The Council of States wants to completely ban alcohol advertising on Swiss radio and television stations and in foreign program windows. This was decided on Wednesday by 22 votes to 19. Several organizations immediately commented on this: Schweizer Werbung SW, the Swiss Press Association and the Campaign for Media Freedom.
Swiss advertising
"Swiss media policy is a tragedy. While the Federal Council wants to allow alcohol advertising on all Swiss TV stations out of consideration for the EU's "MEDIA" support program for filmmakers, the Council of States is now putting the brakes on it with a general ban. This decision contradicts the RTVA, which was intended to give private broadcasters a certain advantage over the SRG.
Of course, this decision by the small chamber comes as no real surprise. As long as film funding and advertising are treated in the same package, there are bound to be disagreements. Spirit and money do not mix well. The opinion on the preventive effect of advertising bans is apparently equally inconsistent. The Federal Council does not believe in this, while the otherwise more business-friendly Council of States supports this thesis.
Everything will probably be completely different again in the next session."
Swiss Press Association
Media agreement: Decision goes in the wrong direction and weakens Swiss media industry
"As part of the implementation of the Media Agreement, the Council of States today decided by 22 votes to 19 to generally ban alcohol advertising on radio and television in future. Until now, alcohol advertising was permitted for private broadcasters in Switzerland. Swiss Press regrets this decision and doubts both the preventive effect and the feasibility of this regulation at European level, as attempts must be made to enforce such a ban by the federal government vis-à-vis foreign TV advertising windows.
Moreover, there was no need for this decision as part of the implementation of the Media Agreement, which is why the Federal Council had even proposed an extension of alcohol advertising to all providers (including SRG). The Council of States' decision will further weaken local media providers and thus also part of the Swiss economy. It is not clear how, in times of economic crisis and economic stimulus programs and in view of increasing media concentration, such measures will further worsen the economic framework conditions for media companies. The National Council will comment on this bill in the summer."
Media Freedom Action
The EU media agreement as an opportunity to restrict advertising bans
"The Council of States today narrowly decided in favor of a radical ban on advertising for alcoholic beverages in television programs aimed at the Swiss public. This is intended to undermine the RTVA regulation in force since April 1, 2007, which allows local and regional commercial TV and radio stations to broadcast advertising for light alcoholic beverages (beer, wine). The Campaign for Media Freedom regrets that the Council of States is in favor of additional advertising bans, thus further worsening the economic situation of Swiss private broadcasters.
The renewed discussion of alcohol advertising is taking place against the backdrop of the Media Agreement with the EU. This not only affects film promotion, but also means that Switzerland must adopt the more liberal EU regulations in connection with advertising for alcoholic beverages.
Unfortunately, the Council of States did not seize the opportunity for a more liberal regulation. Although it wants to contribute to EU film funding in order to benefit from film funding, it does not want to go along with the more liberal regulation of alcohol advertising. It is not at all clear why the current Swiss solution, which allows regional language channels (e.g. 3+, StarTV) and local channels (e.g. Tele Top, Tele Basel) to advertise light alcoholic beverages, should be abandoned. Rather, the media agreement represents an opportunity to give the completely over-regulated electronic media a little more freedom and to make the misguided RTVA at least a little more liberal.
A total ban on alcohol advertising for all Swiss television and radio broadcasters is tantamount to self-discrimination. Heineken would then also be allowed to announce the Champions League match on the German channel in future, while Feldschlösschen would be banned from all advertising for non-alcoholic beer on Swiss television channels - unequal treatment that harms Swiss breweries and puts jobs at risk.
In the discussion on alcohol advertising, the Campaign for Media Freedom is hoping for a more liberal stance from the National Council's Committee for Transport and Telecommunications (KVF). If no further corrections are made in the National Council, the Campaign for Media Freedom is considering rejecting the entire media agreement."