Print A city split, as recently introduced by the Tages-Anzeiger, is not a suitable model for Bern, Basel, St. Gallen or Lucerne. "Advertising in the Tages-Anzeiger was previously of no interest to SMEs in the city of Zurich, as a third of the Tagi readership lives outside the canton of Zurich," says publishing director Rolf Bollmann. Since November 6, this has changed: the Tagi circulation (around 240,000 copies) has been split: of the five new regional editions, one split with around 50,000 copies is specifically tailored to the city of Zurich. It is intended to provide readers in the city of Zurich with even more city-specific news and thus enable the Tamedia flagship to achieve greater household coverage in the city in the medium term. In addition, primarily local SMEs will have an attractively priced advertising platform with less wastage than before - and the Tagi will benefit from an additional source of income. But national customers also have the option of booking the Tagi city split on its own - or, if necessary, booking it with other Tagi splits or even with the Züriland newspapers.this model is currently unique in a large German-speaking Swiss agglomeration. Although the Berner Zeitung also has a kind of city split, called the city edition, unlike the Tages-Anzeiger this is a mix of both Bund and BZ copies. It is also reserved exclusively for local customers. Will the Tagi model now be taken as a model in Bern? At the time, some advertising clients and media agencies demanded that the BZ city edition should also be opened up to national customers.
"No," says publishing director Franziska von Weissenfluh, "a change is not up for discussion." The reason is clear: unlike the Tages-Anzeiger, the BZ city edition with 148,000 copies does not just make up a fifth of the total circulation, but a good half. There is a risk that national customers will be satisfied with the city edition, which could significantly reduce the BZ's overall sales.
The St. Galler Tagblatt has been going the exact opposite way to the Tagi - since this year. In April, the previous eight SGT regional editions were reduced to six - and the former St. Gallen city edition (30,000 copies) was merged with that of Gossau (5,000 copies) and Rorschach (8,000 copies). SGT publishing director Daniel Ehrat justifies this with the fact that the three communities are growing together. Of course, there were initially complaints from some readers. "But these have died down in the meantime," says Ehrat. Advertisers, on the other hand, had hardly any problems, probably not least because SMEs from Gossau and Rorschach can book the new 41,000-copy St. Gallen edition at a rate that is only slightly more expensive than that of "their" previous split.
Split not an issue in Lucerne The situation is different at the Neue Luzerner Zeitung: splitting into a city and a country edition has been discussed several times, "but it's not an issue at the moment", says Managing Director Jürg Weber. This is because the Neue LZ already has a high coverage of around 60 percent, so there is hardly anything to be gained from splits. "What's more, readers in the city want to know what's happening in the countryside and vice versa," says Weber. So far, there has also been "no huge demand" from advertisers. This is because local advertisers who want to advertise in the Neue LZ can choose a special marketplace offer in the regional association. This offers a much more favorable rate (less than half the price of the advertisement). However, if the advertiser wants to limit himself to the Lucerne agglomeration, he is already well served with the Anzeiger Luzern and the Luzerner Woche, says Weber.
Is a city split on the Rhine knee an issue? After all, the approximately 100,000 copies of the BaZ regular edition are split roughly equally between the two Basel half-cantons. But Beat Meyer, CEO of Basler Zeitung Medien, waves it off. BaZ has only just launched a large print run in the Basel region, which can be booked as a split, either on its own or together with the main edition. "And a strictly political split is of no interest to either advertisers or readers, as the large municipalities in the lower Basel area are too city-oriented for that," says Meyer.
Tagblatt am MittwochThe daily newspaper of the city of Zurich,
the free newspaper owned by Tamedia (60 percent) and NZZ (40 percent), will no longer be published five times a week from November 29, but only once a week, on Wednesdays. The contract with the city of Zurich, which runs until 2015 and for which the paper is the official publication organ, contains a clause that allows changes to be made to the publication frequency "for economic reasons", says city spokesman Urs Neuenschwander. The fact that, in this case, it is the majority owner Tamedia itself that is harming the Tagblatt's financial situation with its Tagi-Stadtsplit did not play a role. "We didn't go at each other with lawyers over this," says Neuenschwander. The city had examined what it needed as a minimum option. The new Tagblatt concept fulfills this requirement. Neuenschwander did not answer the question as to whether Tamedia was being asked for compensation. After all, the city has to take potential concession income off its hands. This is because the fee that Tamedia and NZZ pay for the Tagblatt is dependent on turnover above a certain level. This limit, which by all accounts has hardly ever been reached to date, is now definitely illusory.
Markus Knöpfli