Partnerships Norbert Neininger, publisher of the Schaffhauser Nachrichten (SN), explains why he is participating in the Kombi Nordostschweiz (NOS) initiative.
WW: When the NOS press release came out, the immediate reaction in the industry was: The SN is moving closer to the Tamedia Group. What do you have to say about that? Norbert Neininger: We are continuing the Kombi 1B, which has been around for many years, under the name «Nordostschweiz.» The only change is that it will now be marketed by Thurgauer Medien instead of Publicitas. That’s all—there’s absolutely no question of a rapprochement with Tamedia.WW: Another change: The Landbote/Thurgauer Zeitung (TZ) combined module will be discontinued in the future, which will likely benefit the SN the most. So did you set any conditions as well? Norbert Neininger: In any case, we weren’t backed into a corner. On the contrary. But it would also be ridiculous to think we had the others cornered. As always in such discussions, it was a matter of give and take. One thing is clear: the NOS combo benefits all three newspapers. Especially when it comes to job listings, each of the three publishers expects higher volume because the job ads will now appear in all three titles. But the sub-combo had been bothering us for a long time. We’re therefore glad that we were able to get our way. WW: Why did the others agree? Because the NOS only reaches a circulation of 100,000 copies when combined with the SN? Norbert Neininger: Yes, of course. But also because of the new joint job section, the centerpiece of NOS: Sub-sections would hardly make sense there. Moreover, the switch from P to in-house marketing is a major step. From the perspective of TZ and Landbote, going it alone wouldn’t have made sense either. It’s better for them, too, to rely on a combination that has been well-established for years. So we’ve protected our interests. But we always do that whenever possible.
WW: On other levels as well—in sales, for example? For about a year now, Zuvo—the early-delivery service run by Tamedia and NZZ—has also been operating in Schaffhausen and competing with your Schazo. Is a change on the horizon there? Norbert Neininger: Right now, we’re only talking about the Kombi. But it’s clear that Zuvo’s presence here is a major disruptive factor for us.
WW: …was that an issue in the joint negotiations? Norbert Neininger: I won’t comment on that at this time. WW: Back to the NOS: You could have joined as early as April 1, 2007. Why are you doing it only now? Norbert Neininger: Because back then, the question was whether we wanted to join the NOS newspaper system. But that would have required us to standardize the layout and outsource certain editorial and publishing functions. However, we don’t want a one-size-fits-all solution, no standardization of the layout, and absolutely no downsizing of the publishing department. We remain an autonomous, independent newspaper that simply continues to collaborate with Kombi. WW: So you just wanted to be able to continue outsourcing national sales? Norbert Neininger: Yes. National sales, which primarily run through Kombi, have always been handled by P, which is better at it than we are. But unlike the *Landbote*, which was entirely under P’s management and is now transferring all of its operations to the *TZ*, we retained local sales and always kept a portion of national sales in-house. After all, customer relationships are vital for a publishing house. We’ll continue to handle it this way in the future, and we’re now fully committed to the cause. WW: Do you reject editorial collaborations? Norbert Neininger: No, but we only want them to the extent that we had them before Tamedia took over the Thurgauer Zeitung. Even back then, we had joint supplements, exchanged articles, and even had a joint editorial office at the Federal Parliament. We’d like to resume all of these activities.WW: Will there be rate changes in 2008?Norbert Neininger: The SN is raising its rates, while at the same time the combo discount will be significantly larger, so that the combo package becomes as attractive as possible compared to individual subscriptions. We want to generate momentum for the combined package. WW: What percentage of its revenue did the SN generate this year through the 1B combined package—that is, from the national market? Norbert Neininger: The share is less than 50 percent, but a combined package is extremely important to us. WW: Last question regarding the TV project with ZüriPlus, RingierTV, and Goldbach Media in the new Zurich-Northeast Switzerland TV region: Has it already
Submitted?
Norbert Neininger: "No, right now everything is in flux once again." Interview: Markus Knöpfli
See also
The biggest together