Solothurner Zeitung and Berner Zeitung fight each other with a lot of money and shrill tonesBy Markus Knöpfli In the economic area 32, the battle is currently being fought with tough bandages. The Solothurner Zeitung is fighting back against the Solothurner Tagblatt launched by the Berner Zeitung with advertisements, interviews and stop stickers. The BZ publisher Espace Media Groupe, on the other hand, is keeping a low profile and is digging all the deeper into its marketing pockets.
"There are fewer and fewer newspapers in Switzerland. Traditional titles are disappearing or being merged with other papers. So it's all the more pleasing that the exact opposite is now happening in our region: A new newspaper is being created! The Solothurner Tagblatt." This text appeared in a full-page advertisement published by Espace Media Groupe on
October 11 in the Group's own free newspaper Solothurner Woche.
What sounds so nice, however, caused emotions to run high at Vogt-Schild/Habegger Medien (VS/H) in Solothurn, publisher of the Solothurner Zeitung (SZ). "This is hypocrisy," wrote SZ publishing director Christian Müller in large letters on October 18 in an advertisement that was addressed as an open letter to Charles von Graffenried, Chairman of the Board of Directors of Espace Media Groupe. Müller accuses von Graffenried of saying that the Berner Zeitung has caused more other newspapers to disappear "than any other publishing group in Switzerland". If von Graffenried had had his way, the SZ should also have become the BZ's front page. But because VS/H had rejected this, the Espace Media Groupe now wanted to "bring the SZ to its knees". And further: "They are only creating the Solothurner Tagblatt so that the Solothurner Zeitung will soon no longer exist."
On October 19, VS/H director Rudolf Rentsch doubled down in an interview with the SZ: The Solothurner Tagblatt had "the declared sole aim of weakening the SZ over the coming years so that it ends up in the BZ stew". And he added to WerbeWoche: The ad war in Bern at the time showed the true style of Espace Media, "which is why we are on our guard and are putting on the tough clothes". But VS/H is not afraid, "the troops" are motivated, and the Mittelland-Zeitung project with SZ, Aargauer Zeitung, Zofinger Tagblatt and Oltner Tagblatt is also in the making.
Espace Media Groupe keeps a cool head in heated dispute
He is still of the opinion, Rentsch continues, that this project is more promising than a cooperation with the BZ. Presse 99, for example, a former combination with SZ, BZ and Bieler Tagblatt, was "not very successful". In addition, VS/H would have had to give up all newspaper and customer printing in favor of the Bern printing center in the event of a cooperation with BZ.
Espace Media takes these accusations in stride. Board delegate Albert P. Stäheli said on request: "We will not be provoked and do not want to comment on this." Stäheli is optimistic that Solothurn has a modern zeitgeist that will prevail. Espace Media is also spending a few million on marketing for its seventh headline: the 12,000 copies will be distributed to all households in Solothurn, Biberist and Zuchwil for six months by early delivery, the subscription costs only half as much in the first year (WW 38/01), advertisers receive four advertisements for the price of two until June 30, 2002. In addition, there are mailings, radio and TV commercials, dispensers in buses and trains, advertisements and posters with nine different subjects. This is astonishing for a company that announced in the summer months that, in view of the slump in advertising and the poor TV business, savings and, in some cases, redundancies were the order of the day.
Stop the free newspapers - except for vested interests
So far, Rentsch has countered the heavy artillery from Bern with "the quality of our newspaper". He is also consistently trying to pin the label "free newspaper" on the Solothurner Tagblatt - with reference to the six-month free early delivery campaign. Accordingly, he had thousands of letterbox stickers with the inscription "Solothurner Tagblatt - Nein danke!" distributed. "Help stop the flood of free newspapers," reads an accompanying flyer. Which is not entirely free of hypocrisy. After all, Rudolf Rentsch would love to print part of the circulation of the free newspaper 20 Minuten (see box).