The Swiss ADC dice have fallen
Awards: For its 30th judging session, the Art Directors Club Switzerland reviewed an even greater number of entries. And judged them even more rigorously.
the Art Directors Club Switzerland bent over even more numerous works.
And judged even more harshly. Is stinginess cool after all?With its public criticism, the
Since 1976, ADC, as an association of leading creative professionals, has had the aim of
quality and thus increase the efficiency of advertising. After the
The question that arises is: Is his work more necessary or less?
his judgment more severe than ever? Jean-Remy von Matt rates the work of the
jury as "tough but fair." And: "The jury system is one of the most
fairest I have seen anywhere in the world."
The importance of ADC increases
What is certain is that of the 1123 entries - only in 1995 were there more
- only brought one to gold status; never before have there been fewer. With
235 awards (10 silver, 46 bronze and 178 shortlist) was the
Award rate at the national creative championships by far
not exhausted. Pius Walker from the agency of the same name calls
Reasons: "A sparing use of precious metal shows the respect of the jury
in front of the submitted works. In addition, the Swiss ADC Cube is a
currency has become harder, and that's a good thing. We move
thus in the direction of the euro and perhaps soon even in the direction of the pound."
Only in the film category did the rain of dice meet the
House Rule Quotas. In all other categories, the juries showed themselves of
The thrifty to stingy side. "In terms of the number of entries
one might have thought that 2005 was a boom year. In
In terms of quality, however, the absolute highlights were missing, works that
also have chances in Cannes," commented Martin Spillmann of SFLB.
Von Matt sees it similarly and specifies: "There was hardly any attacking spirit at
the clients. Here lies the core for the current level. And
this is exactly where something would have to change." Markus Ruf, Advertiser of the Year and
Co-owner of the most awarded agency Ruf Lanz, makes
changes, especially among the jurors: "It's not the works that are
but the judging process has become tougher. Since the introduction
of the Seven-Plus model by Michael Conrad, ADC judges according to
international criteria. And they became even more radical this year
applied than in previous years."
Il nous faut les Welsches
Equally surprising, because crossmedia is on everyone's lips, was the
The meager result in the category of overall campaigns, which this year - until
on a few shortlists - was left completely empty-handed. This did not meet with
only Jean Etienne Aebi, who is also responsible for popular creative campaigns.
made strong. Markus Ruf proposes that the overall campaigns of
should be judged by a separate jury group, which, in addition, should not
also evaluated illustration, photography and design. "I find that
unserious, because the jury consists of people who are rather interested in illus and
photos than for campaigns. I think it's a blatant
Misjudgment that this year there is no overall campaign on the shortlist
has managed to get out. There were great, multi-layered campaigns
among them, which now count less than a funny
Junior copywriter application in general merchandise category
Sales promotion. This distorts competition and gives a false
signal." Pius Walker also sees the danger in the fact that a single
Group is quickly overwhelmed with the assessment of overall campaigns.
Also this year the level differences gave rise to discussion
between the awarded works in the different categories.
This showed that even standardized evaluation criteria -
ten, after all - are not easy to handle. Since the bar - also
significantly higher for outsiders, the process of
criticism from the outside as well as from the inside more and more often in the sand or is quite
behavior. Officially, the company is already satisfied with a
Shortlist Freestyle.
This time the creatives of the Geneva had double reason to rejoice
Rive Gauche agency from the TBWA network. With its TV spot series for the
Loterie Romande, they won the only gold cube of the ADC year.
unanimously and even more so in the king category. In view of
of the lean vintage, Peter Brönnimann joked appreciatively and
self-deprecatingly about the advertising mecca of Zurich: "The frightening thing about it
Is that the spots are coming from Welschland." The Lotto campaign
breaks through the repeatedly used promise that anyone can
become a millionaire, and rolls the topic from the perspective of the
personified lottery balls in a surprising and refreshing way. With it
According to the rating scale, the computer-animated spots receive the
Attribute world class. One may look forward to the evaluation in Cannes
wait. However, a brilliant result can be expected, after all
international spot stars such as Hansjörg Zürcher, Jean-Remy
von Matt, Jean Etienne Aebi, Martin Fueter, Frank Bodin or Martin
Spillmann rejected the decision. That she, of all people, as the most generous
of all juries, ADC Chairman Andreas Prokesch the
provided the sharpest ammunition for the generally stricter judging,
is not without a certain irony.
Who are the Cannes contenders?
Andreas Prokesch's conclusion: Since the Swiss advertising
international, it would have to be juried accordingly. Reini
Weber adds: "At the ADC of Europe, if ADC gold sometimes comes from the
Switzerland was next to bronze from ADC Germany, that was often pretty
embarrassing." He does, however, caution that one or two juries may be
had taken this a bit too literally. And so, in addition to the
Smirnoff campaign, the very good work for print products such as
Annabelle or Children's Cooking missing from the medal table. "A
a little more metal for newspaper campaigns would also have
Side effect of spurring the other publishers on a bit with this." From
which you can currently see either pretty trivial or even
nothing. For years, the Tages-Anzeiger or Blick have published the medal table.
dominated, now they don't even show up on the shortlist.
Which works have the makings of an international exploit now?
From a German perspective, Jean-Remy von Matt has a clear favorite: "The
TV commercial by Suva and bfu with the bicycle helmet has in my view
great chances to win international awards. I bet you 5
Franconia on a Cannes Lion!" Markus Ruf distributes his bets
a little broader and says pragmatically, "Internationally, only those
Work an opportunity that doesn't require local knowledge." Often
be they those that combine a product benefit with an amazing
dramatize visual conceit, which the juror from Finland in
understand three seconds. "Such candidates for me are, for example
the zoomed-in Statue of Liberty for Panasonic, the advertising damage cases
of the National Insurance or from your own kitchen the
Velohelm campaign and the Dolder teacup gimmicks." In addition
he rehabilitates some works that "only" made it to the ADC Switzerland
shortlist: "Even Cynar, the frame-shattering
Renault convertible poster and others may well score."
Luca Aloisi
