Online payment models The faltering New York Times annoys its readers by charging for web use.conservative commentator Mickey Kaus
could hardly contain his glee on the slate.com website:
"A few days ago, I suggested the new internet service
to replace TimesSelect with TimesDelete, a service that allows readers to
is allowed to delete the most annoying Times columnists. But that is
not necessary. TimesSelect is Time Delete!" The influential blogger
was thus just one of the many voices that criticized the new online payment model.
the New York Times think is a bad idea. "The public
Debate works better when comment and opinion are unhindered.
are available," he argues. "The free content model is therefore
better for democracy."
But the New York Times, whose economic balance sheets in recent
years did not look so rosy (see box), wants to emerge from the
dependence on capricious advertising revenues and has therefore
introduced the hotly debated TimesSelect online payment model. The
Access to the articles of its most influential columnists was thus
subject to a fee. Fifty dollars a year must be paid by the total of 12.5
million unique visitors to the online edition now pay to see some of the
biggest stars of American journalism such as Thomas Friedman,
Paul Krugman and Maureen Dowd. No more than the price
"a few glasses of Martini", as online boss Martin Nisenholtz
let.
The reference journal aims to attract readers with additional offers such as the
unrestricted access to the Times archives since 1981.
In addition, the popular columnists should do more than just
the usual opinion pieces. Thomas Friedman, for example, whose new
book "The World is Flat" made him a favorite of the business elite
provides a web feature called "Talking World Politics with Thomas
Friedman", which readers can also discuss with him. John Tierney
has set up an online book club, and globetrotter Nicolas Kristof
offers a college student in the future to join him on a
research trip. Business columnist Gretchen Morgenson
leads an interactive feature on wages in the business world, and
Sports reporters offer public discussion rounds.
Bloggers find it difficult
The blogging world, in which the discussion of Times columns has become a daily
Bread, has the hardest time with TimesSelect. Some had
announced that they could not afford the fee, others
tried to circumvent TimesSelect for a while. The blogger John
In the first few weeks, Tabin took advantage of the fact that the Times
Columnists on a syndication model in regional newspapers
who posted the columns on their websites. Under the
headline "Who Needs TimesSelect", he listed all the available
Links to the regional newspapers. But this too will now come to an end:
The Times has asked its cooperation partners to publish the columns
to be encrypted as well.
Also "The Unofficial Paul Krugman Archive", the website of a
Krugman fans, triggered a warning e-mail from the star economist himself,
in which he writes: "Alas, alas - the Times has complained. They
have asked me to write this note and to request that the
column is no longer available free of charge. What a pity."
But many media makers think the model makes sense. "The Times has
started something unique," said Melinda Gipson, for example,
Director of Electronic Media at the Newspaper Association of
America (NAA). "It shows that the Internet is no longer just a big
experiment, but rather a means for newspapers to create new
to open up new readerships."
Gerti Schön
For and against free content
The New York Times has been struggling since 2002, its last big year of success,
with falling revenues, unstable advertising sales and declining
Share prices. The circulation stagnates at around 1.1 million despite
efforts to further strengthen the newspaper on a national level.
level. The management therefore now wants to fill 500 positions
of the NYT Company within a year. Although the largest
Cuts at the NYT (newspaper) with 1200 employees
business side are to be expected, 45 editorial positions are going
lost.
The New York Times is struggling with the same problem as many of its
Competitors: Most of the title's revenue still comes from
through the traditional newspaper business, but the medium of the
The future is undoubtedly the Internet. For comparison: the online sector,
which, in addition to the New York Times Digital and boston.com, also includes the
information service about.com, is recording stable growth
of 30 to 40 percent annually and sales of 100 million euros.
Dollar.
Opinions differ as to whether it makes sense to pay for online content.
to charge fees. Only 39 of the approximately 1500 newspaper websites in
the USA currently charge fees, according to the NAA, often for
specialized services such as sports news or local information.
Opponents of the payment practice point to earlier attempts, for example by Los
Angeles Times. The paper has the fees for an entertainment service
has since been discontinued. Proponents, on the other hand, argue
with the Wall Street Journal and its 750000 subscribers. (gs)