Nor was it justified for Ticinonews.ch, Il Caffè, Corriere del Ticino, la Regione Ticino and Giornale del Popolo to identify the man's wife as an alleged rape victim. This is the result of a ruling by the Press Council published on Tuesday.
In September 2010, RSI reported on two consecutive days in the program Il Quotidiano about the arrest of a doctor for an alleged rape. The website Ticinonews.ch then named the wife as the alleged victim. Other media followed suit. The Press Council then received two complaints: a relative complained about the reports from RSI and a journalist about those from Ticinonews.ch, Il Caffè, Corriere del Ticino, la Regione Ticino and Giornale del Popolo.
RSI defended itself against the complaint by arguing that the doctor had become a public figure due to an earlier sensational affair. It was therefore permissible to mention his name. Ticinonews.ch and the newspapers concerned expressed different opinions.
For the Press Council, the mention of the doctor's name by RSI immediately after his arrest was not justified. This was because his public profile was only relative and the current case was not directly related to the earlier affair or his professional activities, the Council stated. Nor was it necessary to warn the public at that time.
After RSI had already reported on two consecutive days in an identifying manner, the follow-up by the other Ticino media hardly caused any further damage, the Press Council continued. The identification of the victim by Ticinonnews.ch and various newspapers, on the other hand, is considered by the Council to be misguided. Even after the doctor was named as a possible perpetrator, the protection of the victim continued to take priority. And since the distribution of the website in question was not comparable to that of RSI's television programs, the other media should not have identified the alleged victim, regardless of Ticinonews.ch's advance.