Free newspapers As the number of free titles grows, so does the caution of media planners. Especially after the unsuccessful distribution of .ch. The latest commuter newspaper, News, must therefore also start with reservations.
Photos (from left): Josi Bauer, Peter Hofstetter, Monica Jäggi, Andy Lehmann, Frauke Potent, Sandro Prezzi and Dominique Schilling News, the fifth national commuter newspaper in German-speaking Switzerland, was launched on December 5. As a non-representative street survey conducted by Werbewoche in Zurich, Berne and Basel suggests (WW 43/07), it will not be easy for the newcomer to change the preferences and habits of consumers. The new free paper from Tamedia and Basler Zeitung Medien will not have an easy time with the media agencies either. In any case, only one out of seven media planners surveyed stated that they had already booked advertisements with News. "We will certainly book News, if only because the newcomer attracts the most attention in the initial phase," says Andy Lehmann, Managing Director of Aegis Media Group Switzerland. He is also eagerly awaiting the Mittelland edition of News, especially since AZ Medien has been up in arms about it. "The best advertising reinforcement is AZ publisher Peter Wanner himself," laughs Lehmann. Apart from the current publicity of News, Lehmann emphasizes another strength of the new title: the paper can be combined with other titles in such a varied and "clever" way that it is also attracting interest from customers, he says.
Dominique Schilling, media planner at Generation Media, takes a different view and criticizes Tamedia's combination policy. This is because News Zürich can only be booked with the Tages-Anzeiger, while solo bookings are also possible in Basel, Bern and the Mittelland. "I will not be patronized by a publisher."
For others, however, the absence of news has more practical reasons. "The fact that we haven't covered news so far is mainly due to the unfavorable launch date," explains Sandro Prezzi, Managing Director of Mediaedge:cia Switzerland. "We simply don't have any corresponding campaigns at the moment." Frauke Potent, Head of Print Purchasing at Initiative Media Western, expresses a similar view. "Our budgets for this year have already been finalized and there was no reason to reschedule at short notice because of the news," she says.
Conscious use of moneyFuture booking behavior is one thing - but how have free titles been managed in the past two months? Two media planners stated that they had never booked .ch during this time. "Advertising budgets are increasing again, but customers are more conscious about how they spend their money," says Josi Bauer from Starcom Adplus with regard to the unclear distribution of .ch. Everyone else has tried out the title, but no one can really assess its performance. "For me, the distribution is the real black box with .ch. The promise to be first to the reader early in the morning was not kept," criticizes Andy Lehmann. Dominique Schilling doubles down: "Since the stands were collected, .ch has lost its USP," she states succinctly. Sandro Prezzi is more positive. He has not yet received any customer feedback on .ch. "But according to an Omnibus study, people with a better education between 30 and 49 seem to have a particular affinity for .ch. "An interesting target audience," he says. He also considers the newspaper project to be innovative. However, it is currently trading below its value.
Peter Hofstetter, owner of Mediaxis-MPG, sees things differently. In his opinion, there is a complete discrepancy between claim and reality, both at .ch and at News. From the outset, .ch assumed 1.5 readers per distributed copy, while News even reckons with two readers. "These assumptions are so exaggerated that you have to negotiate hard. A page in .ch or News should not be equated with a page in 20 Minuten," says Hofstetter.
Speaking of 20 Minuten: None of the media planners surveyed had done without this title in the last two months, despite the new competition. "When I need to reach a broad target group, I always have good experiences with 20 Minuten," says Frauke Potent. Andy Lehmann has also achieved a strong response. Sandro Prezzi, on the other hand, has observed that the Tamedia paper is seen as a "trend medium" by customers and agencies. "Some obviously see it as penicillin for sick media plans," he says with a laugh.
But this seems to have gone to the heads of the 20-Minuten makers. Josi Bauer, at any rate, believes that promotions have gone overboard recently, which could damage the paper in the long run. Opinions on Heute and Cash Daily are even more divided. Some use Cash Daily specifically for the business-savvy audience, but then cross-media with online. Others have not booked the title for more than two months. The situation is similar with Heute: some consider the title to be established with a good price-performance ratio, others describe it as barely tangible, while others have had good experiences, particularly in combination with Blick.
Be that as it may, three of the five titles are still so new that they do not have any reliable figures. Does that make you more cautious about free titles? Most say yes. "I'm generally rather cautious about booking new titles," says Monica Jäggi, co-owner of Konnex. This is because it takes a certain amount of time for a new title to get to where it wants to be in terms of distribution and editorial content. "This can currently be seen with .ch, but could also be observed with 20 Minuten or Heute in the past," she says. Frauke Potent has also become more cautious. She is primarily approaching the free newspaper market with a "gut feeling". She also assumes that free newspaper readers will not increase with the two new titles, but rather split up. "I want to wait and see what happens, because there is cut-throat competition here," she says. From her point of view, a title has to establish itself first.
Josi Bauer agrees. With the growing number of titles in this market, she has also become more cautious. "There is a lot of overlap and it is still hardly possible to differentiate between target groups," she says.
Andy Lehmann is by no means more cautious. "The free newspaper market is booming and is far from exhausted. It would be wrong to simply wait until the fog clears. Instead, we need to make the most of the opportunities that present themselves," he says.
Markus Knöpfli