Classifieds market The Class project is dead -
Some publishers are now perplexed by the growing classified advertising business.
Tool providers now offer publishers all kinds of solutions.
PubliGroupe is also bidding. For 2005 there are still no
full-year figures on the number of advertisements. But the
Wemf advertising statistics from November 2005 suggest that the
all of the daily and regional press sold by the commercial
advertisements will again have to accept a decline of at least 5 percent.
In the classifieds market, on the other hand, there are signs of improvement: the
The decline has slowed and in some areas, particularly in the
and in some cases also in the real estate sector, there is a - partly even
significant growth. The number of jobs in the
daily and regional press sold, cumulated from January to November
2005, by 7.3 percent, while in the real estate sector the volume
was at least narrowly maintained (-0.6%).
Scramble for industry solution
No wonder, then, that publishers have also been considering for some time how
they can best participate in the thriving online classifieds market
precisely because they know that only a part of the lost
volume of classified ads back to print. It is clear that only
A cross-media strategy (print and online, combined if necessary)
with mobile) can be promising. When last May a
industry solution called Class was launched, PubliPresse and
six publishers (Espace Media Group, Basler Zeitung Medien, Gassmann AG,
Südostschweiz, NZZ, Mittelland Zeitung) to this. Class would have ended up
develop the necessary infrastructure as an independent company in order to
the affiliated companies (advertising clients, Publicitas,
publishers, online marketplaces) to ensure the smoothest possible processing
of classified advertisements both in print and online.
However, in the midst of the still hesitant recovery of the classifieds market, the
Shortly before Christmas, the news that the efforts of the seven
class partner had failed. Officially, it was said that the seven
The financial contributions promised by the companies would have
financing was not sufficient. But that is apparently only half the story
Truth.
Albert P. Stäheli, Delegate of the Board of Directors of Espace Media Group and Ini-tiant
of Class, cites another reason for the failure: "Unlike
originally agreed upon, PubliPresse was no longer prepared to
licenses and applications to Class Service AG
and become a recipient of Class itself. However, this would mean that Class
Service AG fell into the undesirable dependency of P, which the
Basic idea of a neutral industry platform absolutely no longer
would have corresponded."
The fact that the publisher of the independent Berner Zeitung does not
could fit, is clear. But he doesn't seem to be the only publisher
to have been at odds. "It's a shame that the circumstances have once again
have made a sensible industry solution impossible," regrets Stäheli. The
As a result, publishers are now likely to offer individual solutions for the
search for or develop different rubric areas or in the
case of leasehold publishers would be bound to the P solution. Espace
Media did not remain idle: For the real estate sector, the
company has developed its own solution, and in the job sector
with the application manufacturer Prospective, the sister company of
Jobs.ch, cooperate.
Industry is sensitized
Although the industry solution does not materialize, Stäheli
nevertheless: "I believe that the idea of Class has at least one
has triggered a real awareness boost in the print industry," says
er. This is also confirmed elsewhere. "The positive thing about Class was,
that publishers have been sensitized to the topic. This has
alternatives," says Peter B. Müller, CEO of
Unio, solution provider for cross-media advertising and print management.
"Class has been the subject of strategic discussion among publishers for some time.
paralyzed, but now everyone has their eyes and ears open for solutions
open," says Roger Wernli, CEO of Previon AG, which also operates a
software solution. Similar information is also available from other
Application manufacturers such as Prospective or X-Media
(software supplier to the Scout24 Group).
It therefore comes as no surprise that they have all been
months and are now stepping into the vacuum that Class has created at
many publishers. Thus launched
Scout24, the online marketplace associated with X-Media, on New Year's Day
motoscout24.ch, a new marketplace for motorcycles, and is going live with
increased marketing budget. Previon, in turn, went on the offensive with
a strategic partnership with the German company Evolver Media in order to
to strengthen their backs and support both the Swiss and the
German market more effectively.
Unio, previously a pure tool provider, has recently started looking for partners.
among the online marketplaces - based on the realization that the
best application is only attractive enough for publishers if
the newly created online marketplace from the outset also provides a basis for
of advertisements. However, the PubliPresse unit Publiconnect was also
active: Initially, it advertised from the competition TopJobScout24.ch
CEO Markus Bieri of all people - as the successor to
Class project manager and Publiconnect managing director Andreas Göldi.
Since May 2005, it has also been driving the further development of a new
application, to such an extent that - as on January 9
announced - despite the failure of Class now with the tool
Publisherconnect can mingle with the software providers and
publishers as a potential partner. Another way
Prospective AG, which is only active in the job market: As
Media agency for job advertisements advertises the company to other competitors
large job customers and binds them with its own, web-based
tool in itself. CEO Matthias Zimmermann's most recent success: the
The Swiss Federal Administration moved from the
PubliGroupe to Prospective. According to reports, it will also be joined by SBB
follow
Decision probably in the middle of the year
All software providers also state that they work with publishers in
intensive discussions. Some already boast partners
on: Unio, which has already been selected by Tamedia and AZ Medien, is
According to Peter B. Müller, he is also the number one candidate of choice for others,
X-Media has more than 100 different applications for its MediaManager
white label partners, with more to follow according to CEO Daniel Grossen.
According to Markus Bieri, Publiconnect already has two
signed contracts and can still use the new Publisherconnect tool.
in the first quarter of 2006 at the St. Galler Tagblatt and at Société
Neuchâteloise de la Presse (limpartial.ch, lexpress.ch, archebdo.ch,
lacote.ch). And Prospective cooperates - as mentioned - with
with the Espace Media Groupe.
In any case, the race has really been on since the death of Class.
and it will probably be clear by the middle of the year which of the
which software providers are ahead in which category and
will have the most customers and partners. Especially much
is at stake for PubliPresse. Not only because they
increasingly losing classified advertisers to other providers, but also,
because some leased or directed publishers could take advantage of the new situation,
to detach or emancipate itself from the P, at least in the classifieds market.
Roger Wernli from Previon puts it this way: "We are counting on
The publishers will be very wary of being forced to
to become dependent on an intermediary once again."
Markus Knöpfli
Caption:
big: Markus Bieri, CEO Publiconnect
small, top left: Peter B. Müller, CEO Unio
small, top right: Matthias Zimmermann, CEO Prospective
small, below left: Roger Wernli, CEO Previon
small, below right: Daniel Grossen, CEO X-Media