Children's newspaper The first issue of Cracks for Kids surprises with innovative picture-text solutions and a relative lack of advertisements After Weltwoche, WochenZeitung has chosen another favorite enemy. At least that's the conclusion drawn by the editorial entitled "Öhrli Bränding" in the Christmas special issue "WoZ für Kidz". In it, the consumer-critical central organ speculates that the children's Sunday newspaper Cracks for Kids (CfK), which was published for the first time last weekend, will probably only engage in "early branding" that endangers young people instead of serious journalism. "Much enemy, much honor", comments CfK publisher René Gehrig on this prophylactic, politically certainly over-correct warning. And: "We provide kids with a picture of the real world, and it's not free of advertising." In fact, three quarters of the 24-page pilot issue is editorial, while the remaining six pages are (still) largely self-advertisements. So for the time being, there is no reason to panic about brand manipulation.
In terms of commercialization, CfK is likely to remain somewhere between its competitors, the recently profitable 20 Minuten and the highly loss-making, ad-free Spick, for the time being. The same applies to the pricing policy: after the three-week introductory phase (see box), the fourth Swiss-German Sunday newspaper will cost CHF 98 for an annual subscription and CHF 2.50 at the kiosk. At the beginning of February, when Gehrig has completed his presentation round with the agencies, the 30 to 40 percent of paid pages (at a price of CHF 9,900 each) that are customary in the industry should and must be in the paper. Otherwise the air will become thin from the middle of the year for the new company, whose operating costs in 2004 are likely to be around four million francs.
From image to text to website
But before establishing itself on the advertising market, the reader market must be conquered. The original mix of topics and styles in the starting number gives us confidence. The exciting avalanche story, the upbeat interview with "Bravo" TV presenter Mia Aegerter and the comparatively critical pocket money report "Verschuldet mit 14" (In debt at 14) pick up young readers in terms of content and language where 9 to 15-year-olds are at home: in nature, in pop culture and in their own four walls.
Most surprising and convincing is the close interlocking of image and text elements, as exemplified by the "Wochenpanorama" news section. The comic collage, complete with explanatory footnotes and further Internet links, is probably one of the most innovative formats that news journalism has produced in recent years. One almost overlooks the Swiss advertisement cross, praised by its inventors as a real novelty: on the panorama page two and three, the four corners are used as advertising space - the layout inside then resembles a Swiss cross. And this is apparently still regarded in some places as a seal of quality for a quality newspaper.
Colorful and cheeky: For the age-appropriate presentation of information, the Kinder-WoZ (top left) relies on comics, while Cracks for Kids tends to use photographs.
"Snack reading for the next generation of consumers "More colorful, gaudier, the texts somewhat shorter, otherwise everything Cracks for Kids offers seems familiar ad nauseam. The newspaper, which wants to take children and their questions seriously, comes along with an astonishing lack of imagination: gossip, sport, multimedia and, for those who don't just watch TV and play games on the computer, a story about a current social issue (debt among young people) and a page about hibernation in the animal kingdom, on which there is so little to learn that any five-year-old would yawn. The so-called "news", which wants to be communicated in a child-friendly way, is already very gray: Anyone who explicitly addresses children who are on the Internet
should not actually be reporting week-old plane crashes. The usual adult perspective is consistently applied, and the newspaper does not offer any orientation in the jungle of information that would be so important for children. Instead of encouraging children to think for themselves, the most stale media trends are chewed over again. In short: snack reading for the next generation of streamlined consumers.
Christine Lötscher, children's and young adult book editor Tages-Anzeiger
"More comics, please "Manon: "My opinion: I liked the newspaper very much because it was very interesting. But I would add more comics because a lot of children read 20 Minuten (newspaper) just for the comics. What I would also change: That you choose the words a bit more straightforward. But otherwise I really liked it."
Leonie: "I like the newspaper. I also like the topics, for example animals in winter, elephants, cell phones or something about Mia. I also think it's great that there's a whole page about puzzles."
Frank: "An excellent business idea that I sincerely wish great success. Not least because, thanks to Cracks for Kids, I can read the SonntagsZeitung, SonntagsBlick and NZZ am Sonntag in peace. "Review by Manon, Leonie and Frank Bodin, CEO Euro RSCG
"Grade 6 for the idea, grade 4 for the implementation for the time being "The idea that the next generation will devote as much time to reading the newspaper on Sunday as
the big ones, is pleasing and gives hope for more harmony on Sundays. The idea of publishing a weekly newspaper for
Making children's books deserves praise and recognition. After all, all publishers have been complaining for years about the lack of young readers, but have offered no satisfactory solutions. However, children who pick up information in newspaper format at least once a week will certainly have easier access to this medium as adults.
It is therefore a shame that the first issue of Cracks for Kids is rather shallow and more reminiscent of a video clip than a newspaper. The mix of topics is rather poor, the entertainment topics predominate, the information topics are kept very simple. Were they afraid of overwhelming the target group? Strange, really, as Spick, which the publisher managed before Cracks for Kids, is known for its child-friendly, yet concise and biting language and sophisticated topics.
A somewhat balanced mix, a focus on the older children (the younger ones prefer to aim higher than the older ones) and a slightly more sophisticated language: Cracks for Kids certainly has a chance in the children's market - and parents have the prospect of a harmonious Sunday brunch.Markus Mettler, BrainStore
Innovative distribution channelsRingier in Adligenswil prints 90000 copies of each of the first three issues of the world's first Sunday newspaper for children and then distributes them free of charge. This is done on the one hand by the company's own colporteurs positioned in front of the nine media markets in German-speaking Switzerland on Saturdays and on the other hand by around 600 sales representatives
of Zurich Insurance, the second of CfK's three long-term partners (WW 40/03), as a customer gift during home visits. A further 2000 copies are available in Orell-Füssli branches. OF produces a children's book hit parade exclusively for CfK. The remaining 40,000 copies are distributed to newsstands in German-speaking Switzerland. After this initial success, publisher René Gehrig expects the circulation to level off "somewhere between 40,000 and 60,000". (oc)
Oliver Classen