New solution, but old problem remains
Private Television: Private TV stations in French-speaking Switzerland have a problem: Despite an expanded package and a new marketing executive, they are lacking in performance and solid numbers.
Private television The private TV stations in French-speaking Switzerland have a problem: despite an expanded combi and a new marketer, they are lacking in performance and useful figures. While the latter already joined forces in the last millennium to form a regional-language advertising combination, the TeleNewsCombi (TNC), this was only possible in French-speaking Switzerland a year and a half ago - and still only happened half-heartedly: although the RomandieNewsCombi (RNC) came into being, it was only thanks to the patient pushing and pulling of marketer Radiotele. Moreover, only five broadcasters took part: TVRL in Lausanne, ICI-TV in Vevey, Canal 9 in Sierre (VS), Canal Nord-Vaudois in Yverdon and Canal Alpha in Cortaillod (NE). The Geneva stations Léman Bleu and Tele Bielingue (Biel) were not included, but the RNC no longer exists and was terminated at the end of 2006. The reason: Léman Bleu and Télé Bielingue decided to join after all, which is why the RNC is being replaced by the new Télé Romandie Combi (TRC). This means that, for the first time, the whole of French-speaking Switzerland can be covered by local TV from a single source. The seven broadcasters have also recently chosen SRG marketer Publisuisse as their marketer. However, this caused astonishment among PubliGroupe subsidiary Radiotele, which had also made an offer. "I had expected that we would be invited by the broadcasters in French-speaking Switzerland to talk to them again. At least that's what was announced," says Radiotele Managing Director Bruno Oetterli. The same can be heard from IP Multimedia.
But Oetterli can come to terms with the decision. "Publisuisse will now have to show how successfully it can operate in this market. Up to now, it has primarily marketed SRG TV channels," he says. But is that true? After all, Publisuisse has been co-marketer of the Swiss-German TeleNewsCombi (TNC) since 2002, together with Radiotele, so it should certainly have some experience in the local TV market. Oetterli says: "TNC sales mainly come through us or from agencies that book online via Publiplan." Some TNC broadcasters confirm this. Publisuisse Head of Marketing Markus Hollenstein, however, does not wish to comment.
Comparative data is lackingOetterli points out another point: Despite marketer Publisuisse, "the main problem of local TVs in French-speaking Switzerland remains. Most of them have no Telecontrol data. This means that they are still not comparable with TSR or the foreign broadcasters." In fact, Telecontrol (TC) was already only able to provide global figures for the previous RNC: The five channels had an average net reach of 11,500 viewers in 2006; together with Léman Bleu and Tele Bielingue, this figure is likely to be around 17,000,000. However, due to the low usage of Léman Bleu and TVRL, channel-specific information or even advertising block ratings are only possible for Léman Bleu and TVRL - for the others, the case numbers are too low. Another complicating factor is that some channels only have small TV areas.
However, the inadequate track record does not seem to be a problem everywhere. "Because the local TVs in French-speaking Switzerland are not the lead broadcasters, the lack of TC data does not play a major role," says Gregor Doser, Head of Electronic Media at the media agency Mediaedge:cia Switzerland. Usually, people don't place large sums of money in this medium, but primarily try to optimize campaigns, he says.
But this also makes it clear that if the channels in French-speaking Switzerland want to try to step out of TSR's shadow, they need higher usage and then also TC data. The broadcasters know this too. However, it is unclear what they are doing to improve their program. On the other hand, they are trying to mitigate the lack of data somewhat by joining the basic research of SRG subsidiary Publica Data. Their weekly interviews are to be supplemented with questions on viewer behavior in French-speaking Switzerland, so that around 1500 interviews on local TV usage in French-speaking Switzerland can be evaluated on a quarterly basis. PDAG Managing Director Rolf Müller confirms corresponding talks, but emphasizes that nothing is definite yet. Moreover, PDAG will only do this on an exceptional basis and for a maximum of two years. He also made it clear that the findings from the interviews would also not allow any statements to be made at station or advertising block level.
Markus Knöpfli
But Oetterli can come to terms with the decision. "Publisuisse will now have to show how successfully it can operate in this market. Up to now, it has primarily marketed SRG TV channels," he says. But is that true? After all, Publisuisse has been co-marketer of the Swiss-German TeleNewsCombi (TNC) since 2002, together with Radiotele, so it should certainly have some experience in the local TV market. Oetterli says: "TNC sales mainly come through us or from agencies that book online via Publiplan." Some TNC broadcasters confirm this. Publisuisse Head of Marketing Markus Hollenstein, however, does not wish to comment.
Comparative data is lackingOetterli points out another point: Despite marketer Publisuisse, "the main problem of local TVs in French-speaking Switzerland remains. Most of them have no Telecontrol data. This means that they are still not comparable with TSR or the foreign broadcasters." In fact, Telecontrol (TC) was already only able to provide global figures for the previous RNC: The five channels had an average net reach of 11,500 viewers in 2006; together with Léman Bleu and Tele Bielingue, this figure is likely to be around 17,000,000. However, due to the low usage of Léman Bleu and TVRL, channel-specific information or even advertising block ratings are only possible for Léman Bleu and TVRL - for the others, the case numbers are too low. Another complicating factor is that some channels only have small TV areas.
However, the inadequate track record does not seem to be a problem everywhere. "Because the local TVs in French-speaking Switzerland are not the lead broadcasters, the lack of TC data does not play a major role," says Gregor Doser, Head of Electronic Media at the media agency Mediaedge:cia Switzerland. Usually, people don't place large sums of money in this medium, but primarily try to optimize campaigns, he says.
But this also makes it clear that if the channels in French-speaking Switzerland want to try to step out of TSR's shadow, they need higher usage and then also TC data. The broadcasters know this too. However, it is unclear what they are doing to improve their program. On the other hand, they are trying to mitigate the lack of data somewhat by joining the basic research of SRG subsidiary Publica Data. Their weekly interviews are to be supplemented with questions on viewer behavior in French-speaking Switzerland, so that around 1500 interviews on local TV usage in French-speaking Switzerland can be evaluated on a quarterly basis. PDAG Managing Director Rolf Müller confirms corresponding talks, but emphasizes that nothing is definite yet. Moreover, PDAG will only do this on an exceptional basis and for a maximum of two years. He also made it clear that the findings from the interviews would also not allow any statements to be made at station or advertising block level.
Markus Knöpfli
