The ADC Gold Cubes for Jung von Matt/Limmat caused a stir in the industry. ADC President Jean Etienne Aebi has now announced a discussion about the submission regulations. Whether the guidelines will be changed at all and become more open or more restrictive as a result will therefore be examined. Advertising Week asked the German ADC what it thinks about these issues.
In our northern neighbor, whose creative competition has also been open to Austria and Switzerland since last year, the conditions of participation state: "The work must have been published or developed either in Germany, Austria or German-speaking Switzerland". The German ADC is thus opening up the field: it is not mandatory for a work to have been conceived in Germany, Austria or Switzerland. It is sufficient if it was published in these countries.
"We are more open, you could say that," confirms Michael Preiswerk, spokesman for the board of the German ADC and managing director of the Stuttgart agency GPP. "Our philosophy is that we can't close the borders in the age of the Internet." The German ADC's annual competition exhibition is also one of the largest in the world. Of course, Germany has a very different approach to Switzerland: the business volume and budgets are many times larger. The conditions for the German ADC cannot be transferred one-to-one to the situation in Switzerland.
Preiswerk, himself a native of Switzerland, is aware of problems with works that come from a network partner of a German agency, despite the ADC's open attitude: "It has already happened that German agencies have submitted works from abroad with false credits. If we notice this, these works are credited to the actual author."
Germany has also prepared itself for so-called fakes, i.e. works that were only created for the competition: "This topic comes up every year, along with discussions about what actually constitutes a fake. The boundaries are sometimes blurred," says Preiswerk. The German ADC has tightened up the relevant regulations in recent years. A first hurdle against fakes is a confirmation from the client, which the submitters must provide for each work. This should prove that the work was commissioned. The agencies must also provide details of when and in which media an article was placed. "The work is then checked in two stages: First by our office and then by the jury, which is required to check suspicious work again." As Preiswerk says, the German ADC has had very good experiences with this course.
Carole Scheidegger