Regional press The Tages-Anzeiger's regional offensive is less than three months old. Since November 6, Tamedia has been present with regional editions on Lake Zurich, in the Zurich Oberland and Unterland as well as in the Limmat city itself. The offensive caused great unrest among the regional papers directly attacked by Tamedia. After almost three months of local journalism from Tamedia, the dust has settled somewhat. The regional titles, which have merged to form the joint Zürcher Landzeitung in response to the Tamedia offensive, are breathing a sigh of relief. Although the threat situation is permanent and the pressure on the advertising business will increase once again with the large Tagi edition announced for the spring, it is business as usual for the time being. At least that's what a small survey of those responsible shows. No euphoria far and wide "Disillusionment is making itself felt," says Christine Fivian, editor-in-chief of the Zürcher Unterländer, after the obviously big promises made by Tamedia strategists in the Zurich Unterland. Although the Tagi regional edition is well presented, it cannot outstrip the Unterländer in terms of journalism. Christian Müller, deputy editor-in-chief at Zürcher Oberländer, finds the Tagi regional edition similarly unspectacular. "We don't feel any concrete effects." The Oberländer is concentrating on having as many current topics as possible in the paper in order to get ahead of the competition. However, this is no great feat. After all, the closing times of the Tagi regional editorial offices at 8 p.m. do not allow media professionals to keep up with the traditional newspapers.
This is one of the reasons why Benjamin Geiger, editor-in-chief of the Zürichsee Zeitung in Stäfa, hardly bothers to take the Tagi-Split out of his letterbox every day. Geiger has noticed the same difficulties for the Tages-Anzeiger on the right bank of the lake in terms of primeurs, range of topics and topicality that the first Tagi regional editorial office on the left bank of the lake has been struggling with since its launch in March 2005. The competition is therefore focusing its topics more on people and portraits, says Geiger. The closing time handicap also means that the Tagi split tries to anticipate events with previews. "For many organizers, however, a preview alone is not enough"; they also want journalists to be present, says Christine Fivian.
The authorities show little euphoria about the presence of the Tages-Anzeiger in the regions. Hardly any municipalities make use of the offer to print official notices free of charge. "I have the impression that the Tagi has abandoned this idea," says Geiger.
Status quo for advertisementsThere hardly seems to be any shift in the advertising business either, neither for the Unterländer nor the Oberländer. On the left bank of the lake, Publicitas branch manager Peter Curiger regularly counts the advertisements in the Tagi-Split. On average, two and a half to three out of eight pages are occupied by so-called filler advertisements. Jost Kessler, head of the Publicitas department in Stäfa, also counts a maximum of one page of advertisements per split edition. "Paid advertising is lean," says Kessler. Both Curiger and Kessler note that local businesses do not want to advertise with the competition. Elections are an exception, for example when the FDP uses the traditional paper for its election advertising in the same way as the Tages-Anzeiger split.
However, the impact of the announced large circulation of the Tages-Anzeiger cannot yet be estimated. "This will be the final blow to take away major advertisers," estimates Christine Fivian. The large print run is expected to be launched at the end of February, but Rolf Bollmann, responsible for the Tagi regionalization strategy and member of the management board at Tamedia, does not yet want to announce the date. It is also too early to talk about the first successful results of regionalization. "There are hardly any big leaps to be made in the reader market," says Bollmann, contrasting with Tagi Editor-in-Chief Peter Hartmeier's assertions about the journalistic efficiency of the strategy. Hartmeier recently said in an interview with the Schaffhauser AZ: "The added value offered is highly valued by the readership. The people in Uster and Bülach are happy to have a large newspaper that reaches deep into their regions." Bollmann is therefore betting his cards on the large circulation and hopes to attract as many large advertisers as possible away from the rural newspapers to his side.
No regional split in SchaffhausenObviously, the Schaffhausen cantonal council
On the occasion of a visit by Tamedia Chairman of the Board Hans Heinrich Coninx, CEO Martin Kall and a delegation from Tele Züri, he expressed slight disappointment that Tamedia does not also want to launch a regional edition in Schaffhausen. The cantonal government is probably not always comfortable with the multimedia monopoly position of the media from Meier. In an interview with the Schaffhauser AZ, Tagi editor-in-chief Peter Hartmeier denies such plans. "We are limiting ourselves to the canton of Zurich." Tamedia, on the other hand, intends to expand to Schaffhausen with a broadcasting window on TeleZüri. René Worni