Newspapers With the changeover to tabloid, Blick is introducing a new advertising system - and often higher rates. Oskar Gasser, co-owner of Zogg, Kettiger, Gasser, finds the rate reductions that Blick is offering its customers as part of the definitive changeover to the tabloid format "stingy". "Blick will now have more full pages to sell, so Ringier could certainly have reduced advertising rates more," he argues. Jürg Siegrist, Director of the Swiss Advertisers Association (SWA), is also "disappointed". "The clients clearly expected more, because the publisher incurs lower material costs and the advertising client receives a lower advertising impact," he says. A linear price reduction would therefore have been justified. A reduction to full-page and double-page ads alone, on the other hand, is "simply not enough." For the small-format Blick, a modular rate structure replaces the millimeter price. One four-color page now costs CHF 28700 (-9.2 percent), two full pages (panorama) cost CHF 60500 (-10.4 percent). All other ad formats, on the other hand, will be more expensive: a three-quarter page landscape will now cost CHF 27800 (+6 percent), a half page landscape CHF 18900 (+0.5 percent).
According to Bernhard Weissberg, Head of Newspapers at Ringier, Blick was based on a McKinsey study with eye tracking. According to this study, small-format advertisements on a tabloid page tend to attract more attention than those in broadsheet format. He also knows "that all publishers who switched to tabloid and made massive price reductions regretted it afterwards." And finally, Weissberg continues, even Hanspeter Rohner, CEO of PubliGroupe, sees no reason to offer lower prices simply for format reasons.
Readers get a better view
At the same time as the transition to the new format, the layout of Blick will be revised and the editorial content expanded. In addition to the current affairs and sports sections, there will be an expanded service section with additional TV tips and horoscopes. The special pages on cars, computers, travel and rock and pop will be smaller, but will appear daily. The Weekend supplement will remain in a large format and will be enclosed folded - because of the giant puzzle, which is a hit with readers.
The Tabloid-Blick will be published as a stapled binding. This has the disadvantage that it can no longer be divided up for reading. "It's true, this is an issue for people," says Weissberg, but a clear majority still prefer a small Einbund newspaper to the large Zweibund newspaper. "Readers will get used to it," he says. Blick-Verlag also has to solve another logistical problem: The restaurants need new newspaper holders, the existing ones cannot hold the thicker magazine.
The switch to tabloid was obvious after the results of the May test run: 69 percent of buyers at the 3,000 sales outlets with both formats opted for tabloid. In addition, in a survey
75 percent of individual purchasers and subscribers considered the small format to be better. 90 percent could well imagine reading Blick only in tabloid format in future. And of over 5000 direct opinions expressed, around 80 percent were enthusiastic about the new format. In addition, individual sales increased by 5 to 10 percent during the test phase.
Advertisers, media planners and advertising clients have been more reserved in their response to the new format. Oskar Gasser is less than pleased with the small format. "Blick is losing its newspaper character and is then just a newspaper," he criticizes. As an advertiser, he doesn't like the smaller format either: "In broadsheet format, a whole page comes across as bulky, but in tabloid it tends to lose out."
What counts is the content, not the formatJürg Siegrist, Director of the Association of
of the Swiss Advertising Association (SWA) accepts the decision of Blick readers. "For me, however, it's still the content that counts and not the format," he says. He welcomes the modular system for the advertisements.
David Honegger, CEO of Mc Cann-Erickson, believes that the smaller format is better suited to Blick: it is a newspaper that most people read on the move. However, Honegger is surprised that Ringier needed a test phase at all. And as CEO of an agency that currently counts 20 Minuten among its clients, he jokes: "The advantage of the tabloid is that you can now hide Blick even better in the Tagi or NZZ."
Andy Lehmann, Managing Director of Aegis Media Group Switzerland, is not unreservedly enthusiastic about the small look. "I would have liked a larger tabloid, like the original Cash was," he says. But this way, Blick runs the risk of being compared even more with 20 Minuten. In addition, Ringier's move in terms of format seems reactive and exudes little self-confidence.
However, he finds the move to a smaller format logical and attractive for advertising clients. However, implementing the content is a "challenging exercise". "I believe that there will be a completely new newspaper, whereby the editorial team will have to radically rethink and rebalance." Readers are hardly aware of this in view of the "Blick bleibt Blick" campaign. "From this perspective, the big challenge for Ringier is still to come," says Lehmann.
Basler Zeitung: A page is a pageUnlike Blick, Basler Zeitung is only just changing its culture section to tabloid on September 4. The rate has not yet been finalized. "At the moment we are still working on the pricing for the advertisements," says BaZ publishing director Daniel Sommer. "However, we are currently assuming that the price of a 1/1 page in the broadsheet and magazine sections of our newspaper will be the same." A page is a page, its advertising impact is not reduced because it is smaller. Sommer: "There are also large and small television sets, without this having any influence on the advertising prices for
TV commercials." (mk)
Blick: The verdict on the tabloid format is divided, the reactions to the ad rates are clear.
Markus Knöpfli