"You should never be satisfied"
Cannes: Time to Take Stock: *Die Werbewoche* asked Swiss advertisers what impressions they brought back from Cannes.
d'Azur this summer. Once again, the
Americans and the British, who are spoiled by prices and who are almost
shared all the Grand Prix and bagged the most Gold Lions. Their image
They were not the only ones to cement their position; for the fourth time in a row
TBWA/Paris won the title of Agency of the Year, and for the second time the
US production company MJZ received the Palme d'Or for the highest score.
But instead of reeling off statistics, Advertising Week wanted to hear from some
Advertisers and producers learn how they remember Cannes 2006.
be retained.
Alexander Jaggy, member of the GL and CD of JvM/Limmat, jury member at IAF Cannes 06
WW: How satisfied are you with Switzerland's performance in Cannes? Alexander Jaggy: I'm not a statistician, but Switzerland did well.
I haven't done so well for a long time.
The yield for Press and Outdoor is disappointing. The tips are
there, obviously at the expense of the width.WW:
How many lions did you expect for Switzerland, and which were your top favorites?
My top favorites were the bicycle helmet spot for SUVA and the
Claims campaign for National Versicherung. My favorite for
next year is the Amnesty International campaign of Walker.WW:
Which works have impressed you the most?
TBWA/Paris shows time and again where the journey is heading visually. On
The most cross-media work is probably currently being done by Crispin, Porter &
Bogusky. The British are still strategically brilliant.WW:
Which seminars or workshops have benefited you the most?
I have viewed around two thirds of the commercials submitted.
I only attended one lecture, the one by Maurice Saatchi. I came
unfortunately 10 minutes late and I didn't have the remaining 10 minutes
got it.WW:
Did the World Cup have an influence on the general atmosphere of the festival?
The World Cup was omnipresent. Practically each of the jurors represented
a football nation. If we haven't talked about advertising,
we discussed football.WW:
Why was the Cannes Festival worthwhile for you again this year?Jaggy:
It was my first time in Cannes. I would never have thought that
my participation as a juror coincides with the year in which our agency was awarded the
wins his first Gold Lion. Since I've been there before, I have the
Prize accepted.WW:
What are the Dos & Donts for advertisers in Cannes?
Come back paler than when you went there.
Hanspeter Schweizer, CD at Wirz Advertising
WW: Which works have made a big impression on you? Hanspeter Schweizer: The Guinness film. The Bangkok Insurance films.
The Man-Man films for Combos Pretzels. The posters "Harley Bikes for
Women". The Lego ad "Periscope". The Toyota film "Human Touch",
completely forgotten.WW:
Who and what did you miss in Cannes this year?
The Tiger Lillys. And above all Mary Woodbridge.WW:
What was the most intensively discussed topic?
Clearly football, unfortunately.WW:
What was the most successful party?
The Switzerland-South Korea match in the back room of the Irish Pub at 37° C with all the Swiss delegates.WW:
Why was the Cannes Festival worthwhile for you again this year?
Because of the multiple kick that the work gives, for their own work and hopefully for the customers.
Jean-Marc Demeulemeester, CD
WW: How satisfied are you with Switzerland's performance at the Advertising Olympics?Jean-Marc Demeulemeester: You should never be satisfied. Five lions
is an impressive result for Switzerland. The total failure
in print and outdoor (categories in which Switzerland has traditionally
is strong) is very painful, however.WW:
How many lions did you expect for Switzerland, and which were your top favorites?
festival like Cannes, I don't think it's a good idea to count on
for presumptuous. I conceded the greatest chances: Ruf Lanz with
the predatory granny of the Coop Bank, SFLB with the sexy nature boys for
Switzerland Tourism, JvM/Limmat with Fritz and Fränzi, the extraterrestrial
children, Wirz and his hobby photographer for furniture. At least there
I was right.WW:
Which works have impressed you the most?Demeulemeester:
Big Ad for Carlton Draught. Because I like self-deprecating customers with a
A love of risk. Bangkok Insurance. Because in these spots
I think this is a completely new way of advertising insurance. Instead of unlikely claims, they show the
Unlikely that nothing will happen. Equipo from Adidas. Because
Despite all the superstars in the spot, it was really about two boys until the end
on the mating ground.WW:
What tip for going out did you bring home?
La Mandela - a really cool beach where you can chill out after you've had a good look around.WW:
Why was the Cannes Festival worthwhile for you again this year?
Because nowhere else can you talk so casually with so many industry giants.
conversation. Because you get an infinite number of ideas on how to
could do even better. And above all: because you can hardly do it afterwards.
can expect to sit in front of a blank page again.
Mike Krüll, CD at FCB Leutenegger Krüll
WW: How satisfied are you with the Swiss performance in Cannes?Mike Krüll: You can never win enough Lions.WW:
How many lions did you expect for Switzerland, and which were your top favorites?
More on the movie. And unfortunately nothing for Leica posters.WW:
Which works have impressed you the most?
"Noitulove", deserved movie grand prix for Guinness. Absolutely crazy.WW:
What trends have you discovered/recognized?
The trend towards good ideas.WW:
Who and what did you miss in Cannes this year?
Me. I was on vacation somewhere else.WW:
What are the Dos & Donts for advertisers in Cannes?Krüll:
Complaining about not having won anything.
Lukas Schmid, CD Text at LangGysiKnoll
WW: Who and what did you miss in Cannes this year? Lukas Schmid: My team. I would have loved to have had my
first lion. And the Norwegian sweater. The movie theaters were like
refreshing every year.WW:
Why was the Cannes Festival worthwhile again this year?Lukas Schmid:
Because there is hardly any other advertising event where you can get so much inspiration in such a short time.WW:
Did the World Cup have an influence on the general atmosphere of the festival?
Fortunately, hardly any. I only remember John
Cleese, who plays a delicious role in Hermann Vaske's film "The Art of Football".
The reason why the term "American football" was used for
this sport is completely absurd.WW:
What trends have you discovered?
You can sense the fear of companies, in the age of hard disk recorders
and the Internet to lose contact with their customers. Brands
try to communicate with their customers on various levels.
network. And are more seriously interested than ever in what
think this.WW:
Which seminars or workshops have benefited you the most?
The Africa agency from Brazil showed in an impressive way how it is possible to
it can pay off to run an agency like a brand. And the
AKQA Future Lions, where student work was shown -
www.futurelions.com.
Olivier Girard, Chief Creative Director Saatchi & Saatchi Simko
WW: Which works impressed you most in Cannes this year? Olivier Girard: Toyota "Human Touch" (TV) and "Survival
International" for Tribal Peoples Rights (Press) and "To Do List" for
Lucozade Energy Drink because of their body copy.WW:
What trends have you discovered?
Humor is still the strongest argument. In press and TV: more sagas
and short stories such as Amora, VW Fox, Vodafone, 42 Below Vodka.WW:
What was the most intensively discussed topic?Girard:
Ghosts! Fakes! Real or fake? That is the question.WW:
Which seminars or workshops have benefited you the most?
Definitely "The Saatchi & Saatchi's Show Cases" with industry stalwart Bob Isherwood.WW:
What was the most successful party?Girard:
The Australians' party was really, really, really ... awesome. Martinez' Beach.
Frank Bodin, CEO Euro RSCG
WW: How satisfied are you with Switzerland's performance at the Advertising Olympics?
balance sheet looks better than ever at first glance. But that should not
the fact that Switzerland is not yet a leader in the classic
disciplines with a bronze lion and two bronze lions.
shortlist placements in film and two outright zeros in print as well as
Poster still has room for improvement.WW:
How many lions did you expect for Switzerland?
Even if my prediction in the movie was between 0 and three
shortlist placements with a Bronze Lion was fairly accurate, is
a real prediction is becoming increasingly impossible. We know for
Some of the works submitted are not even from their own country.WW:
Which works have made a strong impression on you?
273 Work.WW:
What trends have you identified?
No trend is a trend. The improvement in the quality of art direction is impressive, especially in Print.WW:
What was the most intensively discussed topic?
Switzerland-Korea.WW:
What was the most successful party?
The Cinecom party, which is organized together with Germany and Austria
was carried out - a multi-crea-lateral idea, which was a lion
earned.WW:
What tip for going out did you bring home?
Rent a car and book a hotel outside Cannes; Cannes and the festival are more and more a demolition.WW:
What are the Dos & Donts for advertisers in Cannes?
Dos: Work with pleasure. Donts: Pleasure without work.
Martin Spillmann, GL member and CD Spillmann Felser Leo Burnett
WW: How satisfied are you with Switzerland's performance at the Advertising Olympics?
comparison in the new Cannes disciplines. But I am also
surprised at how badly we are doing in print and posters. Disciplines,
in which we should traditionally be strong. Perhaps we should
we are more involved with the work of our neighboring country Germany
to deal with. Works that have been published in recent years dozens of
Lions and brought the country to the top of the world in terms of advertising. WW:
Which works have impressed you the most?
The movie I could watch over and over again - and I'm sure of it
not the only one - is the Grand Prix. The TV commercial for Guinness beer
entitled "Noitulove" (Evolution), in which the idea of "Good things
come to those who wait" is probably the ultimate dramatization. We see 50
Millions of years of human evolution told backwards in 60
Seconds. From perfect beer enjoyment in an Irish pub back to
Stone Age, Neanderthals, meteorite impact on Earth and the
extinction of the dinosaurs to the steamy beginning of history, with
a lurch-like thing drinks a sip of swampy broth and
spits them out again with a loud burp. - The beginning of the
Evolution of good taste. What I particularly like about this movie
the educational aspect. My daughters have been learning at school for years
Pieces of evolution. At one point, I have to take them over the
Neanderthals, another time about the Miocene or the Paleocene
query. No teacher has ever told them the whole story in one go.
explained, even for years. In the future, teachers could
show the children the Guinness commercial. And we fathers can then instead of
Check your exams - thank Guinness - and enjoy a Feldschlösschen.WW:
What was the most successful party?Spillmann:
Leo Burnett's, which was definitely the most sought-after of the week.
I thought it was very good that the Swiss, Germans and Austrians
have decided to hold a joint party. Instead of the 20 years
every man for himself. WW:
What tip for going out did you bring home?
I can only say that I have a bad cold: Never go to a heavily air-conditioned movie theater to watch commercials without a sweater.WW:
Why was Cannes worthwhile for you again this year?Spillmann:
A visit to Cannes is always worthwhile for the same reason - the
scale and thus to adjust the bullshit detector, which is located between
gimmick and relevance. As there is little
new product benefits to communicate, the messages are
always the same. Because this is the case, I am amazed year after year at how
Nevertheless, there is always someone in the world who succeeds in doing something already
To tell what we have heard in a fresh and new way. This is particularly noticeable in Cannes
when, instead of getting sunburnt on the beach, you want to get a sunburn,
tortures itself through an entire category of films. The hours spent
there have the effect of a prevention campaign. One
Prevention campaign against clichés, against tastelessness, against
banal strategies and loveless implementations. A lot is shown about how
you shouldn't do it. But now and again, how great advertising can be.
can. In such a way that it deserves a lion.
Urs Schrepfer, Managing Partner Creation Advico Young & Rubicam
WW: How satisfied are you with Switzerland's performance in Cannes?Urs Schrepfer: I think it's very good that Switzerland is not just
medals in the Direct and Media categories, but also
in the original category of Cannes, in film. In this sense, the
Year 06 more successful than last year and very satisfactory for Switzerland
WW:
Which international works have made a strong impression on you?
I found that the film category in particular was very popular this year.
was very busy. From works such as Guinness to the
Argentinean election spot for public awareness to the
Bangkok insurance spots, the level at the top spots was very high.
high (apart from slips such as "Knorr").WW:
What trends have you discovered?
Fewer and fewer little jokes are being awarded prizes. Or the little jokes
are being done less because it is clear that they are no longer done as often.
are awarded prizes. Rather, more and more ideas are entering the ranks that are
Trigger stories in your head. Or hit a human nerve. How
For example, the Axe campaign "Get a Girlfriend". Campaigns that have a
create a good balance to the sometimes a little too large
Post-orgies from TBWA/Paris. Another trend that started last year
has set in: More and more countries are getting involved in both film and
Print and Outdoor in the top ranks and break the
Dominance of the major advertising countries.WW:
What was the most successful party?Schrepfer:
The Switzerland-South Korea match in the back room of the O'Neil pub with the entire Swiss Cannes delegation.WW:
Did the World Cup have an influence on the atmosphere of the festival?
Of course. The French cab drivers were even less friendly than usual after the match between France and South Korea (1:1).
Kristian Widmer, Producer, Chairman of the Executive Board Condor Films
WW: What trends have you discovered? Kristian Widmer: Not everything that is true is true.WW:
Who and what did you miss in Cannes this year?
The fear of the future.WW:
What was the most intensively discussed topic?Widmer:
The love-hate relationship with festival accreditation.WW:
What was the most successful party?Widmer:
Thursday night at Bacon: The Big Easy.WW:
Why was the Cannes Festival worthwhile for you again this year?Widmer:
Cannes shows the whole life from A to B.
Ernst Wirz, Director Wirz&Fraefel Productions AG
WW: How satisfied are you with Switzerland's performance at the Advertising Olympics?
Shortlist nomination a great year, of course. Switzerland as a whole
it should be a little more.WW:
How many lions did you expect for Switzerland, and which were your top favorites?
You can't count on lions in Cannes. One can only hope.
Of course, the favorites for me were also the already internationally
well-known films: Mobiliar photographer and the World Cup film from Switzerland
Tourism.WW:
Which works have impressed you the most?
"Big-Ad" for Carlton beer. The choir for Honda. Guinness "For Those Who Can Wait" and 50 others. It was a good year.WW:
What was the most successful party?Wirz:
Switzerland-Korea in the back room of the O'Neil pub. Because at the same time the
France-Togo match took place, it was only with great difficulty that
(Thanks to Ultra Images),
to find a television on which the entire Swiss delegation could watch the Swiss match.
WW:
What are the Dos & Donts for advertisers in Cannes?
The dos are up to you. As for the donts: avoid too
rapid and eager clapping during the screening of your own movie.
Enthusiastic enthusiasm from six people from the same corner,
provoked in an otherwise dead silent movie theater filled with 1000 people
inevitably the ever-ready battle whistles in the Grand
Auditorium.
Markus Ruf, co-owner of Ruf Lanz and Gold Lion winner:
Click on image for larger view
The Cannes balance sheet
Five Lions and eighteen shortlist places, that's how the Swiss in
Cannes. A respectable vintage, even if the
classic supreme disciplines of film, print and posters are once again the major
Advertising nations Great Britain and the USA override all others
could. In relation to the number of entries, however, this year
an above-average number of advertisers from "exotic countries" with
precious metals fly home.
The bronze medal was a positive surprise at the grand finale.
Lion from Wirz in the film category. Switzerland therefore needs to
not only in terms of football, but also in terms of creativity.
to hide. This year, a good 120 Swiss advertisers had several
ten thousand francs to participate in the 53rd International Advertising Festival
to be there. The effort paid off in particular for Jung von
Matt/Limmat and Ruf Lanz, who both took home a Golden Lion
Bronze was awarded to Wirz, LangGysiKnoll and OgilvyOne.
Cannes Media Gold to Jung von Matt/Limmat with the "Size" campaign for Mini.
Cannes Direct Gold to Ruf Lanz for Blindenwohnheim Mühlehalde "Featuring Worldhits".
Cannes Film Bronze to Wirz for Schweizerische Mobiliar with "Photographer".
Cannes Direct Bronze to OgilvyOne for Volvo
with "Volvo Inscription"
Cannes Direct Bronze to Lang Gysi Knoll with "Emptying Postboxes", Swiss Post.
Interviews: Luca Aloisi
