Thinking beyond the borders
The Future of Advertising: Communication is increasingly becoming synonymous with marketing. And reality is becoming the result of communication.
The future of advertising Communication is increasingly becoming synonymous with marketing. And reality the result of communication. If you read the same statistics I did in February, you know what the most communicated terms in Switzerland were last year:- Do you have a Cumulus card?
- For risks and side effects, read the package leaflet and ask your doctor or pharmacist.
- The person you have called is not available.
Since March 1, this statistic has become obsolete. Since the Alinghi victory, people only talk about port and starboard, and every housewife knows what a double sheet stay is. Since March 1, every second Swiss would trade the view of the Eiger and Mönch for free access to the Mediterranean.
Communication is addictive
And there's plenty of evidence that communication not only changes mindsets, but is downright addictive:
In Holland, a cab driver had to be hospitalized because of SMS addiction. On average, he sent 267 messages a day. That almost ruined him. In America, there has been a club of anonymous phone callers for 10 years. One member, a photographer, calls her voicebox every 3 minutes.
In Lausanne, a company fired an employee in December who had made it to 193 private
e-mails. Finanz & Wirtschaft complained in February that employees were chatting privately for up to four hours.
The secondary cell phone is also
such as second car, second home, second partner. There are consumers who belong to 50 customer clubs, have 42 credit cards, are subscribed to 39 magazines and receive 78 mail-order catalogs.
In Stockholm, since December, every day in the metro
1.4 million free newspapers distributed, although the city has only 750000 inhabitants.
In Thorberg, the inmates did not mutiny before Christmas because of the hated Birchermüesli for breakfast, but because they can only receive 27 TV channels instead of 43.
At the same time, we all have the old kindergarten fear that someone might take our marbles away. Today, we have more freedom than ever. But very few want that much. And more and more community is dying out. Mr. and Mrs. Swiss still go to Migros together, but take two shopping carts because they can't agree on one toilet paper.
In America, bowling was out until bowling alone came along. Shielded from others, the bowler now bowls alone - and bowling is booming like never before.
Our problem today is not too little, but too much. Buying and spending even more, learning even more, communicating, eating, drinking, living, working - having fun and loving no longer works.
Today, 50000 new articles are launched on the market every year, 90 percent of which disappear again immediately. Because after 115 years of branded articles, there is still no car that is bigger on the inside than on the outside.
The primacy of tempo is everywhere: food becomes fast, love becomes quick, the nap is now called a power nap.
Women are the new heroes
Advertising, on the other hand, has become sluggish. It has to reorient itself because the old images are no longer right:
- It is not men but women who are becoming the heroes of the new century. In 2002, more motorcycles were registered to women than to men in Switzerland. And Franz Carl Weber sells the Barbie doll today best in the outfit of a female dentist with a doctorate.
- Kids today no longer want to hear the story of the mouse, because it's annoying. They ask about the Dax and the Swiss Performance Index. I've been told that responsible parents today equip their child with a cell phone from the age of ten so that he or she is not isolated among peers.
- But even the oldies are no longer what they once were in advertising: bladder-weak buyers of Klosterfrau Melissengeist, modestly munching their Ankezieger in the Stöckli and solving the crossword puzzles in the Glückspost.
In reality, today we are dealing with colorfully dressed pensioners in the forever-young outfit of fitness doctor Ulrich Strunz. Tanned brown like Indian squaws, they populate the piazza of Ascona in droves with flowing white hair and bomber jackets. And it looks like tomorrow's world will no longer be the preserve of young deer, but a hunting ground for gray panthers.
No doubt, the situation of advertising is hopeless. But not serious. When Pope John Paul II on Good Friday again, out of tradition, hears the confessions of five faithful from five continents, I have hope that those who are responsible for communication being the way it is today will also go to confession for once.
First, the clients. Who talk about Customer Satisfaction and make everything disappear: Ticket offices and car washers, mailboxes and post offices, the Migros trolley, the dwarf schools in the Onsernone Valley, the fault service and telephones with which you could simply dial - and make a call.
I mean the pale bureaucrats who have two piggy banks and three cash registers inside. And who fear nothing so much as the impudent, masses of loitering private customers who bring in nothing. They hardly have any money in their accounts, live in rented accommodation, don't understand telebanking, but make transfers by hand, book tickets by hand - and are as bold as brass and complain about everything straight away.
You have to understand that more and more companies are signing up with Martin Mustermann. No more second-class people whimpering at every price increase. Either business customers only. Or reckon like Swiss, which designs the private customer for wood class on a small scale so that two of these fabulous creatures can fit in one seat.
Agencies should also be held accountable, as today the classic approach to direct marketing is like the father who sends his underage daughter out on the street so that he can finance the son's theology studies.
When you enter an advertising agency in Zurich today, you are greeted not by creative chaos but by the frosty charm of a bank branch. The controllers who call the shots there are distinguished by their ability to enter a revolving door behind you only to exit in front of you. In their mousy vestons, they look as inconspicuous as Mormon missionaries and are as cool as if they could spit ice cubes.
The women in the graphic, who always stare at the floor in the elevator, resemble avenging angels: pale complexion, black lips, ascetically short hair, ominous club feet, heavy gravedigger skirts.
The disenchantment of the worldWe must also question the role of the consumer: Is he really a king? Wise, just, sovereign? Does he really want to know whether the Happy Cow from Migros had it nice before it landed on his plate as a breaded cutlet?
Customers find child labor appalling. And yet they expect a hand-knotted carpet for 64 francs at the hardware store. At Tschibo, the 2 pounds of coffee beans for 2.95. At Franz Carl Weber, the leather ball for 6.75. Without being asked which little hands might have pawed at it!
And most customers look anything but regal, instead appearing meek, as if overwhelmed by the rhythm of the new realities: Log-in, log-out, log-on, log-off.
Science should also be sent to confession. Because it's making it harder and harder for us advertisers to enchant the world. It used to be clear to everyone why the Mon Chérie cherry tastes so good. The praline makers said it contained an original Piedmont cherry. Ferrero's confectioners explained that Byzantine royal nuts were crushed for their Baci balls.
That's what people believed - until the scientists came. They brought microscopes and test tubes. They weighed and dismantled every myth. X-any cherries were in Mon Chérie. They had never heard of a Byzantine king nut, the nut researchers explained.
Increasingly, advertising is also being hampered by the army of judges and objectors. A few weeks ago, a senator in Washington DC proposed revoking smokers' civil rights.
And an EU commissioner now wants to ban carmakers from any form of advertising, arguing that the desire to race is reprehensible. Seen in this light, it's a miracle that advertising still exists at all.
And surely it's only a matter of time before it's discovered that TV ads for sweets promote tooth decay. That ads for coffee are to blame if the heart beats faster.
Style groups instead of target groups
Advertising has never had such a hard time. But it has also never been so harmless. Just think of the Americans. They follow all the advice given in advertising and even buy mineral water that is "cholesterol-free. Because everything in the USA is labeled "no fat" and even Big Macs are available "light," Americans should have been floating high above the earth as ethereal beings long ago. But they do not
Or take the commercials that usually air on TV after midnight. Vibrating electric blankets, self-inflating guest beds in seconds, on which heavy men test-hop to the delight of the housewife: Wow - the bed can take us!
I think we finally have to stop talking about target groups, because we're dealing with style groups. Because it's more important if people wear the same tie than if they are the same age or have the same profession.
And we have to be prepared for offensive marketing. In other words, leading the markets by delivering superior customer benefits, by taking the initiative ourselves, by taking the risk of going our own way, and by forcing competitors into the copycat position.
Above all, we must allow the lightness of being again. Realize that buying has ideological qualities. That consumption does not satisfy needs, but fulfills desires.
And that services bind feelings of happiness.
Advertising is vital. Even if it will never be able to prevent conflicts and bring people to their senses. But it can build bridges between social utopias and normal consumers. And must therefore remain the driving force in marketing. It will never be enough to tell people what percentage of strawberries are in the jam. Because they also want to know who picked these strawberries and what stories are told there. Only advertisers can make Valerie Klitschkow read Dr. Faust in the boxing ring. Even make God the buyer of Toni yogurt and let Boris Becker be "in" again, while Verona Feldbusch adds her "blub". We need creative virtuosos who write so close to the truth that they succeed in selling the emperor's new clothes as haute couture.
Marketing must lead
Because it doesn't help any company to leave the customer relationship to mega-intelligent CRM software. Just as little as the illusion that marketing of the future can live on customer consent. If people only buy what they really need, our economic system will collapse within 10 weeks.
And if advertising is made dependent on customer consent in the future, half of all companies will file for bankruptcy. Because marketing must lead instead of follow. It must pick up the customer and take him to where he wants to go before he realizes it.
September 11, the Swissair grounding, the economic slump and the start of an unfortunate war have not changed that. But many things seem to have become questionable overnight, and nothing seems to fascinate us as much as the expectation of the worst.
If you could vote on the future today - many Europeans would be against it. And the age of uncertainty has also devastated the advertising environment. No wonder that never before have so many psychotropic drugs been sold in Switzerland. And that nine out of ten people have no greater desire than to return to everyday life, to normality, to news without the words Rumsfeld, mass layoffs, manager compensation.
However, scare stories have always been part of the advertising environment. And the content of the advertising has nevertheless remained the same: So it must go on. And it will continue. But: We have to create new contexts for a world in which nothing is as certain as the feeling of uncertainty. In the future, we will also need more respect in marketing and communication. Respect for what people feel and what really moves our customers.
We must learn to think beyond the boundaries of marketing and communication. Realize that the tasks of advertising have no beginning and no end. And we must encourage advertisers and allow laughter again, because no happy fart comes out of a despondent ass.
When I say advertisers, I mean the unpredictable alpha dogs. The lateral thinkers, the counterthinkers and the left thinkers. Who are never cool, but always on fire. They have to reinvent advertising now. And they must have the courage and the passion to keep looking at the world with new eyes, to mix new colors for the sky, the earth and the water, to create a new language, a new code and new contexts for this millennium.
We do not need to abolish the laws of nature for this, but only to make our fist wedges more efficient, to lift the prohibition boards and to create a few biotopes with species protection. Because the raw material - the creative human being - is available.
In the past, only geniuses were creative. Today, it can also be the plumber, because the new creatives no longer sit in the ivory tower - but in the midst of the bustling life. Just recently, I read in the ad of a Zurich hair salon: "We put ideas in your hair" - which almost tempted me to let Yvonne or Uschi twist a few ideas into my hair.
Messages on the meta level
The advertising situation seems hopeless, but it is not serious. Because it won't be enough in the future to tell customers how easy their car is to maintain. Instead, people expect messages that lead them on a treasure hunt into their own memories via the meta-level. At the risk of appearances sometimes mutating into reality. But with the chance that the cliché of happiness, reproduced a thousand times, will become reality the thousand hundredth time.
And because meteorologists have taught us that the flutter of a butterfly's wings can ignite a hurricane on the other side of the world, we should not underestimate the leverage of creative advertising. After all, scientists are still searching today for the rational explanation of why cows in Switzerland have purple coats.
"Consumption fulfills wishes," says Friedhelm Lammoth: Kaufhof store on Frankfurt's Hauptwache to accompany the "Shopping" exhibition at the Schirn.
- For risks and side effects, read the package leaflet and ask your doctor or pharmacist.
- The person you have called is not available.
Since March 1, this statistic has become obsolete. Since the Alinghi victory, people only talk about port and starboard, and every housewife knows what a double sheet stay is. Since March 1, every second Swiss would trade the view of the Eiger and Mönch for free access to the Mediterranean.
Communication is addictive
And there's plenty of evidence that communication not only changes mindsets, but is downright addictive:
In Holland, a cab driver had to be hospitalized because of SMS addiction. On average, he sent 267 messages a day. That almost ruined him. In America, there has been a club of anonymous phone callers for 10 years. One member, a photographer, calls her voicebox every 3 minutes.
In Lausanne, a company fired an employee in December who had made it to 193 private
e-mails. Finanz & Wirtschaft complained in February that employees were chatting privately for up to four hours.
The secondary cell phone is also
such as second car, second home, second partner. There are consumers who belong to 50 customer clubs, have 42 credit cards, are subscribed to 39 magazines and receive 78 mail-order catalogs.
In Stockholm, since December, every day in the metro
1.4 million free newspapers distributed, although the city has only 750000 inhabitants.
In Thorberg, the inmates did not mutiny before Christmas because of the hated Birchermüesli for breakfast, but because they can only receive 27 TV channels instead of 43.
At the same time, we all have the old kindergarten fear that someone might take our marbles away. Today, we have more freedom than ever. But very few want that much. And more and more community is dying out. Mr. and Mrs. Swiss still go to Migros together, but take two shopping carts because they can't agree on one toilet paper.
In America, bowling was out until bowling alone came along. Shielded from others, the bowler now bowls alone - and bowling is booming like never before.
Our problem today is not too little, but too much. Buying and spending even more, learning even more, communicating, eating, drinking, living, working - having fun and loving no longer works.
Today, 50000 new articles are launched on the market every year, 90 percent of which disappear again immediately. Because after 115 years of branded articles, there is still no car that is bigger on the inside than on the outside.
The primacy of tempo is everywhere: food becomes fast, love becomes quick, the nap is now called a power nap.
Women are the new heroes
Advertising, on the other hand, has become sluggish. It has to reorient itself because the old images are no longer right:
- It is not men but women who are becoming the heroes of the new century. In 2002, more motorcycles were registered to women than to men in Switzerland. And Franz Carl Weber sells the Barbie doll today best in the outfit of a female dentist with a doctorate.
- Kids today no longer want to hear the story of the mouse, because it's annoying. They ask about the Dax and the Swiss Performance Index. I've been told that responsible parents today equip their child with a cell phone from the age of ten so that he or she is not isolated among peers.
- But even the oldies are no longer what they once were in advertising: bladder-weak buyers of Klosterfrau Melissengeist, modestly munching their Ankezieger in the Stöckli and solving the crossword puzzles in the Glückspost.
In reality, today we are dealing with colorfully dressed pensioners in the forever-young outfit of fitness doctor Ulrich Strunz. Tanned brown like Indian squaws, they populate the piazza of Ascona in droves with flowing white hair and bomber jackets. And it looks like tomorrow's world will no longer be the preserve of young deer, but a hunting ground for gray panthers.
No doubt, the situation of advertising is hopeless. But not serious. When Pope John Paul II on Good Friday again, out of tradition, hears the confessions of five faithful from five continents, I have hope that those who are responsible for communication being the way it is today will also go to confession for once.
First, the clients. Who talk about Customer Satisfaction and make everything disappear: Ticket offices and car washers, mailboxes and post offices, the Migros trolley, the dwarf schools in the Onsernone Valley, the fault service and telephones with which you could simply dial - and make a call.
I mean the pale bureaucrats who have two piggy banks and three cash registers inside. And who fear nothing so much as the impudent, masses of loitering private customers who bring in nothing. They hardly have any money in their accounts, live in rented accommodation, don't understand telebanking, but make transfers by hand, book tickets by hand - and are as bold as brass and complain about everything straight away.
You have to understand that more and more companies are signing up with Martin Mustermann. No more second-class people whimpering at every price increase. Either business customers only. Or reckon like Swiss, which designs the private customer for wood class on a small scale so that two of these fabulous creatures can fit in one seat.
Agencies should also be held accountable, as today the classic approach to direct marketing is like the father who sends his underage daughter out on the street so that he can finance the son's theology studies.
When you enter an advertising agency in Zurich today, you are greeted not by creative chaos but by the frosty charm of a bank branch. The controllers who call the shots there are distinguished by their ability to enter a revolving door behind you only to exit in front of you. In their mousy vestons, they look as inconspicuous as Mormon missionaries and are as cool as if they could spit ice cubes.
The women in the graphic, who always stare at the floor in the elevator, resemble avenging angels: pale complexion, black lips, ascetically short hair, ominous club feet, heavy gravedigger skirts.
The disenchantment of the worldWe must also question the role of the consumer: Is he really a king? Wise, just, sovereign? Does he really want to know whether the Happy Cow from Migros had it nice before it landed on his plate as a breaded cutlet?
Customers find child labor appalling. And yet they expect a hand-knotted carpet for 64 francs at the hardware store. At Tschibo, the 2 pounds of coffee beans for 2.95. At Franz Carl Weber, the leather ball for 6.75. Without being asked which little hands might have pawed at it!
And most customers look anything but regal, instead appearing meek, as if overwhelmed by the rhythm of the new realities: Log-in, log-out, log-on, log-off.
Science should also be sent to confession. Because it's making it harder and harder for us advertisers to enchant the world. It used to be clear to everyone why the Mon Chérie cherry tastes so good. The praline makers said it contained an original Piedmont cherry. Ferrero's confectioners explained that Byzantine royal nuts were crushed for their Baci balls.
That's what people believed - until the scientists came. They brought microscopes and test tubes. They weighed and dismantled every myth. X-any cherries were in Mon Chérie. They had never heard of a Byzantine king nut, the nut researchers explained.
Increasingly, advertising is also being hampered by the army of judges and objectors. A few weeks ago, a senator in Washington DC proposed revoking smokers' civil rights.
And an EU commissioner now wants to ban carmakers from any form of advertising, arguing that the desire to race is reprehensible. Seen in this light, it's a miracle that advertising still exists at all.
And surely it's only a matter of time before it's discovered that TV ads for sweets promote tooth decay. That ads for coffee are to blame if the heart beats faster.
Style groups instead of target groups
Advertising has never had such a hard time. But it has also never been so harmless. Just think of the Americans. They follow all the advice given in advertising and even buy mineral water that is "cholesterol-free. Because everything in the USA is labeled "no fat" and even Big Macs are available "light," Americans should have been floating high above the earth as ethereal beings long ago. But they do not
Or take the commercials that usually air on TV after midnight. Vibrating electric blankets, self-inflating guest beds in seconds, on which heavy men test-hop to the delight of the housewife: Wow - the bed can take us!
I think we finally have to stop talking about target groups, because we're dealing with style groups. Because it's more important if people wear the same tie than if they are the same age or have the same profession.
And we have to be prepared for offensive marketing. In other words, leading the markets by delivering superior customer benefits, by taking the initiative ourselves, by taking the risk of going our own way, and by forcing competitors into the copycat position.
Above all, we must allow the lightness of being again. Realize that buying has ideological qualities. That consumption does not satisfy needs, but fulfills desires.
And that services bind feelings of happiness.
Advertising is vital. Even if it will never be able to prevent conflicts and bring people to their senses. But it can build bridges between social utopias and normal consumers. And must therefore remain the driving force in marketing. It will never be enough to tell people what percentage of strawberries are in the jam. Because they also want to know who picked these strawberries and what stories are told there. Only advertisers can make Valerie Klitschkow read Dr. Faust in the boxing ring. Even make God the buyer of Toni yogurt and let Boris Becker be "in" again, while Verona Feldbusch adds her "blub". We need creative virtuosos who write so close to the truth that they succeed in selling the emperor's new clothes as haute couture.
Marketing must lead
Because it doesn't help any company to leave the customer relationship to mega-intelligent CRM software. Just as little as the illusion that marketing of the future can live on customer consent. If people only buy what they really need, our economic system will collapse within 10 weeks.
And if advertising is made dependent on customer consent in the future, half of all companies will file for bankruptcy. Because marketing must lead instead of follow. It must pick up the customer and take him to where he wants to go before he realizes it.
September 11, the Swissair grounding, the economic slump and the start of an unfortunate war have not changed that. But many things seem to have become questionable overnight, and nothing seems to fascinate us as much as the expectation of the worst.
If you could vote on the future today - many Europeans would be against it. And the age of uncertainty has also devastated the advertising environment. No wonder that never before have so many psychotropic drugs been sold in Switzerland. And that nine out of ten people have no greater desire than to return to everyday life, to normality, to news without the words Rumsfeld, mass layoffs, manager compensation.
However, scare stories have always been part of the advertising environment. And the content of the advertising has nevertheless remained the same: So it must go on. And it will continue. But: We have to create new contexts for a world in which nothing is as certain as the feeling of uncertainty. In the future, we will also need more respect in marketing and communication. Respect for what people feel and what really moves our customers.
We must learn to think beyond the boundaries of marketing and communication. Realize that the tasks of advertising have no beginning and no end. And we must encourage advertisers and allow laughter again, because no happy fart comes out of a despondent ass.
When I say advertisers, I mean the unpredictable alpha dogs. The lateral thinkers, the counterthinkers and the left thinkers. Who are never cool, but always on fire. They have to reinvent advertising now. And they must have the courage and the passion to keep looking at the world with new eyes, to mix new colors for the sky, the earth and the water, to create a new language, a new code and new contexts for this millennium.
We do not need to abolish the laws of nature for this, but only to make our fist wedges more efficient, to lift the prohibition boards and to create a few biotopes with species protection. Because the raw material - the creative human being - is available.
In the past, only geniuses were creative. Today, it can also be the plumber, because the new creatives no longer sit in the ivory tower - but in the midst of the bustling life. Just recently, I read in the ad of a Zurich hair salon: "We put ideas in your hair" - which almost tempted me to let Yvonne or Uschi twist a few ideas into my hair.
Messages on the meta level
The advertising situation seems hopeless, but it is not serious. Because it won't be enough in the future to tell customers how easy their car is to maintain. Instead, people expect messages that lead them on a treasure hunt into their own memories via the meta-level. At the risk of appearances sometimes mutating into reality. But with the chance that the cliché of happiness, reproduced a thousand times, will become reality the thousand hundredth time.
And because meteorologists have taught us that the flutter of a butterfly's wings can ignite a hurricane on the other side of the world, we should not underestimate the leverage of creative advertising. After all, scientists are still searching today for the rational explanation of why cows in Switzerland have purple coats.
"Consumption fulfills wishes," says Friedhelm Lammoth: Kaufhof store on Frankfurt's Hauptwache to accompany the "Shopping" exhibition at the Schirn.
Gifted speakerFriedhelm Lammoth is the creative head of the advertising agency Lammoth Mailkonzept, St.Gallen, which specializes in direct marketing, and Honorary President of the German Direct Marketing Association. He has made a name for himself not only as an advertiser, but also as a gifted speaker and publicist. This text is a slightly abridged version of a speech Friedhelm Lammoth gave last week at the spring festival of Blickle Direktmarketing. His next book, "Changing Course in Marketing: More Offensive - More Innovative - More Creative," will be published in the summer. (sh)
Friedhelm Lammoth
