Google Street View: Data protectionist makes demands on Google
According to Hanspeter Thür, Google Street View does not adequately protect privacy, despite additional measures. The Federal Data Protection and Information Commissioner has therefore issued recommendations. If these are not implemented, he can take the matter to the Federal Administrative Court. Google has expressed disappointment. The internet company intends to vigorously defend its product in court.
Hanspeter Thür calls for Google to develop an improved solution for completely obscuring faces and license plates and to pay special attention to anonymization in the vicinity of sensitive institutions such as hospitals, schools or prisons. Recordings from private streets are to be deleted if no consent is given. Recordings from enclosed places (yards, gardens) must be removed, the camera should be mounted accordingly lower. Google is to inform which towns and villages are affected both one week before the recordings and one week before they are posted. In addition, no new images of Swiss streets are to be posted until the legal issues have been clarified.
Google disappointed - no understanding
"We were very disappointed with the position Mr. Thür took in response to our intensive efforts," Peter Fleischer, Google privacy counsel, was quoted as saying in a statement Monday. Google had met with the Federal Privacy Commissioner before and after the launch of Street View to explain the technology, he said. Today's decision is therefore regrettable, it said, and indicates that Mr. Thür is unwilling to address the solutions offered. "We will vigorously oppose any legal action." , it continues.
Regarding the concerns, Google had proposed five measures:
- Improved blurring of license plates: Swiss license plates are unusual - compared to neighboring countries - because they are smaller and therefore harder to see, he said. Nevertheless, the technology is to be improved.
- Improved blurring of faces: Software that has been available for a short time will be integrated into the product as quickly as possible. In principle, however, the blurring technology has already reached a high standard, he said. "We are proud of the blurring technology we have developed for Street View".
- Dialog with stakeholders: Google meets with various groups working in sensitive areas, such as rehab clinics or women's shelters, in addition to the Federal Data Protection Commissioner. This work would be continued.
- Sensitive places: It is taken into account that there are areas in a city that are more sensitive than others.
- Informing the public about recording trips: Due to bad weather, traffic conditions or other unpredictable events, it is difficult to inform the public about when cars are on the road for recording. This is being worked on, he said. The current status can be here can be retrieved.




