Fuss about ADC gold for Mercedes commercials
On Saturday, Jung von Matt/Limmat took home three gold awards for its commercials at the ADC Awards. The awards went to two films for Mercedes and one for Smart. Now, critics are speaking out, complaining that the two Mercedes commercials were produced by the Jung von Matt offices in Hamburg and Berlin. ADC President Jean Etienne Aebi has indicated that a discussion regarding the submission rules is on the horizon.
Jung von Matt/Limmat won gold for three spots at the ADC awards on Saturday. Two films for Mercedes and one for Smart were honored. Critics are now complaining that the two Mercedes commercials were produced by the Jung von Matt branches in Hamburg and Berlin. As Werbewoche knows, this fact was already the subject of discussion during the ADC judging.
The ADC regulations state that works conceived and published in Switzerland are eligible to participate. According to the call for entries, "conceived in Switzerland means that at least the CD or the team of AD and copywriter is Swiss or is clearly based in Switzerland". Jean-Remy von Matt, Mathias Stiller, Wolfgang Schneider and David Mously are listed as creative directors for the Mercedes commercial "4matics", and Jean-Remy von Matt, Denek von Weltzien and Daniel Frericks for "The Race". Jean-Remy von Matt is known to be Swiss.
The Smart spot is unproblematic in terms of ADC judging: "We developed it here in Switzerland," explains Alexander Jaggy, Managing Director Creation at Jung von Matt/Limmat, when asked by Werbewoche. "The two Mercedes commercials come from Germany under the direction of Jean-Remy von Matt, that's right." The submissions were made in accordance with the current ADC regulations. "Jean-Remy von Matt is not only a regular jury member of ADC Switzerland, but also a minority shareholder in our agency. He is also fully associated with the Swiss agency in the gold jury," says Jaggy. As is the case for all jury members, Jean-Remy von Matt stepped down when his own work was being discussed.
"I heard about the accusations that are now circulating on Saturday evening," Jaggy continues. "But no one has told me to my face that they don't agree". He emphasizes that the title "Agency of the Year", which JvM/Limmat was also allowed to take home on Saturday, is not only based on the Mercedes commercials: The agency has won 39 awards, 16 of which were precious metal. The gold awards are counted four times for the agency ranking.
When asked, ADC President Jean Etienne Aebi explained that, as President, he did not wish to comment directly on the discussion surrounding Jung von Matt's commercials. "All I can say is that we will definitely discuss the extent to which the entry requirements are good and correct at the next board meeting". He is also of the opinion that the two Mercedes commercials comply with the current ADC regulations. Aebi is currently unable to say whether the guidelines for submissions will become more restrictive or, on the contrary, more open: "That will be the subject of discussion".
Carole Scheidegger
The ADC regulations state that works conceived and published in Switzerland are eligible to participate. According to the call for entries, "conceived in Switzerland means that at least the CD or the team of AD and copywriter is Swiss or is clearly based in Switzerland". Jean-Remy von Matt, Mathias Stiller, Wolfgang Schneider and David Mously are listed as creative directors for the Mercedes commercial "4matics", and Jean-Remy von Matt, Denek von Weltzien and Daniel Frericks for "The Race". Jean-Remy von Matt is known to be Swiss.
The Smart spot is unproblematic in terms of ADC judging: "We developed it here in Switzerland," explains Alexander Jaggy, Managing Director Creation at Jung von Matt/Limmat, when asked by Werbewoche. "The two Mercedes commercials come from Germany under the direction of Jean-Remy von Matt, that's right." The submissions were made in accordance with the current ADC regulations. "Jean-Remy von Matt is not only a regular jury member of ADC Switzerland, but also a minority shareholder in our agency. He is also fully associated with the Swiss agency in the gold jury," says Jaggy. As is the case for all jury members, Jean-Remy von Matt stepped down when his own work was being discussed.
"I heard about the accusations that are now circulating on Saturday evening," Jaggy continues. "But no one has told me to my face that they don't agree". He emphasizes that the title "Agency of the Year", which JvM/Limmat was also allowed to take home on Saturday, is not only based on the Mercedes commercials: The agency has won 39 awards, 16 of which were precious metal. The gold awards are counted four times for the agency ranking.
When asked, ADC President Jean Etienne Aebi explained that, as President, he did not wish to comment directly on the discussion surrounding Jung von Matt's commercials. "All I can say is that we will definitely discuss the extent to which the entry requirements are good and correct at the next board meeting". He is also of the opinion that the two Mercedes commercials comply with the current ADC regulations. Aebi is currently unable to say whether the guidelines for submissions will become more restrictive or, on the contrary, more open: "That will be the subject of discussion".
Carole Scheidegger
