall reduction in the price of goods. However, this does not apply at all to at least one category of the statistical consumer basket of goods: daily and weekly newspapers. This is because many of them are once again increasing their subscription and newsstand rates. Of the 93 subscription offers surveyed (including double subscriptions to weekday and Sunday editions), 62 are increasing their rates as of 2016 - by an average of CHF 14.28 or 4.7 percent. 28 titles waived this. And two titles are even reducing their price. One is the Zofingen edition of Schweiz am Sonntag: it is reducing the price of its annual print subscription, which previously cost CHF 134.30, by 30 centimes (not francs!) or -0.2 percent. Basel's TagesWoche is more generous: it is reducing its subscription rate by -46 percent to CHF 120.
Newspaper subscriptions between 188 and 700 francs
But back to the normal case: the most significant increase in the price of the annual print subscription is for the Olten edition of Schweiz am Sonntag (CHaS) - it will be 74 francs more expensive (now 173 francs). The background: AZ Medien, which recently took over OT completely, was already charging CHF 173 for the CHaS solo subscription, but allowed its Olten partners to set their own rates. AZ Medien is now also equalizing the subscription rate in the Olten area, at least for new CHaS subscribers. An interim solution has been agreed with the 50 or so households in Olten that already subscribed to CHaS solo, says AZ spokeswoman Anina Räbsamen.
The Tages-Anzeiger has the second-highest price increase, namely CHF 30 or 6 percent. By contrast, the Willisauer- and Seetaler Boten and Zentralschweiz am Sonntag have the lowest mark-ups - just CHF 2.
The most expensive subscription for a single title is still the western Swiss business daily Agéfi, where subscribers pay CHF 700 per year - unchanged for years. Close behind at CHF 675 is the NZZ, which has not increased its subscription rate for the first time since 2010. And at CHF 188, the cheapest (5-day) subscription is that of the Romansh newspaper La Quotidiana, which also remains the same.
On average 73 francs more expensive than in 2010
Incidentally, the fact that newspaper subscription rates develop completely differently to inflation applies not only in the short term, but also in the long term. Almost all newspaper subscriptions increased between 2010 and 2016 - by an average of CHF 73 or 22%. During this period, inflation was 0 percent, at least according to the BfS inflation calculator.
The biggest outlier was the NZZ, which costs CHF 163 more than in 2010, followed by the Tages-Anzeiger with a price difference of CHF 154. The Bund (CHF 114), Basellandschaftliche Zeitung (CHF 105), Zürcher Unterländer and Finanz und Wirtschaft (CHF 100 each) have also seen a massive increase. In percentage terms, however, the order is somewhat different: The Tages-Anzeiger is at the top here with a total of +41 percent, followed by Zürcher Unterländer (+34%), Finanz und Wirtschaft (+33%), NZZ (+32%) and NZZ am Sonntag (+31%).
Publishers have repeatedly communicated the reason for this sharp price increase: If advertising revenues fall, subscribers will simply be asked to pay more. After all, they are the second most important source of income.
E-paper subscription: up to 54 percent cheaper than print
However, subscribers are increasingly dropping out or switching to e-paper or digital subscriptions. This is also because the latter are cheaper than the print subscription in 93 percent of cases. As of 2016, the average price for an e-paper subscription on weekdays is CHF 291, which is CHF 113 or 28% less than for a print subscription. On Sundays, an e-paper costs an average of CHF 165, CHF 55 or 33 percent less than the print subscription. The biggest price differences in francs are Le Matin semaine at CHF 220 and Tages-Anzeiger at CHF 214, followed by Blick (CHF 204.50). Blick and SonntagsBlick (54% each), TagesWoche (50%) and Matin semaine (45%) offer the biggest percentage discount on the e-paper. Volksstimme in Sissach offers the smallest discount of CHF 4 compared to the print subscription.
However, at least a dozen titles are preparing to reduce the large price differences by charging more for e-papers than for print subscriptions. Tamedia's ZürichseeZeitung, Landbote, Zürcher Unterländer, 24 heures and Tribune de Genève are the most daring in this respect, with their e-papers adding between 50 and 92 francs.
Digital subscription: up to 87 percent cheaper than print
The differences between digital subscriptions and print subscriptions are even greater: for a pure non-replica subscription (without e-paper), i.e. for continuously updated articles on the website or via app, you pay CHF 344 less (-82%) for the Zürcher Unterländer than for the print subscription. In second place is Blick, which sells its digital subscription for CHF 331 less (-87%) than the print version. On average, a digital subscription costs 29 percent less than a print subscription. However, some (smaller) titles make no price difference, namely Agéfi, Höfner Volksblatt, March Anzeiger and Bote der Urschweiz. And again, it is mainly Tamedia titles that reduce the difference to the print subscription. But there is also the opposite strategy: Le Temps has lowered one of its digital subscriptions and increased the print subscription, widening the difference from 25 to 37 percent.
43 centimes more expensive at the kiosk than in 2011
That leaves the retail tariffs: Here, too, there are currently changes, although publishers are more cautious in this respect. "Only" 28 titles now cost more than before. The Werdenberger & Obertoggenburger (W&O) is daring to increase its price by one franc, a jump of 40 percent. The Saturday edition of Le Temps will be 60 centimes more expensive (+14%). Others are increasing their newsstand rates by 10, 20, 30 or 50 centimes, which amounts to 2 to 20 percent depending on the title. The highest (but unchanged) newsstand price is charged by WoZ (CHF 6), the lowest by Bote der Urschweiz (CHF 1.80).
Publishers' restraint can also be seen in the longer-term newsstand price development. As many as 14 titles have not made any increases since 2011. The Bieler Tagblatt, on the other hand, had the biggest impact: It is now CHF 1.20 or 44 percent more expensive in single copy sales than six years ago. The second-highest increase at the newsstand was recorded by the aforementioned W&O, and there were further 1-franc increases at Nouvelliste (35%) and 24 heures and Tribune de Genève (both (31%). On average, a single newspaper has cost 43 centimes or 13 percent more since 2011.
Markus Knöpfli
The table "Subscription and kiosk rates 2016" accompanying the article can be found in the current print edition of Werbewochde (23/2015).
To the subscriptions
Subscription specialties and curiosities
- The AZ Medien newspapers and the Neue Luzerner Zeitung are leaving it open as to whether they will introduce a paywall in 2016. The Giornale del Popolo is different: it has one, but it is voluntary. How it will work, however, has not been disclosed.
- Some titles also increase their rates during the year: 24 heures and Tribune announced a print subscription price increase of 20 francs for 2015, added another 20 francs at the end of January and are now charging another 20 francs more - an increase of 60 francs or 13 percent within a year.
- Some titles have a retail price for digital editions. This is now also the case with BaZ, where you have to pay 1 franc. This is probably the first time that a title in this area has also raised its price: The Walliser Bote is increasing its digital EV price by 30 centimes to CHF 2.80 (+12%).
- In most cases, the print subscription also includes access to the e-paper and other digital editions. Not so with La Liberté: if you subscribe to print, you only get print. If you also want the e-paper, you have to pay an additional 14 francs. However, you can also have the e-paper on its own and then pay 267 francs, i.e. 34% less than for the print subscription.
- Several e-paper subscriptions are now significantly cheaper than they were six years ago, including those of the Nordwestschweiz titles, Quotidiana, Boten der Urschweiz and Tages-Anzeiger. For example, the Tages-Anzeiger e-paper now costs CHF 84 less than in 2011, while the Zofinger Tagblatt has even reduced its price by CHF 95.
Update: SRF picks up on reporting from Advertising Week