Dumb luck: Unlike in other parts of the world, WhatsApp is by far the most popular instant messaging service here. Stupid for business. Because unlike other such chat apps, WhatsApp wants nothing to do with brands. While messages on Twitter are by definition public and users on Facebook usually communicate with a circle of more or less selected "friends," WhatsApp was created in advance for one-to-one communication via smartphones. It is very similar to sending text messages, except that the text length is unlimited and videos or audio files, for example, can simply be sent as well. And all of this is virtually free. In our country, WhatsApp has spread rapidly over the last two to three years as a free alternative to paid SMS. Although there are no concrete usage figures, there are clear indications. One is our own circle of friends and acquaintances, where WhatsApp is now part of everyday life even among contemporaries who can hardly be counted among the smartphone avant-garde. And secondly, two studies. A study from last year among young people between the ages of 14 and 25, in which WhatsApp was surveyed as the most-used app by far. This observation was supported by the 2014 "Media Use Index" study, which also showed Whats-app to be the most popular smartphone app. Swisscom's largely unsuccessful efforts to compete against WhatsApp & Co. with its iO app also speak a clear language.
No Ads! No Games! No Gimmicks!
Just as Facebook is shaped by founder Mark Zuckerberg (who bought the Whats app messaging service for a whopping $19 billion in February of this year), WhatsApp is defined by its two founders. Above all, Jan Koum's life story puts its stamp on the company, its product and its behavior on the market. Now 38, he grew up in a poor Jewish environment in a small village outside the Ukrainian capital of Kiev. As a teenager, he emigrated to the United States with his mother and taught himself computer networking. He left university early in 1997 to join Yahoo as an infrastructure engineer, where he met his future co-founder Brian Acton. Ten years later, they both left Yahoo at the same time, and two years later WhatsApp was launched. In Ukraine, Koum's parents avoided making phone calls at the time because the government intercepted conversations, and advertising didn't exist in Soviet times either. Although the WhatsApp software has made a name for itself with a number of security gaps, protecting privacy is one of the company's top priorities, which is summed up in "No ads! No games! No gimmicks!" to the point. Because advertising is consistently avoided, there is no need to collect data about users in order to be able to place advertising messages as precisely as possible - and users do not have to fear that their chat conversations will be disturbed by advertising. And this is where the difficulties for WhatsApp use in a commercial environment begin. Because WhatsApp wants to have as little to do with advertising as the devil does with holy water, there is no support whatsoever for the mass distribution of messages via Whats App. The terms of use are restrictive, there are no special corporate accounts, and above all, there is no officially supported application programming interface (API). Although there are various open-source solutions for this, WhatsApp took legal action against it before the takeover by Facebook, which did anything but build trust. In addition, anyone who wants to subscribe to a distribution list, for example of a brand, has to go through several steps - there is no simple registration option. And the use of content via WhatsApp cannot be reliably measured either.
Big business in Asia
Messaging providers in Asia show the opportunities in m-commerce that such services offer. Take, for example, the Japanese Line service with its flash sales. When this was launched a year ago, 5.5 million of the 22 million Line users in Thailand signed up to benefit from exclusive offers. The offers included smartphone covers, cosmetics and kitchen products, all of which sold out within minutes. Young professionals in particular, two-thirds of whom were women, took advantage of this bargain opportunity. Line customers have long been able to buy virtual stickers and games for good money. KakaoTalk, for example, which is installed on nine out of ten smartphones in South Korea, and WeChat from China with 470 monthly active users are on the same path. Here, not only can cabs, flights and movie tickets be booked, but money can also be transferred to other users or invested in investment funds. Most importantly, it is possible to pay not only for in-app purchases, but also for purchases in stores. For many of these functions, existing services from the parent company Tencent are often integrated into WeChat. These WhatsApp counterparts offer brands their own presences, have officially supported application interfaces, and can be used not only via smartphone but also on desktop. These are all features that are not present in the two corresponding Facebook offerings, WhatsApp (with over 600 million and 500 million registered users, respectively) and Facebook Messenger (500 million). So the question arises how long Facebook, despite the personal preferences of the founders, wants to stand aside here. After all, the chat applications are not only putting pressure on the telecom companies, which are losing out on the once hefty SMS revenues, but also on heavyweights like Google, Apple and Amazon. In their app stores, they skim off margins of typically 30 percent, both on app purchases and later on purchases within the apps. As the examples from Asia show, social messaging services are rapidly establishing themselves as new platforms through which advertisements, apps, goods and services are distributed. But in markets like ours, where WhatsApp has spread, such innovative impulses for new forms of business are lacking.
No urge with Swiss brands
Werbewoche conducted a short, non-representative survey to find out how WhatsApp is viewed in professional communications in this country. Peter Erni, Web Content & Social Media Manager at Mammut Sports Group AG, reported that WhatsApp is only used for private purposes. And he puts it in a nutshell: "As long as the guidelines don't change or WhatsApp doesn't offer comparable options to WeChat, we're not considering increased use." At the Federation of Migros Cooperatives, media spokesperson Christine Gaillet also responds succinctly: "No, we don't work with WhatsApp." She said that the M-Infoline currently offers a total of around ten contact options for customers. "We consider this to be sufficient and efficient." And at Swiss International Air Lines Ltd, Nadja Waldraff from Social Media Marketing notes, "WhatsApp doesn't feature in our marketing mix, but I don't think this is based on a conscious decision either, but simply hasn't been discussed yet." The answer from the social media team at Wander AG (Ovomaltine, Isostar) mentions that WhatsApp is currently only used for internal company communication in special cases and leaves a door open: "If we find that it is a growing need among our customers, we will certainly consider it." Thomas Brühwiler, Head of Communication at Hostpoint AG, agrees: "In principle, the use of chat services in customer service is a possibility that we are observing. However, there are no concrete plans for immediate use at the moment." At online retailer Brack.ch, WhatsApp is also "not an issue at the moment," according to PR Manager Daniel Rei. However, he adds, "We have always said that we need to be where our customers are. From that point of view, we are not fundamentally averse to learning from other companies' experiences with the business application of Whats- App." He sees the main areas of use in marketing, such as sending multimedia push notifications to groups, and customer service. "When responding to customer inquiries, it's advantageous for both companies and customers that contacting them can take place without the channel public being aware of it - unlike Twitter, which is usually the case." And he adds: "Perhaps the relevance of the platform for users also decreases the more companies try to advertise via it. And then we'd be at the same point as on Facebook, where I now get more company news and sponsored posts displayed in my stream than interesting stuff from my friends."
SRF hits the brakes ...
Unlike brands, media companies are more aggressive with WhatsApp. In Switzerland, the youth TV station Joiz distributes news via Whats App to users who have signed up for it - touting "special guests, top news and show highlights ". SRF News distributed information and backgrounds via WhatsApp for the first time during the national votes on the weekend of September 28 as part of a time-limited trial. Project manager Konrad Weber, community manager SRF News, reports that in a subsequent survey, 80 percent of subscribers wanted such a service with regular news. Nevertheless, the state broadcaster is currently putting the brakes on WhatsApp. Weber explains: "If one wants to work with the official WhatsApp solutions and not contradict the general terms and conditions, the personnel costs for an interactive news distribution via WhatsApp are currently enormous." Due to the high demand, however, this decision will be regularly reviewed. While according to company spokesman Christoph Zimmer tagesanzeiger. ch is not currently planning to integrate WhatsApp, Luzi Bernet, deputy editor-in-chief and head of news at NZZ, reports a "small, short and temporary 'guerrilla experiment' with WhatsApp." This type of news distribution is interesting and this option "will certainly be examined more closely". However, they do not want to give away high-quality journalism here either. Whats-app, as well as other social channels, are part of the considerations for new products that are currently being prepared. Ringier has a similar approach. According to Chief Communications Officer Edi Estermann, the use of chat services is currently being examined, particularly in the newsroom of the Blick Group. In the test phase, this is mostly being done on a topic- or event-specific basis, and after initial experience has been gained, a decision will be made as to whether, in what form and with which provider "this new, young information channel should continue to be used.
... 20 minutes gives gas
Last fall, 20 Minuten already introduced a share button so that messages could also be shared via WhatsApp. As Peter Wälty, head of digital development and deputy editor-in-chief, explained on request, this function is now to be placed more prominently and placed over the entire text for Whats App. Because at peak times in the morning up to 95 percent of calls are made via mobile and because WhatsApp can only be used on smartphones, "we are interested in what happens if we make it more visible". This is despite the fact that all the social media hardly bring in much traffic, according to Wälty, with Facebook's share "in the mid single-digit percentage range". At 20 Minuten, they are also working on introducing a WhatsApp broadcast channel to distribute breaking news in advance, and as Wälty revealed in an interview with Werbewoche, preparations for this are already well advanced. But he is in two minds: "What do we actually gain by sending news messages to the audience via WhatsApp, because we can already do that today via our own app." With such a push message, 20 Minuten reaches 1.6 million readers today, he says. And an additional back channel from readers to 20 Minuten, as would be possible via WhatsApp, doesn't necessarily make sense either, he said. "We already receive hundreds of pictures and tips from readers every day anyway." Publishers must therefore think carefully about how dependent they are on such platforms if they use them so prominently, Wälty continues, and concludes for 20 Minuten: "With our own new app, we want to build our own brand even more clearly into a social media brand and place even more emphasis on the return channel.
Christoph J. Walther