Print The new Nordostschweiz association of Thurgauer Zeitung and Landbote is open to the Schaffhauser Nachrichten, but at the same time leaves it on the sidelines.The new Nordostschweiz association of the two newspapers Thurgauer Zeitung (TZ) and Landbote is an interesting construct. Unlike the three Züriland newspapers, the two titles manage without a joint company. The publishers Ziegler Druck und Verlag in Winterthur and Huber & Co in Frauenfeld have shared the joint tasks. The Landbote will take over responsibility for the editorial work, while the joint publishing activities will be handled in Frauenfeld. "The co-determination is regulated in such a way that each partner can exert influence in both areas," says Urs Lüdi, company director of Huber & Co. Nevertheless, the lead lies more with the Tamedia subsidiary Thurgauer Medien, as it will hold all the revenue in its hands in future with subscription management and advertising business. Or to put it another way: Landbote, in which Tamedia holds a 20 percent stake, is becoming heavily dependent on Zurich.
The aim of the new alliance is to "keep the two newspapers fit in the long term", says Lüdi. This is not surprising, as the merger had been on the cards for some time. However, the actual structure of the alliance is so contradictory that it will hardly bring any financial added value, at least in the medium term. The joint presence in the advertising market already existed in the past, simply under the name Kombi 1a. Some synergies and cost savings will now be added - a total of 3.2 jobs will be cut.
At the same time, however, TZ and Landbote are also reducing the combined rate from 8 to 15 percent as of April 1, 2007. This is intended to increase volumes, but will initially only reduce revenues. This is all the more so because both publishers first have to invest in a new advertising department in Frauenfeld. This also costs time and money. Both publishers have hardly any experience or contacts in the national advertising market. The TZ has only been fully under its own management for a few days, and the Landbote will remain under a full P lease for another year, after which it will switch to the full lease of the Tamedia subsidiary Thurgauer Medien, so to speak. The latter will then have to prove its worth.
The lowering of the tried-and-tested combined rate thus shows: Because the two publishers still lack contacts to the national market, they have to draw attention to themselves with a more favorable CPM. Especially as Verbund Nordostschweiz, with a total of 78,000 copies, remains a lightweight from a national perspective.
Keeping the doors openLothar Dostal, Managing Director of Ziegler Druck, and Lüdi are also aware of this, which is why they both emphasize that they are keeping the doors of their association wide open for the Schaffhauser Nachrichten (SN). Because only with the SN would the new association exceed the circulation limit of 100,000 copies. A year ago, the SN was included in the talks about the alliance, but soon pulled out again. "We don't want to produce a newspaper that looks the same as TZ and Landbote," says SN editor-in-chief and publisher Norbert Neininger. In addition, the SN printing plant would be overwhelmed with a 4-bundle newspaper. But precisely because Dostal and Lüdi are aware of Neininger's striving for independence, they deliberately designed the new association in such a way that it does not require a joint subsidiary - as a gesture of goodwill and with a view to the future, so to speak. They are also maintaining Combi 1b, which includes SN.
Nevertheless, they are also behaving contradictorily towards SN. For example, the tariff reduction at Nordostschweiz (Kombi 1a) was not agreed with Neininger, although Kombi 1b, to which SN also belongs, is based on it. It is now unclear whether Kombi 1b will retain its tariff or whether it will be reduced in line with Kombi 1a. Either way, SN must expect a loss of revenue. Although surprised by the step taken by the north-eastern Swiss, Neininger remains calm and is counting on talks. He seems to believe in a faux pas rather than an attempt by TZ and Landbote to further isolate SN. He wants to negotiate anyway. "In the commercial sector, we'll do anything that makes sense," he says with regard to the real estate and job supplements planned by Verbund. It is at least not out of the question that he will join on April 1, says Neininger.
The association at a glanceThe two titles
Thurgauer Zeitung (TZ) and Landbote will be subtitled "Die Nordostschweiz" from April 2, 2007. The new association provides for a joint editorial office in Winterthur and the bundling of the joint publishing business in Frauenfeld. A total of 3.2 jobs will be cut. Colette Gradwohl, Editor-in-Chief of the Landbote, will become Editor-in-Chief of the joint mantle. A successor to TZ editor-in-chief Andreas Netzle, who is moving into politics in the middle of the year, will be appointed in the first quarter. The visual appearance of the TZ will match the layout of the Landbote from April 2, and the TZ will also be published as a 4-bundle newspaper like the Landbote, while Felix Walder will continue to manage the Landbote publishing house, but Urs Bucher, publishing director of the TZ, will take over the management of the joint publishing operations (subscription management, supplement editing, marketing, pre-press, sales). He will also be responsible for the entire advertising business of the two titles. TZ, which had previously entrusted its national business to Publicitas, has been standing on its own two feet since the beginning of 2007. The Landbote, which was still on a full P lease until the end of 2007, will have its marketing handled by Thurgauer Medien from 2008. The latter is setting up a new sales team for the local marketing of the Landbote in Winterthur.
From April, the two titles will also be launching a new jobs supplement and a new real estate market for north-eastern Switzerland.
No surprise, but a bit of troubleWeder beim St. Galler Tagblatt
Neither the NZZ Group nor the Züriland newspapers were surprised by the new association. However, Erland Herkenrath, Managing Director of Zürcher Unterländer (ZU) and ZürichseeZeitung (ZSZ), is somewhat annoyed by the name "Nordostschweiz". Two years ago, there was still an advertising combination under this title that combined six titles, the three Züriland newspapers (Zürcher Oberländer, ZU and ZSZ), the Landbote, the Thurgauer Zeitung and the Schaffhauser Nachrichten. It had 400,000 readers. The new association, on the other hand, only has 150,000 readers. "But we knew that a geographical name cannot be protected," says Herkenrath. Markus Knöpfli