TV Heinz Margot presents the SF program "Bsuech in..." and a Migros advertising program at the same time. An inadmissible dual role, according to the supervisory authority, which wants to investigate the case.Migros' "Fanmeisterschaft M'08" is in full swing, and the major distributor is bringing its advertising message to the people on SF1 in the style of a TV show. The show is hosted by Heinz Margot and Lolita Morena. The two of them already presented a Migros competition two years ago. In addition to his work for the orange giant, Margot is primarily known as a television presenter, formerly for his quiz show "Megaherz", and for the past two years he has presented the summer show "Bsuech in ...", which he will do again next July.According to the Swiss Radio and Television Act, permanent program employees of Swiss television are not allowed to take part in commercials. However, anyone who works for SF only occasionally or as a regular employee may also appear in front of the camera for commercial purposes. The exact dividing line between permanent and regular collaboration is not clear in the legal text. "This is a question of interpretation that must be considered carefully on a case-by-case basis," says Susanne Marxer, responsible for the supervision of radio and television at the Federal Office of Communications.
At the same time, it is inadmissibleTransferred to Heinz Margot's situation, this would mean that the Basel resident, who works full-time as a landlord in Zermatt, could certainly appear in commercials. However, for OFCOM as the supervisory authority, other criteria are also decisive when assessing inadmissible advertising appearances by program employees. "The appearance of an employee in the editorial section and in commercials during one and the same period is problematic and at first glance inadmissible," says television inspector Susanne Marxer, "regardless of whether the person in question is a permanent or regular employee."
This will soon be the case for Heinz Margot. From July 2 to August 13, he will be presenting the show "Bsuech in ..." from seven villages in the Bernese Oberland. Shortly before that, on June 27, he will present the round of 16 draw for the Migros "Fan Championship M'08". The other rounds will then be held in September.
Swiss television is aware of the problem of Margot's dual role. "We have looked into it intensively," says SF spokesman Urs Durrer, "and have come to the conclusion that we cannot prohibit him from an important source of income." The decisive factor was that Margot would only be in front of an SF camera for the seven programs of "Bsuech in ..." in the summer. So far so clear, Bakom had already come to the same conclusion. SF considers the simultaneity of editorial and commercial appearances criticized by the authority to be unproblematic, "as the programme 'Bsuech in ...' and Heinz Margot's appearance in the commercial do not take place on the same day."
"Take a closer look "Regardless of SF's stance, it is clear to Bakom that the matter needs to be clarified. "The way the 'Margot case' is currently presenting itself, I assume that we will take a closer look at it, ask SF and, if this is actually broadcast, open proceedings if necessary," says Bakom's Ms. Marxer. The investigation is also in SF's interest. It would bring legal certainty to a delicate gray area. Heinz Margot was unable or unwilling to comment to Werbewoche.
If the National Council had had its way with the revision of the Radio and Television Act (RTVA), Heinz Margot's appearance in an advertising program would have been clearly illegal. The Grand Chamber wanted to prohibit not only permanent but also regular program staff from appearing. This provision became known as the so-called Lex Russi, according to which Bernhard Russi would no longer have been allowed to advertise for the car brand Subaru as long as he was commentating on ski races for SF. However, the Council of States and ultimately the united Federal Assembly decided in favor of the more liberal regime. The most liberal regulation is for local radio stations and local TV stations with small coverage areas. Under the new RTVA, which came into force in April, permanent employees - with the exception of news editors - are also allowed to take part in advertising broadcasts.
Nick Lüthi