The new Christmas lighting for the
Zurich's Bahnhofstrasse arouses emotions. Good and bad. The
The majority of the population still rejects the plant for the time being. But how
do the professionals judge? Every year, the Raymond Loewy Foundation invites 30
of top designers from all over the world for the traditional Design Summit in
St.Moritz. During a stopover in Zurich, the international
Stars of Design also took a look at Bahnhofstrasse.
Werbewoche was there and gathered expert opinions on the new
Zurich landmark captured.
crazy
Michael Erlhoff, Professor of Design History and Theory at the International School of Design in Cologne:
"I think the new decorations for Christmas are completely bonkers, because
Christmas is also kitschy. It has to be that way and Zurich had a
the most beautiful Christmas lights in the world. From January
I find the new decoration excellent as a general
Street lighting. Wonderful idea, this could be a trademark for
Be Zurich. But really not for Christmas."
beautiful
Lisa Strausfeld, Pentagram Agency, New York:
"I love it. It shows me once again that European design has a lot to offer.
is better than American. Strict, elegant, beautifully executed."
fantastic
Ruedi Baur, Atelier Intégral, Head of the Institute of Design at the Zurich School of Art and Design:
"I think it's absolutely fantastic that the city of Zurich is doing something like this.
and that the industry itself wanted to finance something like this. The
Lighting shows a new dimension in what Christmas lighting can be
could. I understand that this triggers discussions. But that is with
This is the case with all new things. News can never be immediately
please. I am sure that in two years' time, the new lighting
be accepted and represent Zurich. People abroad will talk about it
and suddenly Zurich will even be proud of it. In every
case, the new light is a thousand times better than the bears from the last
Summer."
technological
Cheng-Neng Kuan, founder of the Department of Industrial Design at Shih-Chien University in Taiwan:
"It is technologically interesting as an installation - but it falls short of
its purpose of arousing a little emotion at Christmas. Too cold."
cool
Jörg Zintzmeyer, Zintzmeyer & Lux, Zurich, designer of the current Swiss banknotes:
"I think it's a beautiful work of art. It's also brilliant that something like this
can be financed at all. I think that's great. But I think
also that Christmas is kitsch. And it can also be a bit
Have lights and be beautiful. But you can't have everything
at the same time. It has become too cool for me, but let's give
give the object its chance."
sterile
Pia Bech Mathiesen, Director of Design Danish State Railwys:
"When I saw pictures of the design for the first time in Denmark,
I thought: Wow, that looks interesting. When I then put the decoration in
reality, I thought: What a shame that Zurich has something like this!
for Christmas. I think it's too sterile. Christmas is
is a matter for the heart and triggers the most people's
romantic longings. The new light cannot do that. It is a
great installation. However, this should not compete with
all the other old-fashioned lights on Bahnhofstrasse.
Too much blue light that does not match the warm light of the other
decorations on the facades of the commercial buildings. I would like to
get to know the intention of the designer. But if the intention is a
was a big controversy, then the experiment was a success."
takes some getting used to
Paolo Tumminelli, Milan, designer for Alfa Romeo, Rosenthal, Ferrari, Versace.
"I didn't like it as Christmas lighting. The
Christmas atmosphere does not come across. As a lighting concept
on the other hand, I really like it. In the public area, every novelty is
but a reason for disappointment. This was also the case in Milan with
a marvelous monument by Aldo Rossi, which today is much loved.
becomes. Everything takes time."
brave
Hanspeter Danuser, Traffic Director St. Moritz:
"I think the lighting is great. Elegant and above all: "it
makes the difference". Unlike everyone else, just like more than
twenty years ago, when the old decoration was introduced. It speaks
for Zurich for once again daring to do something innovative. The old
Zurich pattern we have also adopted in St.Moritz and we too
now have something new here in front of the Hotel Palace. What impresses me is that
Zurich always wants to set new trends. Cool city."
exciting
Garth Walker, Orange Juice Design, Ogilvy South Africa:
"I think it's fantastic. I can't understand why people are upset about it."
Lars Müller, publicist for design literature in Baden:
"The lighting would look better if all the other lights on Bahnhofstrasse were switched off."
avant-garde
Johann Tomforde, Managing Director hymer/idc Innovation and Design Center, Professor in Pforzheim:
"Zurich is a bit in search of cosmopolitan standards. Some
Things here are excellent, lots of subculture. But now you have to
not at any price with an avant-garde design element
try to evoke a pre-Christmas atmosphere in a different way."
Survey: Andreas Panzeri