The reason for the lawsuit is a Media releasewhich the SFF published at the end of December. In it, the VgT spot broadcast over the holidays is described as "maliciously misleading, unfair and completely out of place". The "missionary-like praising of veganism" is a disregard for SRF guidelines, as it is political advertising. The "tendentious, one-sided and reputation-damaging" images would also completely hide the efforts that Switzerland has made in recent years to raise animal welfare standards.
VgT head Erwin Kessler does not want to put up with the accusations: "Now legal proceedings are underway against the meat trade association SFF because it reacted to the commercial with a defamatory statement," he tells Werbewoche.ch (Request for mediation, PDF).
The TV spot, which aired 18 times on SRF 1 between December 19 and 31, 2014, shows various scenes of Swiss farm animal husbandry. In doing so, Kessler emphasizes that all the footage comes from Switzerland and that "much worse" images could have been shown. On the one hand, Kessler says, he didn't want to give SRF an excuse to reject the spot as "unacceptable," and on the other hand, he didn't feel the need to work with particularly extreme examples. "The quite normal madness is bad enough," says the animal rights activist.
Screenshots of the VgT spot broadcast in December
The "restraint" has paid off: According to Kessler, the commercial criticized by the meat association is the first to be accepted by SRF/Publisuisse without legal proceedings. In 2013, Kessler won an airing via the Federal Court (Werbewoche.ch reported). This time Publisuisse had announced that SRG had no legal basis to ban the spot. This, although the SFF as a "good customer" - the meat association is sponsor of "Giaccobo/Müller" - was outraged. For Kessler, it is clear: "There are no more questions left open as to why SRF so stubbornly rejected our spots and why it took two condemnations of Switzerland by the European Court of Human Rights before the Federal Supreme Court finally looked into this matter."
This is an accusation that SFF President Rolf Büttiker resolutely and unequivocally rejects in an interview with Werbewoche.ch: "Such an approach would be out of the question; my fundamental liberal stance would forbid it. We work with arguments, not with blackmail!" It is therefore not up for discussion that the meat association changes something in the SRF sponsoring due to the discrepancies concerning VgT-Spot. The complaint on the part of VgT is taken note of "with great composure". "We were already aware in advance that disputes with Mr. Kessler usually end up in court." The association's legal clarifications are still underway. For former Council of States member Büttiker, however, the political dimension of the controversial spot is beyond question. The dimension that would prohibit Swiss television from broadcasting a commercial.
What is certain: Erwin Kessler and the VgT will continue to make headlines with commercials. Even outside the courtrooms. As Werbewoche exclusively knows, the next commercial is already in preparation. It will direct itself this time not against the meat economy, but against the egg industry and punctually before Easter be platziert. (hae)