E-papers Digital newspaper editions are only a marginal part of Swiss publishers' accounts. They are popular with readers who travel a lot. "Please wait. The application is loading." "Veuillez patienter.": This or a similar message is received by anyone who selects one of the now quite numerous e-paper editions of newspapers and magazines on the Internet. The surfer almost feels transported back to the early days of the World Wide Web, when - with the feeling of being a pioneer - he listened attentively to the hissing and crackling of the telephone line and watched, deeply impressed, as the first website was hesitantly set up. In the hope of winning back or gaining one or two new readers, but above all because of the widespread herd mentality in the industry, one publisher after another is now also offering its print product digitally.
Back to the future
According to Katja Riefler, consultant for new media and author of a comprehensive e-paper study, around 25 software companies are currently offering solutions for generating electronic newspapers. And business seems to be going well. While Riefler counted 90 digital newspaper editions across Europe in October 2003, six months later there were already 220. Around two dozen e-papers can currently be listed for Switzerland alone.
One reason for the e-paper boom is probably the fact that they hardly meet with any resistance on the shop floor. After all, publishers and editors-in-chief can finally conjure up the well-known and familiar on the screen - and without additional editorial costs. The electronic newspaper also offers publishers tangible advantages. For the first time, customers in the most remote regions of the world can now be served with the latest edition on the day of publication at negligible distribution costs.
According to Christoph Bauer, Head of Marketing at NZZ, this aspect was also the main focus when the digital newspaper was launched in March last year under the "NZZ Global" brand. Above all, subscribers living outside the German-speaking region, who pay up to CHF 1358 (!) a year for the paper delivered by airmail, were to be offered a cost-effective alternative with electronic versions of the international edition and the NZZ am Sonntag. However, the willingness of overseas customers to replace the physical NZZ with the virtual NZZ has so far been very limited. For the Swiss businessman in Shanghai or the German professor in Harvard, the delayed delivery of the reference newspaper, which is probably used as a second or third newspaper anyway, is obviously of little importance.
A beacon for paid content
According to Bauer, the "screen newspapers" are more popular with business people, frequent travelers and generally with mobile readers in Switzerland, who currently make up around two thirds of NZZ Global customers. Especially for subscribers with several domiciles, the e-paper is a welcome addition to the print edition. The access to the NZZ monthly archive associated with the digital subscription is also appreciated as an additional benefit.
Marcel Sennhauser, Head of Interactive Media at Tamedia, makes similar observations for his company's products. The e-paper offerings of Tages-Anzeiger, SonntagsZeitung and Facts are also predominantly used by domestic customers: On the one hand, in areas without early delivery, but also as an additional subscription to the printed edition, which often leaves the house early in the morning with a family member traveling to work. According to Sennhauser, e-papers are also increasingly being used as a substitute for vacation redirects. And the electronic facsimiles can even be used as virtual specimen copies.
The industry's euphoria about this innovation is also due to the fact that it appears to be the first time that customers have been persuaded to pay for journalistic internet content: Users are apparently more willing to reach for their wallets for a format they are familiar with. Many publishers are also using the e-paper launch to seriously experiment with web-based business models and billing systems for the first time (see box above).
A supplement, not a replacement
Nevertheless, e-paper is still a very niche product. Not only can the lack of broadband connections in many places make reading digital editions a pain. The limited readability of newspapers reduced to screen size and the lack of hypertext functions in most cases also make the offerings appear static compared to conventional online services.
Experts therefore recommend e-papers as a supplement and not as a replacement for traditional newspaper websites. It is doubtful whether Swiss publishers see it the same way. In contrast to the New York Times, Washington Post or USA Today, for example, leading local newspapers have started to offer less and less print content on their portals since the launch of their e-papers.
The regular newspaper websites are therefore increasingly developing into suppliers of current (agency) news independent of their print mothers. Background and long-lasting information from the paper products can hardly be found in the free area and is therefore not covered by the search engines. As a result, the major newspapers in particular run the risk of gradually losing their importance as reference media. So are quality newspapers saying goodbye to the Internet with e-paper?
With 2,500 paying subscribers, the digital NZZ is the highest-circulation e-paper among Swiss daily newspapers.
Different business modelsPublishing pricing policies in the e-paper sector are also (still) experimental in nature. Most publications grant existing print customers more or less substantial discounts on additional digital subscriptions. Subscribers to SonntagsZeitung and Le Temps can even use their electronic edition free of charge. However, while Tages-Anzeiger, Blick and SonntagsBlick pass on some of the savings in production and distribution to their customers for full e-paper subscriptions, the NZZ has, according to its head of marketing, "deliberately opted for a stringent application of the print business model" and offers e-paper and print subscriptions at the same price.
Cash, Finanz und Wirtschaft, Basler Zeitung, Corriere del Ticino and La Regione also take this approach. A curious fact about the two Ticino newspapers: e-paper subscribers in Switzerland also receive the printed newspaper, whether they want it or not. Le Temps also only makes the PDF newspaper available to subscribers of the print edition. (mhz)
Very small circulationsEven the New York Times, the paper with the largest international reach, currently sells just 0.28 percent of its print circulation, with 3172 e-paper subscriptions. The USA Today newspaper only sells 900 electronic copies or 0.05 percent of its total circulation. The situation is not much better in Germany, where e-paper circulations have been certified by the IVW since the beginning of 2003, but with a few exceptions are still in the two or low three-digit range.
Only the NZZ publishes its figures in Switzerland. 2,500 copies - 1,700 as additional subscriptions and 800 as full subscriptions - are currently sold via NZZ Global, which corresponds to an impressive 1.6 percent of the total circulation. Tamedia, on the other hand, can only be elicited that its percentage figures are
are comparable to those of American newspapers. The circulation of the E-Tages-Anzeiger is therefore likely to be somewhere between 200 and 600 copies. The e-paper edition of Cash also has a circulation of
Information from Online Managing Director André Michel "in the low three-digit range". (mhz)
Martin Hitz