Dignitas article: Acquittal for Tages-Anzeiger journalist
According to the indictment, Tages-Anzeiger journalist Thomas Hasler published a defamatory article about the euthanasia organization Dignitas and was therefore guilty of defamation. The Zurich District Court has now ruled that this cannot be proven.
On 22 February 2011, the Tages-Anzeiger newspaper published an article about the euthanasia organization Dignitas and its founder Ludwig A. Minelli (pictured). It stated that the organization was suspected of having assisted a double suicide for selfish reasons. Specifically, it concerned the suicide of a mother and daughter who had previously paid a special membership fee.
Minelli filed criminal charges against the author Thomas Hasler for the article, who had to answer to the Zurich District Court on Monday for defamation. The Zurich public prosecutor's office demanded a conditional fine of 30 daily rates of CHF 220 and a fine of CHF 1,500 for the long-time court reporter. Hasler described himself as absolutely innocent in court and explained that a guilty verdict would mean the end of court reporting.
Immense damage to reputation
The private plaintiff Minelli appeared in court in person and demanded that Hasler be convicted. The lawyer argued that the defendant had published a vague suspicion and thus caused immense damage to Dignitas' reputation. The defense lawyer, on the other hand, demanded an acquittal and explained that Minelli is now regarded as a pioneer of death tourism and is therefore in the public spotlight.the court followed the defense and came to a full acquittal. The offense of defamation was fulfilled in both objective and subjective terms, said court chairman Philippe Ernst.
However, Hasler could invoke a justification. His article was a truthful report on an event of contemporary history. In addition, the report was written in compliance with the presumption of innocence. Last but not least, Dignitas is a politically controversial organization. Hasler had also repeatedly pointed out that it was merely a suspicion. As a result of the acquittal, he was awarded compensation of CHF 6,500. (SDA)
(Image: Keystone)


