Zigzagging past the view
Ringier Free Newspapers is serious about its free newspaper project. What are the requirements for a new title in the age of *20 Minuten*?
free project seriously. What are the requirements for a new title in the
The age of 20 minutes? It's an open secret that in the
Ringier is working on its own free newspaper under the working title "Day"
is being worked on. So far, however, those responsible have remained silent about
Concept and launch dates covered. Head of newspaper Bernhard Weissberg
for example, only states that the aim is to publish a free newspaper in
this year. CEO Martin Werfeli gives an interview in the
the latest issue of Ringier's in-house magazine Domo, that the
working at full speed on a corresponding project: "I personally
assume that we will succeed in creating a free Swiss newspaper.
realize." No News.
SBB is also keeping a low profile. In the
Last summer, the locations of the newspaper boxes at railroad stations were
with a start of use from January 1. Which of two,
possibly three applicants were awarded a contract - an unmistakable sign that
indication of launch plans - is open in German-speaking Switzerland. "The
The decision will be made in the next few weeks," says SBB spokesman Roland Binz.
At the end of October last year, Ringier opened its first
experiment in the free store with 24 hodin (24 hours) in order to - like
it meant - gaining experience. They were there with 200,000 copies
rival Metro (160000 units), which has been on the market since 1997.
market is. Meanwhile, Metro is spreading nationally, a scenario,
which, according to company spokesman Marco Castellaneta, was foreseeable,
but 24 hodin is developing well. Analogies for behavior in the
Swiss market cannot be derived from this. This is determined by the
currently the most successful print title owned by Tamedia, 20 Minuten
mastered.
The additional difficulty lies in getting the company into the red.
not to cannibalize the faltering tabloid flagship Blick. Because
Blick is not a real tabloid, but rather one that is lost in the shallows of the
"serious tabloid" meanders, new newspapers must be created around it.
be tinkered with. However, publisher Michael Ringier, who attended the
publishers' conference last September, journalistic
Content should not be given away for free, seems to be his
Having overcome bite inhibition. What options are there?
Six possible scenariosDirect competition with a second commuter newspaper:
The situation
already existed for two years between 20 Minuten and Metropol.
This disappeared from the market in 2002. From March 8, the
Constellation under different auspices between Le Matin Bleu
(Edipresse) and 20 minutes (Tamedia) on Lake Geneva. Whoever
observes the reading habits of commuters, finds that 20 minutes is
is popular with all age groups and is no longer a youth phenomenon.
is. This has made it more difficult to focus on one target group.
Blick will be free:
A nice mind game from
Weltwoche media columnist Kurt W. Zimmermann. However, the
about 60 percent of the circulation (262262 copies) by subscription, why
so break these reader ties? What would Ringier have done
Blick subscribers as a replacement? Would the
free version, the Blick brand would be lost forever.
Ringier's "Neue Zeitung" project combined with free Blick: The
Blick subscriptions are converted into subscriptions to a new (whatever)
newspaper, with a free copy of Blick. About the "new newspaper"
has become conspicuously quiet. Boulevard would also have to be
and be geared more towards an urban audience. Because
the majority of Blick's core readership lives in rural areas and
has a relatively high average age. Among the common
distribution channels (analogous to 20 minutes), the mailing would be sent to a non
or people who do not commute by public transport.
Blick light: Analogous to Le Matin Bleu, the challenge would be to
to explain to readers the difference between a paid-for newspaper and a
a free spin-off (otherwise see above).
Abendzeitung:
This is a niche market. Since the mid-90s
years, no publisher has dared to venture into the evening business. A
concept, however, is available with Cash Daily, the multimedia
Ringier project, which among other things is planned as an evening paper from 4 p.m.
is. At the launch of 20 Minuten, the idea was rejected because the
morning generates too little topicality. It is questionable whether advertisers
how the retail giants Migros and Coop make the evening attractive.
find. However, an evening paper would offer the opportunity to set thematic accents.
to set: Business, culture, the agenda, processing individual news from the competition and so on.
Blick am Abend:
The Abendzeitung idea would also be possible in the version
evening view is conceivable, provided that the urban audience would be more
taken into account. Whether this makes readers more likely to return to the
parent paper would be left open.
The crucial question of how a future free title can be
view is to be maneuvered past, however, is not compatible with any of the aforementioned
Examples answered conclusively.
What the experts say
Josef Trappel, media scientist and head of IPMZ Transfer at the
Media Institute at the University of Zurich, describes Ringier's intentions as extreme
difficult. Picking up the commuters in the evening during the return journey,
he considers more promising than, for example, looking into a
free sheet.
Management consultant Klaus J. Stöhlker sees Ringier's "escape into the
free business" as a "terrible mistake", 20 minutes for "almost
perfect". A new free title would have to convey the joy of consumption or serve as a
Abendblatt are "hotly boiled".
For communications consultant Sacha Wigdorovits, ex-Blick editor-in-chief and at the time responsible for the concept and
Launch of 20 Minuten Switzerland responsible, decide content concept
as well as the financial strength and staying power of the new competitor over the
Success. Wigdorovits estimates the investment costs at CHF 50 to 120 million, including marketing and sales.
He believes that there is room for a second title alongside 20 Minuten.
René Worni
