Award At the German Dialog Marketing Award (ddp) in Berlin, there was not a single medal for Switzerland.
Yellow card for the Swiss agencies: at the German Dialogue Marketing Award 2008, not only were there no medals, but there was also criticism of the passivity of the helpers. "We are disappointed with the response to our international competition," said Michael Koch, jury president of the German Dialog Marketing Award (ddp) and managing director at OgilvyOne Worldwide in Frankfurt. The chairman finds the lack of Swiss participation in one of Europe's most prestigious dialog competitions "completely baffling". "There have been complaints from Austria," says Koch, "about the additional 1,000 euros that are due if a campaign either wins a medal or receives an award." But this is a contribution towards expenses that is due for a current book publication.
As the jury of the German Dialog Marketing Association (DDV) received very little mail from the Swiss and Austrian dialog agencies, there was not much to award. Other categories such as "Customer Loyalty", "Mailing" and "Digital Media" celebrated two gold medals. In contrast, the international category "D-A-CH" had no gold winners.
Negative record "We are sad that only 21 campaigns were submitted from Switzerland and Austria," said DDV President Dieter Weng, describing the absolute negative record.
Nevertheless, it was the Viennese agency PKP proximity that scored points in the international category with silver ("How oh") and bronze ("smartam Zug!") for its client ÖBB-Personenverkehr AG. Two agencies from Switzerland also made a positive impression with one award each and made it onto the shortlist.
The jury commended Agentur am Flughafen AG, which designed a multi-stage mailing for the Swiss Textile Federation. The aim was to acquire qualified young talent for the textile industry. This was achieved through a targeted approach and information to high school teachers. The jury liked the approach and execution, especially as the response rate for the dialog campaign was 15 percent out of 1,200 mailings.
The jury also considered the work of Publicis Dialog for the client Hewlett-Packard Switzerland. Under the title "HP magnifying glass mailing", the aim was to raise awareness among Swiss customers of efficient printer solutions from HP. Publicis developed an appealing box containing a tiny letter that could only be read with the enclosed magnifying glass: "Save on small things..." In this case too, the judges recognized the response success of the campaign. Within ten days, there had been 28 presentation appointments on site.
The number of participants from Austria and Switzerland for the international DACH category has more than halved over the past four years. As recently as 2005, 56 agencies submitted entries to the ddp for this category. At that time, Lowe Direct won bronze. In 2006, OgilvyOne took silver, and last year there was also bronze for the Swiss advertising agency Fisch.Meier.Direkt/Publicis and its work for Saab.
Raising awareness among participantsDDV President Weng and ddp jury chairman Koch now want to raise awareness of the ddp among Swiss and Austrian dialogue agencies through campaigns and personal contact. "The German Dialog Marketing Association is now the largest national association of dialog marketing companies in Europe and one of the leading associations in the communications industry. We are open to cooperation," said Weng. "We have to think outside the box, especially as dialog marketing is becoming increasingly important."
German dialog agencies confirm this trend. This time, 126 companies took part, more agencies than ever before. A total of 628 entries were judged (728 in 2006). With 15 gold, 14 silver and 21 bronze trophies as well as 46 awards (shortlist), the current year, according to jury chairman Koch, "shows a very high quality. With fewer entries, we have awarded more golds compared to last year."
OgilvyOne Worldwide was able to defend the title of "Best Dialog Agency". The creatives scored a total of 62 points and distanced themselves from their rivals Heye, 121 (27 points) and DDB Germany (21).
However, the biggest applause of the evening did not go to perennial winner OgilvyOne, but to DDB Germany. The dialog agency based in Hamburg and Berlin won the Grand Prix "Best in Show" for the Volkswagen campaign with the oddball local journalist Horst Schlämmer, alias Hape Kerkeling, which has already won several awards. "No campaign shows more impressively how dialog marketing has changed through digital media and what opportunities are available here," said Michael Koch, explaining the decision in favor of Horst Schlämmer.
Procter & Gamble was delighted to receive the "Eddi" customer prize, which was awarded for the 15th time. Leo Burnett Frankfurt won the gold medal in the Junior Creative Award. All the campaigns and works honored at the ddp 2008 will appear in the ddp yearbook, which will be published in May by Varus-Verlag in Bonn at a price of 50 euros.
Peter Ehm, Munich
Membership decline haltedAt the DDV General Meeting
which also took place in Berlin before the gala event, President Dieter Weng was re-elected for the next three years by a large majority. The former Reemtsma board member had brought the association out of an economic and media slump. The decline in membership, which had been ongoing since 2002, was halted last year. The association currently has 754 members, with 15 new companies and agencies joining since the beginning of the year alone. At its meeting, the DDV also decided to change its name: the German Direct Marketing Association is now called the German Dialog Marketing Association. (pe)