Jürg Brechbühl, who has switched careers, discusses the reasons why, as CD at Contexta, he might want to step back from advertising and pursue a new career path.
WW: After a successful career at Advico Young & Rubicam, Spillmann Felser Leo Burnett, and now three years as Creative Director at Contexta, you’re stepping away from advertising. What’s next? Jürg Brechbühl: I’m taking a break until Christmas. Time to reorient myself. I want to fulfill a few wishes. For example, taking an Italian course in Ravenna.WW: Your departure came as a surprise. Now you can speak with a certain degree of freedom. What’s going wrong in advertising?Jürg Brechbühl: That can’t be summed up in a single sentence. I’m not really in the mood for that either. I’m curious about the next three months. I’m in my early 50s now—an age where I might be able to chart a new course for the last time. I don’t feel like I need to settle scores with advertising right now. WW: So you haven’t completely had enough of advertising? Jürg Brechbühl: It’s not that I’m absolutely fed up with advertising. The industry remains exciting. But a lot has changed in the last nine years, since I switched to advertising as a career changer after 20 years in the classroom. WW: What has changed? Jürg Brechbühl: Advertising has lost its social significance. It’s not considered very relevant anymore. People used to publicly discuss whether an ad was good or bad—it would get people worked up. Today, advertising isn’t even a topic of conversation among non-advertisers. In the past, advertising films often inspired major feature films in theaters. Today, commercial filmmakers copy new ideas from feature films. Advertising no longer sets trends. That happens in the new arts and on the internet—but hardly ever in advertising anymore. WW: Where has the passion gone? Jürg Brechbühl: Not everything has changed for the worse, of course. I also have to say: I’ve naturally changed along with it. It’s always a two-way street. But Cary Steinmann is right when he said, upon leaving the industry, that the fun factor had been lost a bit. When I started out in the «90s, we were able to work with more leisure, time, and enjoyment. What worries me is that, despite taking a tougher approach, advertising hasn’t actually gotten any better. In recent years, we’ve been treading water and settling for a certain level of mediocrity. WW: You were able to write copy at the highest level right from the start. What are some fond memories from that time? Jürg Brechbühl: It was great for me that, even at an advanced age, I was really able to learn a new profession from scratch. That was exciting. Back then, too, I hadn’t had enough of high school. But I saw a new opportunity in advertising—and I had to seize it. It’s better to step away from a career while you still have the desire to do it than to just let yourself drift into burnout. I don’t feel burned out yet. Once you’re burned out, it’s always too late. There are people who say, »Too bad, he’s quitting.« But maybe in three years people will be saying, »When is he finally going to leave? He’s not cutting it anymore.« WW: What are you already struggling with? Jürg Brechbühl: In our industry, you often work in a vacuum or a somewhat artificial environment. My wife is a goldsmith. In my eyes, she has a great job. She creates things with her hands. The very next day, a customer finds the piece of jewelry beautiful. And that’s not always the case in advertising. Sometimes you come home in the evening and have no idea what you did during the day. Although that might be a bit of an exaggeration. WW: What did your wife say about you leaving the industry? Jürg Brechbühl: I always have her full support. WW: What are your plans starting at Christmas? Jürg Brechbühl: Nothing’s clear yet. The next three months are meant to be a time of discovery: Will I stay in the communications industry, or do I want to return to my roots as a teacher? At most, it could also be an interesting combination of both worlds as a lecturer at Sawi or at a school of arts and crafts. I can also imagine doing something in the educational-social sector. WW: What motivated you to get into advertising back then? Jürg Brechbühl: It was a childhood dream of mine. Even as a 16-year-old, I wanted to become a copywriter. But back in the »60s, no one in that industry was waiting for us. So I became a teacher first, and I really enjoyed it. WW: These days, many people go through several careers. Why did your fascination with advertising fade? Jürg Brechbühl: Is it because I’ve lived out that dream? A little bit, yes. It’s like with many dreams—everyday business comes into play. That’s often tougher than you’d expect. We’re an industry where money has to be made. It has to be profitable, and sometimes the human aspect gets pushed to the side. WW: You’re considering a career in the social sector. Do you also want to examine advertising from an ethical perspective? Jürg Brechbühl: More like finding a greater sense of purpose in life. You can’t ethically scrutinize advertising if you’ve worked in the field for so long. Otherwise, something would have gone wrong. But perhaps there’s a more lasting sense of purpose in working with young people, for example, than in creating a great campaign. WW: As a teacher at Sawi, could you guide young people in the right direction?Jürg Brechbühl: One could try. WW: Why did you leave Contexta? Jürg Brechbühl: It just happened that way. My three years at Contexta were very good and exciting for me. We celebrated major successes not only with “Beck & Bondi.” A team has really grown there. Contexta is a large agency, and I think it’s absolutely right that younger people get their chance, too. WW: To what extent have clients contributed to your disappointment in advertising? Jürg Brechbühl: It’s too easy to say the clients are to blame. But you increasingly sense the mentality: “He who pays the piper calls the tune.” Economic pressure is leading clients to interfere more and more in the creative process. They write their own headlines and want to choose the photos themselves. Mistrust has clearly increased. Many clients feel that the agency is trying to talk them into something under the guise of “creativity.” For me, Migros and Swisscom are the positive exceptions—large corporations in Switzerland that still have the courage to invest in good advertising. WW: The famous 50 percent that’s thrown out the window… Jürg Brechbühl: Creativity continues to be pitted against market impact. Yet it has been proven time and again that creative advertising can actually sell better. Nevertheless, these prejudices persist, and clients prefer mediocre advertising. Klar: When they invest in it under significant financial pressure, the impact is inevitable. It’s also become harder to reach decision-makers in this field. There are more and more people involved in the decision-making process, but they’re also very afraid. The economic situation is such that many people have to worry about their jobs. They don’t want to make a mistake under any circumstances. And you certainly don’t make a mistake if you opt for the status quo. This has been extremely evident over the past three years. WW: Have you grown tired of fighting? Jürg Brechbühl: It would be far too easy to blame clients alone for bad advertising. Most agencies, too, no longer really fight for their creative ideas the way they used to—for the same reasons. There have been many new agencies, but the pie hasn’t gotten any bigger. The economic pressure on agencies has actually increased. Back in the ’90s, you could still turn away a client who lacked an understanding of creativity. An agency with 40 people can’t afford to do that anymore and often has to fulfill strange requests. Today, well-known agencies are producing commercials they would have been ashamed of in the past. But this isn’t just the case in advertising. WW: What are some good memories? Jürg Brechbühl: There were more good moments than bad ones. It was great when we could really bring a good campaign to life—make a film that resonated with the audience. Even more than recognition from the ADC, I was delighted by positive feedback from people outside the industry. That happened to us several times at “Beck & Bondi.” WW: What advice would you give to young advertising professionals? Jürg Brechbühl: Look to the best for inspiration. Interview: Andreas Panzeri