Discounts Media agencies welcome the new handling fee from NZZ and Publimedia. Urs Schneider, owner of the media agency MediaSchneider, welcomes the handling fee (HE) that NZZ and Publimedia have decided on for booking NZZ titles (see box). "Like the direct booking fee, it helps to cover our expenses," he says. Nevertheless, he is "somewhat irritated". "Why is the HE only granted for NZZ titles and not for all publishers with Publicitas management?" asks the media strategist, speaking from the hearts of many media agencies. After all, a solely NZZ-related HE cannot be the last word in wisdom. Chris Flückiger, Managing Director of Mediatonic, therefore speaks of a "first step in the right direction". "It shows that the P is slowly understanding what is really at stake." However, he notes critically that the HE is "in principle nothing more than a price discount", which Mediatonic will pass on to customers - just like other discounts. The direct booking allowance (DBE) is different: Mediatonic is allowed to keep it.
Konnex is completely different: the agency is paid by its clients on a time and material basis, not by volume percentage, which is why it passes on all discounts, the DBE and now also the new HE to its clients. "That's why HE doesn't play a role for us. But for agencies that are paid by percentage, it is certainly an additional source of income," acknowledges Konnex co-owner Ronny Schmid.
It is still completely unclear how the Association of Swiss Advertisers will react. Director Jürg Siegrist now wants to "take a global look at the issue of compensation".
Publishers with Publicitas management are of course particularly interested in the new HE. They also assume that the HE cannot be limited to the NZZ. They all want a level playing field with the independent publishers with DBE. "HE is of course pushing our considerations, but we still know too little about it," says Beat Meyer, CEO of Basler Zeitung Medien, which was the first P-directed publisher to study a form of compensation. Erwin Bachmann, CEO of LZ Medien, which belongs to the NZZ Group, also finds HE "an interesting approach", but he will now discuss it with P first. AZ Medien, Biel-based Gassman AG and publisher president Hanspeter Lebrument, head of Südostschweiz, have a similar view. "But what is customary in Zurich is usually followed with some delay here too," says Lebrument.
Marcel Siegenthaler, Head of Advertising Market at Edipresse Switzerland, is more cautious. He also expects a solution for the Edipresse newspapers, all of which are P-leased, "especially for Matin bleu, as it is in direct competition with Tamedia's 20 minutes, where a DBE is granted". Nevertheless, he first wants to know how HE will be financed in detail: Does the P pay, does the publisher pay - or both? A question that NZZ and P have so far left unanswered (see WW 3/07). "In any case, we are not willing to bear these costs," says Siegenthaler. A HE is a matter for the P, because the agencies relieve it of work with professional preliminary work. "That's why the P should take the HE from the advertising commission that we pay it."
The handling compensation in a nutshellLast week Publimedia and the NZZ Group agreed on the following,
to grant major customers and media agencies a "handling fee" of one percent from the beginning of the year, provided they book at least CHF 0.5 million worth of advertisements annually with NZZ, NZZ am Sonntag and the new Z magazine. This is in response to the direct booking compensation offered by most independent publishers to agencies that book directly with the publisher, bypassing the P. Markus Knöpfli