The helpless from media land
Instead of guidance, this year's Epiphany gathering offered nothing but declarations of helplessness
Instead of guidance, this time there were only declarations of powerlessness at the Epiphany meetingBy Oliver Classen At the start of the year, the only person who was able to keep this promise at the 5th Epiphany meeting of the Media Institute of the Swiss Press Association was Vorarlberg publisher Eugen Russ. And only thanks to the uncritical attitude of his Swiss colleagues. Their diplomacy once again prevented any serious debate.
What Socrates said in six words takes eight presentations, a panel discussion and therefore a long working day in today's talkative publishing industry. The official conference slogan was "It's the invisible values that matter".
However, the collective confession "I know that I don't know anything", which was also evident in the prognosticating presentations at the World Trade Center (WTC) in Zurich, was a defining feature of the event. Individual industry experts let it be known that they had certainly gained insights in the past year of crisis, but did not want to "just rub it in" to the competition.
Statistries and a politically incorrect "No comment"
For example, Publicitas boss Hans-Peter Rohner. The main sponsor of the networking event concealed his lack of concept with a PowerPoint presentation overloaded with figures. Apart from not entirely disinterested generalities - such as "the increasing fragmentation of TV usage improves print prospects" or "the prevailing industry consensus in terms of price structure secures the future of us all" - and exotic, non-binding statements (that China, for example, will become the second-largest advertising nation by 2008), Rohner's "trend analysis" offered little that was informative. The appearance of Switzerland's most powerful media manager became delicate when he responded to Karl Lüönd's question about the credibility of 20 Minuten's break-even reports with a "no comment" - thus nipping any discussion in the bud.
The advertising market predictions of Bruno Widmer, currently Chairman of the Board of the Swiss branch of Advico Young & Rubicam, were similarly uninformative. The fact that direct and internet marketers are increasingly nibbling away at the traditional advertising cake is just as well known as the gradual shift in global advertising budgets from North America and Europe to the rest of the world. Such truisms do not seem any more enlightening when they are repeated by Widmer's boss, WPP CEO Martin Sorel. Sorell's invocation and the discreet omission of the local market only really revealed the embarrassment about future-proof evidence and arguments that the most worldly-wise Swiss advertiser shared with his colleagues this year.
"The newspaper as a recyclable material" and other recipes for success
Against this backdrop, the only foreign speaker had an easy time of it. Not that the 30-minute commercial that Eugen Russ ran for his Vorarlberg media company in front of the 300 or so managers was uninteresting. On the contrary: the energy and consistency with which he has upgraded his provincial publishing house into a cross-media service platform could well serve as a role model for some of those present. This also applies to the in-house recycling of read newspapers, which for Russ are "also physically a valuable material" that should be handled with care.
It is all the more astonishing, even frightening, that none of the potential imitators asked the particularly obvious question of financing with such rosy prospects. But they obviously didn't have the courage to do so. Or the interest. Neither of these would be encouraging signs for the industry's third year of crisis, which began at the WTC. It will be interesting to see whether the intensifying competitive and margin pressure in 2003 will result in boxing gloves being used for a change at the next Epiphany meeting instead of the usual ice-cream gloves.
What Socrates said in six words takes eight presentations, a panel discussion and therefore a long working day in today's talkative publishing industry. The official conference slogan was "It's the invisible values that matter".
However, the collective confession "I know that I don't know anything", which was also evident in the prognosticating presentations at the World Trade Center (WTC) in Zurich, was a defining feature of the event. Individual industry experts let it be known that they had certainly gained insights in the past year of crisis, but did not want to "just rub it in" to the competition.
Statistries and a politically incorrect "No comment"
For example, Publicitas boss Hans-Peter Rohner. The main sponsor of the networking event concealed his lack of concept with a PowerPoint presentation overloaded with figures. Apart from not entirely disinterested generalities - such as "the increasing fragmentation of TV usage improves print prospects" or "the prevailing industry consensus in terms of price structure secures the future of us all" - and exotic, non-binding statements (that China, for example, will become the second-largest advertising nation by 2008), Rohner's "trend analysis" offered little that was informative. The appearance of Switzerland's most powerful media manager became delicate when he responded to Karl Lüönd's question about the credibility of 20 Minuten's break-even reports with a "no comment" - thus nipping any discussion in the bud.
The advertising market predictions of Bruno Widmer, currently Chairman of the Board of the Swiss branch of Advico Young & Rubicam, were similarly uninformative. The fact that direct and internet marketers are increasingly nibbling away at the traditional advertising cake is just as well known as the gradual shift in global advertising budgets from North America and Europe to the rest of the world. Such truisms do not seem any more enlightening when they are repeated by Widmer's boss, WPP CEO Martin Sorel. Sorell's invocation and the discreet omission of the local market only really revealed the embarrassment about future-proof evidence and arguments that the most worldly-wise Swiss advertiser shared with his colleagues this year.
"The newspaper as a recyclable material" and other recipes for success
Against this backdrop, the only foreign speaker had an easy time of it. Not that the 30-minute commercial that Eugen Russ ran for his Vorarlberg media company in front of the 300 or so managers was uninteresting. On the contrary: the energy and consistency with which he has upgraded his provincial publishing house into a cross-media service platform could well serve as a role model for some of those present. This also applies to the in-house recycling of read newspapers, which for Russ are "also physically a valuable material" that should be handled with care.
It is all the more astonishing, even frightening, that none of the potential imitators asked the particularly obvious question of financing with such rosy prospects. But they obviously didn't have the courage to do so. Or the interest. Neither of these would be encouraging signs for the industry's third year of crisis, which began at the WTC. It will be interesting to see whether the intensifying competitive and margin pressure in 2003 will result in boxing gloves being used for a change at the next Epiphany meeting instead of the usual ice-cream gloves.
