Is branded entertainment coming?
In 2005, Euro RSCG won the Goldbach Media Group Award for its successful, integrated campaign for PostMail. The question is: Who will take home the Crossmedia Award 06?
electronic off- and online media Goldbach Media last year, a
award, which it has introduced for advertising clients and agencies.
for networking a communication idea across different media
wants to win. Using various studies and case studies, she shows
that cross-media campaigns can lead to an in-depth, interactive
experience of a brand or an offer and thus for the
create added value for the target group. So not only the
High-impact, networked campaign "Great things start with a letter"
will still have fond memories of the finalists. The finalists such as Dove
or Feldschlösschen beer have set the benchmark for their successors.
set high.
Although cross-media is a key factor due to the involvement-generating implementations in
the various media is primarily a task in the creative sense. The
However, the invitation to tender is aimed at a broader group of people
Marketing and communication - i.e. planners, consulting teams, agencies,
customers and clients. The award will be presented at the Mediarena on 17.
May. However, before the jury has even finished the - by the closing date
of April 11 - was to be judged by the Advertising Week.
from university of applied sciences lecturer Stefan Gürtler to find out how the
discipline and its potential in Switzerland.
WW: What were the most creative cross-media concepts for you last year?Stefan Gürtler: Perhaps 2005 was not the year of the
Cross-media campaigns, perhaps we have already become cross-media snobs
with exaggerated claims. I really noticed
There is only one campaign - the "Mary Woodbridge" campaign from Mammut.
WW:
And what was particularly winning or intelligent about this?
The intelligent thing about this is that the campaign is - at least
was co-designed by the active part. The communication costs -
planning, logistics and content - are partly or fully financed by the broadcaster.
to the recipients. This requires content with which
want to engage the recipients. On the campaign theme, dilettantism
and overconfidence when climbing Everest, and that is the
second intelligent person to Mary Woodbridge, this was obviously the case.
WW:
With cross-media strategies, isn't there often the danger of
Because of the fascinating projects, it is easy to lose sight of the goal
loses, because one assumes a very high level of media competence and
Gürtler:
The short-term effects of cross-media strategies - multiplying and
transfer effect - have been researched since 1967 and are considered certain.
An ongoing study by our institute also shows a trend that
integrated communication has a positive effect on awareness,
corporate image and business success compared to the rest of the industry.
At least in terms of short-term success, that is what
clarity. It is equally clear, and I agree with you, that
many campaigns are based on false assumptions regarding the probability of media use and involvement and hardly
can be successful.
WW: The
Projects usually aim to generate hype by means of viral
measures, events and the like. If the target group of
30+ win at all?Gürtler:
As long as projects are designed to absorb young media nomads
or to make the self-presentation of the participants the content, such as
the current campaigns of Swisslife or Peugeot, they will have trouble
to reach the 30+ target group. In principle, there are
Cross-media campaigns, however, are not an age guillotine, on the contrary: older
Target groups have a more consolidated so-called relevant set
media through which they can be reached. On this basis, the
Probability of media use in this age segment rather
predictable and campaigns therefore easier to plan.
WW:
I argue that sustainable cross-media campaigns are not possible because of the
additional costs in creation, media and logistics are similarly high.
budget than conventional campaigns with direct marketing as
Interaction tool. Does the price argument speak for cross-media at all?
Concepts?Gürtler:
A good cross-media campaign must be interactive and individualized,
be consistent in terms of content and so on - which thus
The associated complexity costs make cross-media a trend towards
expensive form of marketing. Forms such as the aforementioned
Mary Woodbridge campaign are therefore also a cost alternative because
they reduce complexity on the transmitter side and
Include recipients' own contributions.
WW:
We often hear the criticism - especially from creatives - that
Advertising clients only prefer cross-media strategies because
they are primarily looking for the lowest possible GRP price and therefore
very much like to use below-the-line media. What do you think of this
Reservation?Gürtler:
It is rational behavior in complex situations such as
of a cross-media campaign on the basis of the few reliable figures
and that is the cost. Regardless of this, if you look at the
marginal costs of traditional advertising, then it makes sense, especially with
larger campaigns, it makes sense to invest part of the budget in below-the-line
invest.
WW:
Under what circumstances can it become too much for users to choose from all
channels to be bombarded with the same advertising message?
If cross-media is misunderstood and is nothing more than the
Pushing an advertisement through all channels. Used correctly
Crossmedia is exactly the opposite - the media-compatible adaptation of the
message to the usage and activation needs of the
Media target groups.
WW:
Will the combination of traditional and new advertising media soon be exhausted?Gürtler:
New media technologies, increasing media convergence and changing
Media usage behavior is constantly changing for cross-media.
create starting situations. This will always lead to a
short-term overvaluation and overutilization of channels or shapes
currently no cross-media campaign seems to be possible without podcasts.
to get by. But I don't believe in exhaustion. Special
I see potential for development in "branded entertainment" or "brand
casting" - the combination of media entertainment formats with the
Company or product presentation and supplementary communication.
Stefan Gürtler is a lecturer and deputy head of the
Head of the Institute for Corporate Communications at the University of Applied Sciences
Northwestern Switzerland in Olten.
Interview: Luca Aloisi
