Serious attempt to pair
Research: Funding for the MMXI Internet panel will expire at the end of the year. SRG and Wemf are in talks about future models of cooperation.
Research Funding for the MMXI Internet panel expires at the end of the year. SRG and Wemf are in talks about future cooperation models. Internet research in Switzerland has so far been conducted on two tracks: Wemf uses Net Audit to count visits to websites and surveys around 2,000 people for the MA Comis study. MMXI Switzerland operates a panel plus the Konso study with over 40,000 interviews. The five-year contract between MMXI's financial backers can now be terminated for the first time at the end of the year. The main client and main investor is the SRG Research Service, other investors are the SRG Directorate General, Publisuisse, Swiss TXT, IP Multimedia (Switzerland), Banner.ch, the Yellowworld.ch postal portal and Espace Media Groupe. These have financed MMXI research with CHF 2.4 million annually since 2001.
According to Manuel Dähler, Head of the SRG Research Service, no resignations have yet been received. However, he confirms that the future of internet research in Switzerland is currently the subject of intense discussion. He is in charge of this. "We are in the process of evaluating various options from 2006," says Dähler. The following options are under discussion: continue with the current research (panel), expand the existing system or make a change. According to Dähler, one thing is certain: "The demands on online research today are higher than what the current panel is currently able to offer." The question of future funding also needs to be clarified.
The considerations in Switzerland are based on the three-pillar model of the Arbeitsgemeinschaft Onlineforschung (AGOF) in Germany (see box). If this model is followed, a merger of MMXI Switzerland and Wemf could be in the offing for Internet research in Switzerland. Both Dähler and Wemf Director René Schmutz confirm talks. "We are talking to each other," says Dähler. "We are clarifying whether we can get something clever off the ground together," adds Schmutz.
Solution by mid-year
It would be technically possible to merge the MMXI data with that of Net Audit, and both tools are well established internationally. They also have considerable customer numbers in Switzerland. And finally, Net Audit is envisaged as the second pillar of the AGOF model. However, the MMXI data does not fit into the AGOF model because it comes from a panel and not from an on-site survey. The opportunity to develop an international currency at the same time would therefore be lost with the MMXI data.
It would therefore also be conceivable to move away from the MMXI panel, which today belongs to Nielsen/Netratings, towards an on-site survey, as offered by the German company Infratest. However, this would mean sacrificing the five-year history of the MMXI panel.
No decision has been made yet. "There are currently three systems that link site-centric and user-centric data," says Dähler. The Dutch company Netstat, TNR Infratest and Nielsen/Netratings have submitted offers to Dähler. He is confident that a solution can be found by the middle of the year.
"Higher demands today": Manuel Dähler, Head of SRG Research Service.
"Doing something good together". René Schmutz, Wemf.
The AGOF modelIn order to establish a standardized currency for online reach on the German market, AGOF relies on a three-pillar model. An on-site survey using an online questionnaire (user-centric) forms the first pillar, the measurement of visits to websites (site-centric) forms the second and a representative telephone survey forms the third pillar.
Each of these pillars alone only provides an incomplete picture of internet usage: The site-centric measurement identifies the computers from which the websites are accessed, but not the individual users. The on-site survey only partially solves this problem, but it does provide socio-demographic data on some users. And the telephone survey only provides summary recall values, but also socio-demographic data.
Only through the interaction
of all three pillars, it is possible to determine the reach and structural data of online advertising media, according to www.agof.de. And this is how it works: The data from the on-site survey and the technical measurement are compared to filter out those users for whom data from both surveys is available. From this, so-called "ideal-typical user profiles" are created. Their socio-demographic data can then be projected according to the principle of similarity onto those users for whom only the technical data is available. Finally, all this information is transferred to the population as a whole thanks to the telephone survey.
Markus Knöpfli
According to Manuel Dähler, Head of the SRG Research Service, no resignations have yet been received. However, he confirms that the future of internet research in Switzerland is currently the subject of intense discussion. He is in charge of this. "We are in the process of evaluating various options from 2006," says Dähler. The following options are under discussion: continue with the current research (panel), expand the existing system or make a change. According to Dähler, one thing is certain: "The demands on online research today are higher than what the current panel is currently able to offer." The question of future funding also needs to be clarified.
The considerations in Switzerland are based on the three-pillar model of the Arbeitsgemeinschaft Onlineforschung (AGOF) in Germany (see box). If this model is followed, a merger of MMXI Switzerland and Wemf could be in the offing for Internet research in Switzerland. Both Dähler and Wemf Director René Schmutz confirm talks. "We are talking to each other," says Dähler. "We are clarifying whether we can get something clever off the ground together," adds Schmutz.
Solution by mid-year
It would be technically possible to merge the MMXI data with that of Net Audit, and both tools are well established internationally. They also have considerable customer numbers in Switzerland. And finally, Net Audit is envisaged as the second pillar of the AGOF model. However, the MMXI data does not fit into the AGOF model because it comes from a panel and not from an on-site survey. The opportunity to develop an international currency at the same time would therefore be lost with the MMXI data.
It would therefore also be conceivable to move away from the MMXI panel, which today belongs to Nielsen/Netratings, towards an on-site survey, as offered by the German company Infratest. However, this would mean sacrificing the five-year history of the MMXI panel.
No decision has been made yet. "There are currently three systems that link site-centric and user-centric data," says Dähler. The Dutch company Netstat, TNR Infratest and Nielsen/Netratings have submitted offers to Dähler. He is confident that a solution can be found by the middle of the year.
"Higher demands today": Manuel Dähler, Head of SRG Research Service.
"Doing something good together". René Schmutz, Wemf.
The AGOF modelIn order to establish a standardized currency for online reach on the German market, AGOF relies on a three-pillar model. An on-site survey using an online questionnaire (user-centric) forms the first pillar, the measurement of visits to websites (site-centric) forms the second and a representative telephone survey forms the third pillar.
Each of these pillars alone only provides an incomplete picture of internet usage: The site-centric measurement identifies the computers from which the websites are accessed, but not the individual users. The on-site survey only partially solves this problem, but it does provide socio-demographic data on some users. And the telephone survey only provides summary recall values, but also socio-demographic data.
Only through the interaction
of all three pillars, it is possible to determine the reach and structural data of online advertising media, according to www.agof.de. And this is how it works: The data from the on-site survey and the technical measurement are compared to filter out those users for whom data from both surveys is available. From this, so-called "ideal-typical user profiles" are created. Their socio-demographic data can then be projected according to the principle of similarity onto those users for whom only the technical data is available. Finally, all this information is transferred to the population as a whole thanks to the telephone survey.
Markus Knöpfli
