The age of PIN data begins. This euphoric sentence was written above an offer that the Mediapulse subsidiary Publica Data (PDAG) presented to media agencies and TV marketers at the end of April 2011 - an offer for the purchase of "personalized usage data" (PIN) from TV research, including the GfK evaluation tool EvoAd. PDAG set the start of the new "era" for July 1, 2011. Corinna Schneider, employed by PDAG specifically as Senior Project Manager for PIN data and EvoAd sales, did what she could. Her job was to find enough agencies and marketers who wanted to sign the contract for PIN data and the EvoAd tool in time and take the plunge into the new era. Mediapulse CEO Manuel Dähler did not want to put an exact figure on how many at least, but he spoke of "less than ten".
Continue in the text - without PIN data
But when Werbewoche asked Mediapulse, agencies, marketers and the Interessengemeinschaft Elektronische Medien (IGEM) about initial experiences with PIN data last week, there was not the slightest hint of a new era. On the contrary: all agencies continue to work with the previous, aggregated TV data and the old Publisuisse tool Mediaoptimizer. The reason: demand for the PDAG offer was too low, there was "more than one interested party missing", said Dähler. Elsewhere it has been reported that PDAG has only found two or three real interested parties at most. One thing is certain: So far, no PIN data has been delivered at all.
The flop of the PDAG offer is hardly surprising. After all, tests a year ago had shown that the EvoAd tool developed at great expense by GfK was only suitable as a reporting instrument, with which the historical values of TV programs could be evaluated in greater depth than before. However, it was only suitable to a limited extent for the company's own forecasts, planning, optimization and monitoring. In addition, PDAG charges CHF 19,000 for an annual licence - eight times what agencies currently pay for the current planning tools TC2000, Mediaoptimizer and Publiplan (around CHF 2,300 per year - including data). "The costs for the reporting part alone are very high," states IGEM President Stephan Küng.
A new glimmer of hope despite setback
After years of breakdowns and delays, the PIN data issue is thus entering another round. The two TV marketers Publisuisse (SRG) and Goldbach Media (Swiss and foreign private broadcasters), in coordination with IGEM and Mediapulse and with the involvement of the other marketers, have now taken the lead in evaluating advertising planning tools. "These will be presented to us in the near future and we will carry out initial tests," says Publisuisse Director Martin Schneider. Depending on the tools available and the initial test results, it will then become clear whether an "all-in" tool (from forecasting to reporting) will be used in future or a pure planning tool that needs to be supplemented with appropriate tools.
Mediapulse, stick to your last!
The working group that will test the tools should evaluate the tool requirements and market needs in close coordination with the IGEM. Specialists from the various application areas (e.g. agencies for planning, marketers for forecasting) will be delegated to the working groups. However, this also means a new distribution of roles between marketers and Mediapulse. This is what both Küng and Schneider say. Specifically, Mediapulse will in future concentrate on operating a panel and collecting TV usage data, while the TV marketers will procure and operate the tools suitable for the advertising industry. "This is based on the view that in the TV market, the provision of data is primarily in the interests of marketers, as has long been the case in the print and poster sectors," says Küng. And then he adds: "So now we finally have the right distribution of roles with regard to TV data."
Everything is waiting for Mediapulse
At the moment, however, the entire TV industry is looking to Mediapulse. In recent months, the three providers Kantar Media, Nielsen and GfK have been evaluating a new TV measurement system, which is expected to replace the current Telecontrol system from 2013 (see box). The decision on the successor system is expected in December. However, the new system will also have an influence on the choice of future evaluation and planning tools. "Because the new measurement system will also provide a new generation of PIN data, it makes sense to adapt the evaluation of the forecasting and planning tool accordingly," says Schneider. He continues: "The decision in favor of the new measurement system is therefore the next decisive milestone on the way to TV planning with PIN data. The PIN data is therefore automatically a sub-project in the course of replacing the current TV measurement system." The next few months will therefore decide whether the new tool landscape will be ready by 2013 as planned. If not, the introduction of PIN data will also be delayed. However, a postponement to 2014 is to be expected anyway. This is because if planning with PIN data is already possible from 2013, a corresponding tool will have to be available in May or June 2012 so that agencies and marketers can still practice before bookings open in fall 2012. "The timing for an introduction in 2013 is certainly tight. In addition, it is still unclear how exactly the transition from the 'old' to the 'new' data will take place," says Stephan Küng. Markus Knöpfli
Today's panel does not measure around 8 percent of TV usage
At the end of May, Mediapulse announced that it would be renewing the TV panel called Telecontrol as of January 1, 2013. The reason: the current TV panel, which measures 1,918 households across Switzerland, is unable to measure time-shifted television, which, according to Mediapulse CEO Manuel Dähler, accounts for around 7% of total TV usage. Web TV (live streaming via Zattoo or Wilmaa, for example) is also not reported, with only around 1% of TV currently being used via this vector. However, Mediapulse wants to close both measurement gaps with the new panel. Dähler reckoned that the investment in the panel renewal would be "in the single-digit millions".