"The worst time, the best time".

In the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, the HWZ launched a new degree program—the EMBA in Digital Leadership. A conversation with co-initiator Manuel P. Nappo.

HWZ Digital Leadership
(Image: Unsplash)

m&k: Manuel Nappo, the first EMBA in Digital Leadership program has come to a successful conclusion. What was your experience like?

Manuel P. Nappo: The video shows what's most valuable (see below, Editor's note) It’s clear: how the EMBA has shaped the participants. Program Director Sunnie J. Groeneveld and I have designed a program that has a visible impact on the participants’ personalities and, as a result, on their surroundings—including their colleagues and companies. There isn’t much that could top this. The feeling of inspiring people to do something positive is the greatest reward for me as the institute’s director.

 

You launched your EMBA in Digital Leadership in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic. Be honest: Was that the worst possible timing, or the best possible timing?

As is so often the case, it depends on your perspective. It was unfortunate for certain activities that had originally been planned, such as the study tours to the U.S. or Asia. However, the timing seemed perfect in light of the many challenges the participants faced. The EMBA provided them with a platform at exactly the right moment to reflect on and further develop their own leadership skills. The extraordinary situation also brought the pioneer class even closer together. We created new formats, turned TEDxHWZ into a streaming conference, and held Alpine Retreats instead of study tours. The positive feeling of having succeeded despite all the unexpected challenges prevails.

«To be honest, looking back, I think it's amazing how many solutions came about just because of the pandemic.»

 

What is the composition of your participants?

We are proud that our first class was very diverse. Employees from a cannabis startup, an international tech conglomerate, and Swiss family-owned businesses—they were all there. Participants ranged in age from 35 to 51, and women made up 25 percent of the class. We’d love to see that percentage rise even higher in the future. This broad interest clearly shows that application-oriented executive education in the areas of digital and leadership should be a priority regardless of industry or company size.

 

What key takeaways did your participants gain?

I hope that they truly understand and embody leadership as a skill. In the VUCA world, technical expertise alone is no longer enough. The pandemic has made that very clear. In our program, subject matter expertise was just the foundation. Building on that, participants developed and refined their public speaking skills, remote team leadership, innovation skills, foresight, and, of course, self-reflection skills.

 

As an organizer, what were the highlights for you?

The biggest highlight is clearly that the premiere was a success despite the pandemic. And honestly, looking back, I also think it’s great how many new formats and solutions emerged solely because of the pandemic. Not only did we make the best of it, but certain things turned out even better than originally planned. That’s why I’m all the more pleased that documentary filmmaker Alessandra Berti accompanied us throughout those eighteen months and captured some of these highlights for posterity.

 

A new EMBA in Digital Leadership program begins in January 2022. Is it still possible to register?

Yes, registration is still open. Together with the program directors—Urs Bucher, Daniela Landherr, Chris Luebkeman, and Claude Siegenthaler—Sunnie and I will continue to refine the program and ensure that it remains «not just another EMBA.».


The first EMBA Digital Leadership program was documented over the course of eighteen months by documentary filmmaker Alessandra Berti. The result is a retrospective for anyone who wants a look behind the scenes who want to take the HWZ exam—or are considering participating in the next round of the program.

The scent of success

Maison Francis Kurkdjian is one of the most popular perfume brands in the world. Exclusively for m&k, Marc Chaya, CEO and co-founder, reveals the secrets behind his brand: Are perfumes works of art? What does luxury smell like? And how do you build a premium brand that customers love?

Parfum-Labels
(Illustration: Silvan Borer)

m&k Maison Francis Kurkdjian has become one of the world's most renowned perfume brands. When you and Francis Kurkdjian founded the brand in 2009, what ideas and goals did you have in mind?

Marc Chaya: When I met Francis about eighteen years ago at a dinner party, I asked him, «What do you do for a living?» He replied, «I’m a perfumer.» At the time, I had no idea what a perfumer was—and when I learned that he had created Jean Paul Gaultier’s «Le Mâle,» followed by more than 40 well-known fragrances for various fashion and couture houses such as Dior, Saint Laurent, Armani, Narciso Rodriguez, and Elie Saab—I asked him, «How come I’d never heard of you? You’ve created all these perfumes that everyone wears, but I’ve never heard of you!» What struck me most was that such an extraordinary creative talent had simply been «hidden away» and was only allowed to work under the guidance of—and to meet the needs of—marketing teams. I quickly realized that there is room in the market for a brilliant perfumer who can freely express his ideas and put creativity at the center—as is the case in couture, for example, where designers are the origin and heart of everything.

 

Would you describe that as your founding vision?Yes, that was the vision: to enable one of the greatest perfumers of our time to freely express his ideas. Moreover, even back then, Francis Kurkdjian was already taking perfume beyond the bottle and transforming it into beautiful artistic installations, such as «scenting» the fountains in front of the Palace of Versailles. We decided to do the same at our company and, from the very beginning, not only to develop a beautiful fragrance collection but also to create other things, such as scented leather—we’ve actually patented the know-how for that — incense paper, scented laundry detergent, or scented soap bubbles for children.Before founding the company, you were a partner at the consulting firm Ernst & Young. Why did you take on the entrepreneurial risk of entering a highly competitive market like that of luxury perfumes?

As a child, I was very creative and sensitive; I had a passion for drawing, architecture, fashion, art, and music. However, the people around me—and especially my father—encouraged me to focus on business. So I clearly missed creativity in my professional life and sought a field where I could apply the business skills I’d acquired while also expressing my innate creative nature. After forming a close friendship with Francis, I left my position at Ernst & Young in 2009. We both felt it was time to try something new. Since then, we’ve been on an extraordinary journey (laughs)! With passion, determination, and joy, we’ve built what is now widely recognized as a leading global player in the market for high-quality and selective fragrances.

«The vision was to give one of the best perfumers of our time the opportunity to give free rein to his ideas.»

 

What factors did you primarily consider in order to differentiate your brand from the competition?

I’ve already mentioned this briefly: Our «Maison» began with a vision that was disruptive in many ways—to free perfumer Francis Kurkdjian from the typical dynamics of the market and give him the freedom to do whatever he wants. That is our first distinguishing feature and a major difference from many competitors who still follow old structures. We also take a very selective approach to distribution: we’d rather focus on a few high-quality distribution partnerships than on many of lower quality. We offer expertise and an excellent product. Our narratives spring directly from the perfumer’s spirit, and our marketing always serves his creative vision. We believe this is what makes the stories we tell meaningful, authentic, and inspiring.

 

You mentioned your products. If we stick to perfumes for now: What sets them apart?

The fragrance collection that Francis has created over the years is extraordinary. His creative signature is highly appreciated by our customers. Take, for example, the iconic «Baccarat Rouge 540» or the fragrance «l’eau À la Rose,» which has made the scent of roses—often stereotyped as something only for older women—feel younger and more contemporary. Furthermore, with «l’Homme À la Rose,» we’ve invited men to venture into new olfactory territory. And with «Gentle Fluidity Silver» and «Gentle Fluidity Gold,» we’re leaving gender labels entirely behind—as the names suggest.

(Illustration: Silvan Borer)

You frequently collaborate with other premium brands—such as Fendi. How do these collaborations come about?

For us, these collaborations are never just about «promoting» products or making market entry easier. We are a creative house, and as in any creative field, there are sometimes wonderful encounters that lead to inspiring, surprising results. That was the case with Fendi, where—just like us—they place great value on craftsmanship; we used a special technique to create a fragrance for the iconic «Baguette» bag. And that was also the case with our partnership with Baccarat: collaboration between crystal manufacturers and perfumers has a long tradition, and when Baccarat contacted us to create a bespoke fragrance for their 250th anniversary, we practically had to say yes (laughs). Francis was very interested in exploring how the alchemy of crystal-making could be interpreted in a fragrance. That’s how the fragrance «Rouge 540»—which I mentioned earlier—was born. It was supposed to be a limited edition of just 250 crystal bottles, but the fragrance was incredibly well-received. That’s why we decided to take the collaboration to a new level and launch «Rouge 540» as part of our collection in 2016. Authenticity is essential to the success of a collaboration; otherwise, the whole thing won’t hold up.

 

A handbag and a perfume: How do you bring together two things that are so different?

The creation of a fragrance begins with a story, an inspiration. When collaborating with a fashion brand, you approach the project from a creative perspective and look for the story and angle that best suit the collaboration and make it meaningful and inspiring. Storytelling and emotions are of fundamental importance to us. That’s how Francis works; he tells stories through his creations, and in this case, the story is about revealing a specific aspect of the fashion house—because a fragrance can’t say everything.

«Authenticity is essential to the success of a collaboration; otherwise, the whole thing won't work.»

 

Do you feel that the pandemic has intensified people’s longing for beauty, for luxury products, and for little escapes from everyday life—or has it made your business more difficult?

We were not overly affected by the general slowdown in the consumer economy because our customers continue to want to experience our fragrance collection and purchase their favorite scents from the «Maison» collection. After a weaker first half of 2020, we have experienced dynamic growth since the second half of 2020, with the share of digital sales rising significantly. This trend is continuing in 2021, and I expect it to persist well beyond 2022.

 

So has the pandemic also reinforced the trend toward e-commerce in the premium segment?

The pandemic has definitely amplified certain pre-existing trends, particularly online shopping and the digitization of customer relationships, to which we have responded by strengthening our digital presence. At the same time, many stores have reopened since the beginning of the year, and we’re pleased to have reestablished a foothold at most of our physical locations—particularly in the U.S., which is our largest market. We’re moving toward an omnichannel model, where we aim to deliver an exceptional customer experience at every touchpoint. But, to come back to your previous question: In recent months, we’ve noticed that our customers continue to wear their perfume—even more than before. I believe that perfume is now an integral part of our lives—almost a necessity for feeling good and taking care of ourselves. The need for self-care and positive feelings has, of course, been further amplified by the pandemic, and perfume is an accessory that enhances our emotions and complements our personality, while at the same time being invisible and personal. A pleasant sensory experience that helps us feel more confident and sensual—and, in a way, brings us closer to ourselves. In a year of restrictions, sacrifices, and depressing news, perfume has been a way to create a positive balance and enhance our lives at home—whether by wearing our favorite scents or using home fragrances to create a pleasant atmosphere.

«In a year of hardship, perfume was a way to create a sense of balance.»

 

Do you feel that perfume creation is generally recognized as an art form and receives the respect it deserves?

It’s starting to happen, and we’ve worked hard to achieve this goal. Perfume-making is a perfect combination of creative genius and technology—though technology is primarily a vehicle for bringing ideas to life, with the method itself taking a back seat. You know, for many years, perfumers were relegated «behind the scenes.» That’s changing now, and the recent appointment of my co-founder Francis as Creative Director of Parfums Christian Dior—while he simultaneously retains his leading creative role at Maison Francis Kurkdjian—pays tribute to this fact. Perfumers are now recognized as creative authorities, and like fashion designers, they can lend their talent to multiple houses at the same time. The history of fashion is full of such examples: Karl Lagerfeld worked for both Chanel and Fendi for decades, and Kim Jones worked for both Dior Men and Fendi at the same time …

In closing, allow me to ask: When—in business or in life—should one choose a subtle fragrance, and when should one opt for a bold one?

The same fragrance can smell completely different depending on the person, so there’s no single answer to this question. For example, I like to wear «Amyris,» «Gentle Fluidity Silver,» or «Grand Soir» as my everyday fragrances, while I save «OUD Satin Mood» or «Baccarat Rouge 540 Extrait de Parfum» for special occasions. However, others in my circle wear «OUD satin mood» and «Baccarat Rouge 540» as everyday fragrances! Perfume is an invisible accessory that boosts our confidence and brings us joy. The most important thing is to be true to yourself!


Marc Chaya is the CEO and co-founder of the perfume house Maison Francis Kurkdjian. Before founding his company, he worked for nearly two decades at the consulting firm Ernst & Young, most recently as Global Head of Telecom Markets. Born and raised in Lebanon, he now lives in Paris.

The company Maison Francis Kurkdjian was founded in 2009 by the perfumer of the same name and his business partner, Marc Chaya. Long an independent company, Maison Francis Kurkdjian has grown into one of the best-known boutique brands in the premium fragrance segment. In 2017, the luxury conglomerate LVMH acquired a majority stake in the company, but Kurkdjian and Chaya remained on board as creative director and CEO, respectively.

The pressure increases

The once so proud black guild has been battered in recent years: fewer orders, smaller print runs, customers are increasingly doing the work themselves. This raises the question of the current state of the printing industry and its future prospects.

stolze schwarzeIn September, the Swiss Printing Industry Association hosted a forum to discuss post-pandemic business models for the graphic arts industry. Speaking on behalf of the client side was Martin Scholl, CEO of Zürcher Kantonalbank, and he didn’t mince words. At Switzerland’s fifth-largest bank, media production companies hardly play a role anymore (which he regrets), but he understands the reasons for this from his own institution. Prepress work is often handled in-house within the new newsroom, and the print runs of the few print products still used for advertising have fallen sharply—specifically, the ZKB annual report has dropped from 4,000 copies (2004) to just 550 today (2020).

«Above all, clients want simpler—and therefore faster—solutions.»

Matthias Künzler can confirm Martin Scholl’s findings. The media professor, who now teaches at the Free University of Berlin, was previously the head of research at the Institute for Multimedia Production at the University of Applied Sciences in Chur. In that capacity, he led a study that took a scientific look at corporate newsrooms as production centers within companies. According to the study, such media production workplaces can be better tailored to a company’s needs and are set up as multimedia desks. As researcher Künzler notes, these centers employ new professions that do not originate from the graphic design industry—such as producers, directors, video journalists, and social media managers. What they have in common is that they are proficient in new technologies, think commercially, and are customer-focused. These are the key findings from the study on the corporate newsroom.

René Theiler, one of the leading experts in the graphic arts industry, largely agrees with these statements. In his opinion, when it comes to purely promotional printed materials, clients today tend to get more involved in the production process by creating the print files themselves or uploading them directly to specialized web portals, which are now seen as useful and well-designed tools. In contrast, when it comes to periodicals (magazines published regularly) or annual reports, they continue to leave the entire process to specialists in the printing industry.

«The bold members of the Black Guild are even venturing into the agency business, much to the dismay of the advertisers.»

The Wirz agency also set up its own production center several years ago. Daniel Ehrensperger notes that, in his opinion, not much has changed in terms of preparing print materials, but the individual steps in the process are becoming more integrated—this is undeniable. Hans Preuss of Zurich-based nsgroup, another pioneer in media production, elaborates: In general, traditional print order processes have changed significantly, and the pandemic has further accelerated and accentuated this trend. What remains unchanged, according to Hans Preuss, is that the output is still a physical product. However, the production process is becoming increasingly digitized, leading to new interfaces and efficiency gains. As examples, the business development expert cites documents shared in the cloud, online ordering processes, web shops, and video communication instead of in-person meetings. Companies that are modern and customer-focused can easily handle any type of print artwork.

This raises the question of how this looks from the client’s perspective: Does the client have any specific requests for the printer? For Daniel Ehrensperger, this isn’t an issue—at his company (the Wirz Group), the end clients typically choose the printer. This is also the case for nsgroup, though they address this point in more specific terms. According to Hans Preuss, they increasingly view the client as a communications manager who focuses primarily on the channels they want to use simultaneously and thus pays more attention to the content and the output than to the production process itself. That’s why, according to him, clients tend to look for a partner who understands the processes and, above all, can manage them. The client sets the requirements in terms of time and budget (schedule and budget), and the execution must be flawless.

René Theiler expands on this idea; according to his observations, clients are primarily looking for simpler—and therefore faster—solutions; therefore, printing companies that support the digitization of production with effective strategies have an advantage.

Where the focus lies

Not only has the printing industry lost existing orders, but the remaining ones have become smaller, and certain tasks—especially in prepress—are now handled by the clients themselves or by third parties. How can a traditional printing company make up for this shortfall? Hans Preuss has a simple answer: If the printing process remains the focus of a graphic arts company, that business will face difficulties; if, on the other hand, it focuses on the customer experience, new services will open up for the graphic arts company, particularly in consulting. However, this requires that employees receive appropriate training in marketing and communication and develop the ability to adapt—on a case-by-case basis—to translate the client’s goals into their own services, as Preuss puts it. According to nsgroup, more concrete and obvious examples of additional services would include proofreading, shipping logistics, or warehousing—that is, services that print providers have offered in the past. Other in-demand services could include data handling—especially when dealing with large volumes of data—or tools to help present potential print projects, such as blind and paper samples or even proofs.

The bolder members of the print industry are even venturing into the agency business—much to the chagrin of advertisers—though in many cases they have already brought a (large) portion of print production in-house. René Theiler brings another aspect into play: Those who can offer cross-media services—and by that he means, first and foremost, the integration of print and web—hold the upper hand. Added to this today are other cross-media applications such as augmented reality and printed electronics—or, more immediately relevant, multichannel concepts in which multiple channels are utilized for the same campaign.

The online channel is also playing an increasingly important role in the printing industry, as illustrated by the example of the Jordi printing company in Belp, which has established the online print shop «Printzessin» alongside its existing graphic arts business. Managing Director Gabriel Jordi wouldn’t want to be without this second source of revenue. On the one hand, Printzessin fills the revenue gaps in the traditional business, and on the other, it brings in new customers who would rarely turn to a «traditional» graphic design firm. But the online business doesn’t work properly without good service, says the reoriented print specialist. Even if the online portal is easy to use, questions keep popping up that need answers. If they receive good information, these customers are also willing to pay extra for it. Typically, it’s the simpler jobs in smaller print runs (from about 20 to around 400 copies) that come in through the online channel, but in many cases, these are customers who also place larger orders in higher print runs from time to time. And when these customers are well served—receiving not only the right information but also high-quality printed materials—they’re also willing to turn to Jordi Printing for larger print jobs. This traditional company benefits from the fact that optimal customer focus has always been a priority. Production takes place on the same machines with the same staff.


INTERVIEW

«The Swiss Print Award Needs More Glamour»

Marco Bieri, Chairman of the Swiss Print Awards.

In an interview with Anna Kohler, Marco Bieri, Chairman of the Swiss Print Awards, discusses how the Swiss Print Awards are reinventing themselves and what it takes to do so.

m&k: Marco Bieri, wWhat is the current status of the Swiss Print Awards?Marco Bieri: The Swiss Print Award is still in its growth phase. It has not yet reached maturity. However, despite its young age, it is already well established and positioned. Of course, we hope to gain even more visibility, popularity, and recognition. 

Where are we going?

The journey has only just begun. We are on a long-haul flight. We will land in about 2 to 3 years. The leadership team has big plans to expand the Award Night and to revitalize participation in the Swiss Print Award. The six-member, independent, and autonomous jury, led by Christian Theiler, is working on new evaluation and judging criteria as well as the creation of new categories.

 

What does it take for the award to get the glamour it deserves?

Greater visibility and attention. But to achieve that, we need more partners and sponsors. Marketing costs money, after all! Expanding the Award Night also means more work and higher costs.

 

Who would you like to encourage to apply for one of the four categories?

Everyone involved in or connected to a print project. That means the end customer, the agency, graphic artists, designers, the print shop, and post-press service providers. We still have a lot of ground to make up when it comes to end customers, agencies, graphic artists, and designers! The Swiss Print Award is still not well known enough among them.

 

In just a few sentences, weave together a tribute to print, tactile quality, and ink.

Print can be loud. Print can be quiet. Print can convey every nuance in between. Print can let us see, hear, feel, and taste. Print engages all the senses. Those who skillfully play this range of possibilities add value to communication, enhance quality, support a company’s unique identity, and ensure the right image is conveyed. Print is alive! No other medium can express multisensory perception better than print. Print evokes emotions and creates added value. Yesterday, today, and tomorrow.


At Swiss Print Award Swiss companies and individuals who have carried out projects as contractors or who are client companies or individuals are eligible to participate. The projects must have been designed and carried out in Switzerland. The deadline for entries is April 30, 2022. 
 

Hour of rebirth

The successful restart of the trade fair and event industry after the 2021 summer break sends a convincing signal to the exhibiting industry: trade fairs are irreplaceable in marketing. Thanks to 3G, exhibitors and visitors can meet again without masks and look forward to their trade fair renaissance in 2022.

Michael Mätzener
(Image: Unsplash / Rodolfo Cuadros)

»At Art Basel in Basel, we finally rediscovered the pleasure of experiencing art in real life rather than through a screen,« explained an exhibitor in September 2021. »Finally, trade shows are back, and we’re making in-person connections with our buyers—and our order books are full. What more could you want?« said an exhibitor at Ornaris in August 2021. There’s no doubt about it: Now, after »online fatigue,” the business world wants to meet in person again. It needs trade shows once more.

Swissbau as a Barometer

In the trade fair sector, Swissbau in Basel, taking place from January 18 to 21, 2022, will serve as a barometer of sentiment among exhibitors and trade show visitors regarding the coming year. The number of exhibitors at Swissbau 2022 is expected to decline compared to 2019, as many exhibitors are still undecided about participating due to the pandemic.

This trend could shift after Swissbau 2022. Observers expect a large number of visitors to attend the trade show, and that could mark a turning point in the mistaken assumption that trade shows will be replaced by virtual platforms, providing a new, additional boost to the trade show format. The only uncertainty is the pandemic, which is still holding exhibitors back from committing to trade shows as a medium. However, 88 percent of industry professionals surveyed by Swissbau say that attending trade shows will remain a fixed date on their calendars. Of the 4,300 survey participants, nearly 90 percent even stated in August 2021 that they are looking forward to returning to Swissbau in 2022.

«I've never been so happy about a glass that's half full»

Statements like the one quoted at the beginning run like a common thread through the comments from exhibitors and visitors during the 2021 fall trade show season. Switzerland’s largest public trade fair, Olma, describes the event as a «successful relaunch with 220,000 visitors from October 7 to 17, 2021»—compared to 350,000 guests before the pandemic. This suggests that exhibitor and visitor numbers could return to pre-pandemic levels in the future. Olma Director Christine Bolt said at the press conference ahead of the event, «I’ve never been so happy about a glass that’s half full.».

The usual lines at the entrances were on display at Vitafoods, held October 5–7, 2021, at Palexpo in Geneva. From September 14 to 17, 2021, 530 exhibitors took part in the EPHJ technology trade show. Still, 12,000 visitors attended—compared to 20,000 in a typical trade show year.

«Now that people are getting tired of being online, the business world wants to meet in person again.»

A second, highly anticipated barometer for the Swiss—and even the international—trade show industry is the Geneva International Motor Show, which was canceled twice during the pandemic and has now been canceled for 2022 as well. People are now wondering whether—and in what form—it will ever return.

Auto Züri, once considered the «poor cousin» of the Motor Show, could be the big winner in this situation. After last year’s hiatus, it returned to Messe Zürich from November 4 to 7, 2021. The organizer used the pandemic-related hiatus to implement a completely new exhibition concept focused on functionality and sustainability.

A fresh start without a mask? Sure thing!

Exhibition centers were among the first to respond to the pandemic by developing their own safety and hygiene protocols. Thanks to the 3G rule (tested, vaccinated, recovered) and a well-thought-out hygiene plan, visitors can now attend virtually all trade shows without wearing a face mask. To gain access to Olma, visitors aged 16 and older were required to present a valid COVID certificate. Thanks to this solution, trade shows were able to operate in the fall of 2021—as was the case at all Swiss trade fair venues—without restrictive safety measures such as mandatory masks or social distancing rules.

«Event organizers have used the pandemic as an opportunity to develop entirely new concepts.»

Join the community in just three clicks

Despite the resurgence of trade shows, the topic of «digital expansion of trade shows» is finally being taken seriously by trade show organizers because, in the wake of the pandemic, they can no longer avoid it. This will not lead to trade shows being replaced as a medium. However, organizers must now take on the task of connecting their exhibitors and visitors more effectively. The Bernexpo Groupe masterfully demonstrated what networking means in the trade show industry at Sindex, held from August 30 to September 1, 2021. It used the COVID era and the time leading up to it to reposition itself digitally. At Sindex, visitors could connect with exhibitors and other attendees via the «Networking» menu—even on their smartphones—with just three clicks. At the same time, it enabled networking even without attending the trade show (!)—thereby breaking down the previous limitations of trade shows in terms of space (exhibition hall) and time (duration of the event).

At Ilmac, held in Basel from October 19 to 21, Conteo’s latest digital initiative (see interview)—the Ilmac Community—was launched. It is an example of what exhibitors and visitors can expect from trade shows: an industry hub available 365 days a year.

The digital events organized by Messe Luzern under the motto «Prepare digitally, meet in person,» such as AM-Expo and the Swiss MedTech Forum—which, due to the pandemic, will now take place simultaneously on September 14–15, 2021—were already established before the pandemic and had generated 42,000 page views just one week before the fair began. With 81,000 page views, the AM-Expo website became the central source of information and inspiration for visitors preparing for the trade show.

The Conclusion

During the pandemic, one thing has become clear: with a few exceptions, trade shows are irreplaceable for the economy. People want to meet in person again. Digital extensions of trade shows will serve as an important bridge to the live experience. But they won’t replace the handshake that seals a deal or the unexpected, unplanned event. Only live encounters can do that.


INTERVIEW

«Nothing in the world can replace face-to-face communication»

Michael Mätzener, owner and founder of «die Werbeartikel» and organizer of the «Markeding» festival for tactile advertising.

Michael Mätzener, organizer of the marke[ding] promotional products trade show and owner of the agency die werbeartikel, on the importance of tactile experience and the realization that messages on a screen simply fall flat these days.

m&k Expodata: Michael Mätzener, how has the COVID-19 pandemic affected the promotional products market?Michael Mätzener: The promotional products market has been severely affected. On the one hand, the industry is partly dependent on the events industry, since promotional products and giveaways are used there. On the other hand, global supply chains for promotional products are currently stalling. 

What does this mean for your company?

I’d like to speak here as the organizer of ­marke[ding]. The 2020 and 2021 editions both had to be postponed to August—and on both occasions, we saw a decline in both visitors and exhibitors. In response, we created a new platform called ­Digital marke(ding), but we quickly realized that nothing in the world can replace live communication, especially in the tactile world of advertising. People want to touch things to understand them. Attendance at the digital trade show was disappointing.

We are excited to host the trade show at the Kongresshaus Zürich in the future. This means it will be even more centrally located in the vibrant business hub of Zurich. We’re also rethinking a few things and will certainly go even further in adding value for visitors—for example, with workshops. Visitors have a lot to look forward to and will soon be able to register for free.

 

Will promotional items take on a different significance in the future than they have in the past?

The importance of haptic boosters—that is, promotional items—certainly remains a key element in advertising. However, there are certainly even more extensive—and increasingly deliberate—ways to engage customers, and to an even greater extent, employees, with a tactile message. After all, we all know that a message simply gets lost on a screen these days…

Marketing in 2022: Towards new horizons

Artificial Intelligence and Humanity, E-Commerce and Regionality, Personalization and the Slow Phase-Out of Cookies: What Does 2022 Have in Store? We highlight the most important trends, topics, and technologies on the marketing horizon, and have spoken with key industry representatives.

Marketing im Jahr 2022Be honest: Where are you buying your Christmas gifts this year? Online? Or at the little shop next door? Celebrating with a big group—or preferring a smaller gathering? Going vegetarian for the holiday meal, for the sake of the environment and your health? Our year has been shaped by the pandemic, which has changed us for the long term; it has brought classic themes like trust, local production, and humanity back into focus and accelerated other developments like a turbocharger. Welcome to the «New Normal»!

«The pandemic has accelerated growth in areas we couldn’t have imagined two years ago,» explains Peter Schäfer, Chief Strategy Officer and member of the Executive Board at Serviceplan Suisse. First and foremost, digital transformation, but also e-commerce and climate protection. On the following pages, we’ll show how this is reflected in marketing: the nine major marketing trends for 2022.

1. Digitization

The biggest trend and the biggest challenge in marketing in 2022—all in one. After all, digitalization brings not only enormous opportunities and possibilities, but also new challenges. According to the «Marketing Tech Monitor 2021» benchmark study, which examined companies« marketing technologies and strategies in the DACH region, while most companies have the will to undergo digital transformation, consistent action is often still lacking. »There needs to be a shift in resources,« says Serviceplan manager Peter Schäfer. Employee skills also play a key role: »It’s essential to have the right people. Everyone working in marketing or related fields must embrace and understand the ‘digital first’ mindset.”

2. Artificial Intelligence

AI (Artificial Intelligence) has been making headlines for several years now. But 2022 could be a pivotal year for the field, including in marketing. What can AI accomplish here? «It can analyze interactions to reveal previously undiscovered correlations and assess demand for services in real time to allocate resources and identify dynamic patterns among consumers,» says Schäfer. This represents enormous progress in marketing. AI could also play an increasingly significant role in content creation: «Artificial intelligence will permeate all areas of content creation in the coming years,» says Marco Schlauri, founder and CEO of the B2B SEO and content marketing agency Digital Leverage. AI can also support marketing efforts when it comes to optimizing budgets. A study by the University of Zurich and Nexoya showed that when it comes to optimizing campaigns, artificial intelligence is actually superior to humans.

3. Sustainability

Greenwashing? Not a chance. In 2022, consumers will be taking a closer look. «Sustainability is becoming a basic requirement and a growth driver. And by 2022 at the latest, it will no longer be a differentiating factor,» says Luitgard Hagl, Executive Creative Director and member of the executive board at Jung von Matt Limmat. After all, customers are increasingly expecting sustainable practices, and companies must act accordingly. «This issue will grow because of consumer needs—not because of corporate policy. Companies have no choice but to respond,» adds Peter Schäfer. And this goes hand in hand with another trend: the return to regionality. According to GfK, more than half of Swiss consumers would like to buy more from smaller suppliers and local producers in the future. But regionality doesn’t have to be limited to one’s own backyard, says Marcus Schögel, associate professor at the Institute for Marketing and Customer Insight (IMC-HSG), because regional brands and offerings do not automatically contradict globalization: «Brands are rooted locally and use that to establish a global presence as well.»

4. Personalization

More data, more possibilities. After all, the more you know about your consumers, the better you can address them individually—and that’s exactly what they increasingly expect. «The ever-greater availability of data is leading to an ever-more-precise segmentation of target groups. Individualized assets are deployed for virtually every micro-target group,» says Carsten Jamrow, Executive Creative Director and member of the executive board at Jung von Matt Limmat. The challenge here: «It’s becoming harder for brands to consistently reflect their brand essence across all touchpoints.» Colleague Luitgard Hagl adds: «…and at the same time, not losing sight of the quality of each individual, personalized asset. This is where agencies and marketers with a modern mindset and the ability to lead brands strongly and consistently will stand out. Not everyone has to see the same thing, but everyone has to feel the same brand.»

«A compelling corporate purpose will become even more important in the future. And the future begins in 2022.»

5. Humanity and Purpose

The pandemic has also brought the human factor back into focus. This means that customer relationships and customer loyalty are gaining in importance, as are issues such as diversity, inclusion, and gender. The reason: «Social distancing during the pandemic and new work models have made us increasingly aware of how important team spirit, people, and talent are,» says Serviceplan manager Peter Schäfer. Trust, authenticity, and emotions are also playing a greater role in communication once again. «More than ever, brand perception is determined by the connection between what is promised in advertising and what is ultimately delivered by the actual products and services,» explains Carsten Jamrow. And even if «we’re actually sick of hearing the word »purpose,«» as Sören Schröder, Creative Director and member of the executive board at Publicis Zurich, puts it, “unfortunately, that doesn’t change its relevance. Because more and more consumers expect brands to stand for something and embody a certain stance. Only then are brands able to support consumers in shaping their identities. A compelling corporate purpose—or sense of meaning—will therefore become even more important in the future.” And that starts in 2022.

6. Social Commerce

E-commerce was one of the hottest trends during the pandemic—and it’s here to stay, with ever-evolving variations. The latest trend is social commerce: If the customer can’t come to the product, the product must come to the customer. In this case, customers aren’t actively searching for a product; instead—just like when window shopping—they’re inspired by what they see on social media and can purchase products right there. «A huge growth opportunity,» says Peter Schäfer, «especially among Gen Z and millennials, both of whom are driven and motivated by influencer content.» Even though the scale may still be a long way from what’s possible in Asia when it comes to social commerce—2022 will bring significant changes here.

7. The Post-Cookie Era

Even though Google has postponed the end of cookies until 2023, the issue could already start to have a noticeable impact on marketing as early as 2022. Expert Alexander Igelsböck, co-founder and CEO of the marketing analytics platform Adverity, sees this as an opportunity: «Marketers and technology companies need to be prepared. They now have a little more time to align their targeting and measurement practices. Overall, this is a good thing for the user experience and data control. The transition means that advertisers will have to collect and use first-party data, which is a more robust targeting method anyway. It should lead to higher-quality ads and less irrelevant content. Ultimately, companies will need truly robust data governance to control and manage their data and enable data democratization.»

8. Voice Marketing

Although it was already hailed as a hot trend for the year that is coming to a close, voice marketing has not quite made its breakthrough yet. Perhaps 2022 will be the year of voice; Serviceplan expert Peter Schäfer, in any case, predicts «rapid growth in all areas of life.» However, he does not believe that voice will replace offline and online shopping. The Swiss are, in any case, relatively open to voice functions: According to the «Voice First Barometer,» a representative study on voice user interfaces conducted by the University of Lucerne, one in two Swiss people were already using voice user interfaces at the beginning of the year; 30 percent use them as part of their purchasing decision-making process. Alexa, we’re excited to see what 2022 brings!

9. Live Formats

Whether it’s live videos on TikTok, live shopping events, or livestreams on Instagram: New features are constantly emerging that enable brands to connect with consumers live and directly. What Chinese internet giants have already successfully pioneered is also growing increasingly in Europe. Live-stream shopping with interactive and chat features could become an exciting sales channel in 2022.


Into the Future with «I-N-S-P-O-P»We asked Publicis Zurich to take a look into the crystal ball. What does 2022 have in store? The result is an exciting concept with the catchy name «I-N-S-P-O-P.» With this thematic framework, the agency summarizes the key drivers of marketing trends that no one will be able to ignore in the future. The three major trends in consumer behavior (I-N-S) are mirrored by three major developments in marketing (P-O-P): individualization, sustainability, and meaning on the consumer side, and—in contrast—personalization, omni-channel experience, and purpose on the marketing side.

B2B Commerce: It's Now or Never!

Online commerce in the business-to-business sector is gaining tremendous momentum. Those who fail to adapt are putting their success at risk.

B2B-Commerce
(Image: Unsplash.com / Werner Du Plessis)
B2B commerce is gaining momentum rapidly. According to the PwC study «The Evolving Customer: The Future of B2B Commerce,» e-commerce will be the most important area of investment for 65 percent of companies over the next two years. From January to August 2020, B2B orders placed via e-commerce solutions increased by 44 percent, and most B2B executives expect sales through digital channels to account for more than half of their business over the next two years. In reality, change takes time. Companies should plan carefully and proceed step by step to successfully overcome these challenges.

Resist change or embrace it?

As a rule, we encounter two types of B2B companies: those resistant to change and those that are digitally savvy. Our change-resistant clients wonder whether modern B2B commerce is really right for them. They doubt the value of investing in online commerce and intend to continue selling through their distributors and wholesalers, just as they always have. They want to manage their customer relationships themselves and resist change—or even believe that their customers neither need nor want it.

Some customers who are resistant to change view B2B commerce merely as a marketplace where the goal is to distribute more goods to more sales locations. Others want to dominate the entire marketplace and involve only their own partners. A third subgroup, which includes large multinational companies, offers such a wide variety of brands that it sees no way out of its complex system. It is therefore trying to improve its current analog approach.

Then there are B2B customers who are 100 percent committed to online commerce. They have laid the groundwork for it but are not generating enough added value. They want to develop digital capabilities that will enable them to support their customers across the full spectrum of their business needs. These companies realize that most B2B sales interactions will shift to digital channels over the coming decade—and that new technologies will not only fundamentally change the way they find and retain customers and bring products and services to market, but will also fundamentally transform their supply chains.

Customer expectations are changing rapidly, whether companies resistant to change like it or not. The shift of retail to the internet had already begun before the outbreak of the COVID-19 virus; the pandemic has accelerated this transformation. Customers have discovered 24/7 service, seamless omnichannel journeys, and personalized experiences—a compelling combination. They now expect this experience not only in the B2C world but also in B2B business.

A Strategy for Every Channel

Many of our clients who are resistant to change actually know that digital transformation is crucial to their survival. But they hope the problem will simply go away if they ignore it or put it off. However, those who have not yet embarked on customer-centric transformation are already falling behind—slowly at first, then at an ever-increasing pace.

Our tech-savvy customers who have jumped on the B2B commerce bandwagon know that the transition to B2B online commerce involves significant challenges and takes time. However, the benefits of an e-commerce model are too compelling to ignore. When used correctly, digital B2B channels open up many new opportunities: lower service costs, greater value for customers, an expanded customer base, more loyal customers, real-time feedback, and cross-selling and upselling with segmented and personalized offers.

«Online retail isn't just another opportunity; it's inevitable—customers are demanding it.»

The fact is, there is neither a one-size-fits-all solution nor a perfect channel. For the future of data-driven omnichannel sales, a strategy must be developed for each channel. This means combining online and offline channels in a way that offers customers the convenience they need and allows each channel to remain profitable and deliver added value. It’s also not enough to simply digitize product catalogs and provide basic online sales functionality. To stand out from the competition, B2B retailers must focus on the customer and their true needs. Companies must align their processes with their customers and ensure they can deliver on their promises. They should view the digital commerce model as an integrated business function that establishes a genuine connection with customers and simplifies their lives.

Challenges and opportunities

The development of a new retail platform also has an impact on existing distribution channels and networks. This can lead to conflicts with retailers that aren’t a good fit, but it can also enable a new mix of online and offline retail. Some distributors have developed digital solutions that meet the needs of both manufacturers and end consumers. As companies embark on their B2B journey, they must ask themselves: «Are my suppliers ready to go down this path with me?» The changing dynamics of distribution channels necessitate decisions: With which distributors should the partnership continue, and with which should it not? How does the new business model affect inventory management? How are relationships with retailers changing? Which third-party B2B marketplaces offer attractive sales opportunities, and how can they be leveraged? In any case, companies must work closely with retailers and suppliers to ensure that they can fully meet the new requirements.

Online commerce isn’t just another «significant opportunity» for B2B companies. It’s inevitable; customers are demanding it. Companies are under immense pressure to navigate the transition to the virtual marketplace «correctly,» and the disruption that comes with it is very real. But B2B e-commerce is worth it. Companies can increase their market reach and impact, improve sales effectiveness, delight customers, and gain a significant competitive advantage over rivals. Furthermore, B2B e-commerce could drive digital transformation at many companies and pave the way for a future-oriented business model.


INTERVIEW

«What happens if you don't change?»

Carl Haynie, Director of Customer-Centric Transformation at PwC Switzerland, on the challenges of B2B commerce.m&k: Why should companies digitize their B2B commerce?Carl Haynie: B2B e-commerce is booming because customers are demanding it. They have become so accustomed to seamless customer experiences in B2C retail—think of Amazon or Galaxus—that they expect similar experiences in their B2B interactions. Companies need to reassess what their customers want. Perhaps it’s greater transparency in the procurement process and order management, or a wider range of offerings in the self-service portal. Once you understand your customers’ needs, you’ll know where to invest when building a digital commerce solution.

 

What are the biggest challenges facing B2B companies?

Typically, this involves complex legacy systems and conflicts between sales channels that make the transition difficult. Then there are companies that fear e-commerce solutions will cannibalize their existing business. To these companies, I ask: «What happens if you don’t change?»

 

How can companies set themselves apart from the competition?

It’s worth keeping an eye on certain trends, such as B2B marketplaces or headless commerce. With a headless commerce platform, for example, companies and brands can decouple their backend from the frontend and link the standalone components in a way that leads to a better customer experience. But the most successful companies are those that truly understand their customers and their needs and then place them at the center of their transformation.

 

What approach should companies take when it comes to data security?

This is an important question, because a fully digital journey can increase the number of potential points of vulnerability—and every cyberattack poses a costly risk. Implementing technologies and controls to protect customer data is a central part of any transformation.


Would you like to learn more? Then download the PwC Study on the Future of B2B Commerce Scroll down to see the detailed results.

Swiss: Up from here

Swiss International has suffered massively from the Corona pandemic. Now the airline has given itself new structures - including in marketing: Caroline Drischel and Stefan Vasic are now in charge. A double interview.

Swiss Doppelinterview
(Photo: Chris Reist)

m&k: Stefan Vasic, before you 2021 Head of Marketing at Swiss While you were with the airline, your responsibilities included managing sponsorship partnerships. 2020 was supposed to be a «sports year» for your company—but then the pandemic hit. How challenging was that period?

Stefan Vasic: We had to react incredibly quickly—we had to find ways to address not only the new financial demands but also the staffing needs. On the other hand, we were determined to try to retain at least part of our broad partner portfolio. In the end, we reduced Swiss’s sponsorship activities by a third, which was often difficult. At the same time, I learned a great deal from this involuntary learning experience.

 

Caroline Drischel, as Head of Brand Experience, you had to walk a tightrope—between customers who were canceling trips en masse and the few who continued to fly with Swiss. How much does something like that take a toll on a brand?

Caroline Drischel: The term «balancing act» describes it quite well: Anyone who flew with us during the height of the pandemic should have experienced us as a confident brand; they should have been able to trust our hygiene standards, our customer focus, and our flexibility. On the other hand, those who—and unfortunately, this was a huge number of people—had to cancel their trips should have been «taken care of» by our service staff. Even when frustration and anger were, at times, extremely high. In both cases, our company was—and still is—called upon to deliver on its «brand promise»; this is where it becomes clear whether customer focus is just an empty phrase or something we truly live by. It’s no walk in the park, and we haven’t put the crisis behind us yet.

 

Specifically, what expectations did you encounter from your passengers?

Drischel: Over the past few years, we’ve focused heavily on the «upper funnel» and sharpened our brand. We emphasized values like inspiration, passion, and emotion. Then, suddenly, everything had to be purely fact-based. The customer who wanted to fly needed to know: What happens next? What do I need to bring with me? They relied on us to help them. And we had to learn to understand this shift in customer focus internally as well. As a result, we engaged in more direct customer communication than ever before.

Vasic: To put it simply, an airline «only» transports people from one place to another. Before the pandemic, entry requirements for individual countries were the responsibility of each traveler and a relatively static matter. At the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, however, passengers’ expectations changed in such a way that we, as an airline, were obligated to be fully informed: What do I need if I want to go to Spain? What if I’m returning to Switzerland from Turkey? We quickly recognized this need and took steps to meet it.

 

What lessons have you learned from this new responsibility, which was essentially imposed on you?

Drischel: The fact that Stefan Vasic and I hold the positions we have today is also related to a reorganization of the entire marketing, product, and customer service division. Even before the pandemic, the Lufthansa Group, as our parent company, had recognized that we weren’t operating with a strong enough customer focus. The pandemic was the catalyst we needed to finally integrate marketing, products, and services more closely.

Vasic: The impact of the pandemic on travel has taken a heavy toll on all of us, but especially on our guests. That is why it is our stated goal to do everything we can to remain in the hearts of our customers—and, more broadly, in the hearts of the Swiss people. At the same time, as a company, we want to—and must—generate revenue and ticket sales. For the time being, the Swiss marketing department will no longer carry out any campaigns that do not contribute to one or the other of these goals.

 

Also, because the current situation means you have to operate on a limited budget …

Vasic: The next two or three years will be all about maximizing cost efficiency. What we absolutely cannot afford is wasted reach. So we ask ourselves: What spontaneous opportunities can we take advantage of? We’ve even coined a special term for it: «instant marketing»! (laughs) To illustrate, I like to use the example of Euro 2024 «superfan» Luca Loutenbach: It was my social media team that recognized the potential and the effort required to capitalize on his viral photos within thirty minutes. And it took less than an hour for the «superfan» to have his plane ticket to the next Switzerland game. Big impact for a small investment: that’s what we have to keep achieving time and again.

Drischel: That was truly a wonderful story. It made many customers feel: «They see me! In the eyes of my airline, I’m first and foremost a person, not just a number!» That must be our guiding principle in everything we do.

«The next two or three years will be characterized by maximum cost efficiency.»

 

In the past, you were able to set yourself apart from low-cost competitors through large-scale branding campaigns. Wasted coverage or not, you invested enormous resources in those campaigns. Will a radical focus on the customer now become your new unique selling proposition?

Drischel: I’ll mention a few keywords that represent what we want to stand for in the future: «Trusted Servicing,» «Carefree Travel,» «Tailored Offering,» and «Dialog.» Are we already achieving this one hundred percent? No, unfortunately not yet. But we’re on the right track. You can always tell when you talk to friends and ask, «So, how was your flight?» In the past, it was always about the seat or the food; that’s what people would talk about. Today, it’s about whether I had a worry-free trip and whether everything went smoothly. That’s what our customers expect today, and that’s what we need to deliver.

 

What does this mean for the advertising campaigns you plan to run in the future?

Vasic: We are currently rolling out a marketing campaign designed to help our guests rediscover the true value of travel. And that value is as individual as each person’s own values. Especially in difficult times, the motto should be: «Travel is what you make of it.» Swiss is here to support people in that journey.

«But we have another dream: to be the airline in Europe that combines a perfect customer experience with certified sustainability.»

Current Swiss themes: rediscovering the value of travel. (Photos: courtesy of the publisher.)

You have clearly outlined your tasks for the near future. What are the plans for the «post-coronavirus» era?

Drischel: We share a problem with many other airlines: We don’t know our customers well enough. We have to ask them every single time what their preferences are and where they’d like to fly. We have to ask for their credit card number. That’s why creating detailed customer profiles will be a major, important project. But not because we want to market to them, but because we truly want to get to know our passengers. And because we no longer want to ask on board, «Would you like your water with or without carbonation?» Our cabin crew should already be able to tell when someone boards. Or imagine you’re returning from a business trip to South Africa, and the cabin manager on your connecting flight asks you: «You’ve been traveling for a long time—would you prefer just a light dinner and then some sleep?» By the way, we’re not just thinking about frequent flyers, but also about people who travel with us to Mallorca only once a year. Their preferences are important, too.

Vasic: And that, in turn, affects the offerings we promote in our marketing. I can’t offer a first-class flight for one person to a family of four just because I don’t know that behind the profile there’s actually … a family of four. (laughs). That, too, is part of the issue of wasted coverage. And the better we know the customer, the better we’ll be able to provide that customer with relevant information.

Drischel: But we have another dream: to be the airline in Europe that combines a perfect customer experience with certified sustainability. We don’t want sustainability to remain just a buzzword; we’re serious about it. In the medium term, we want customers, investors, and independent auditors to confirm that no one does this better than we do. Everything we do should be completely transparent—where the water in the cups comes from and the cardboard used to make them; where we source our food for in-flight meals; and what we’re doing to offset our CO2 emissions. We still have a lot of work ahead of us, but we’re extremely motivated to get it done.


Caroline Drischel has been Head of Brand Experience at Swiss since February 2021. In this role, she is responsible for the strategic roadmap for all customer, product, and marketing matters at the airline; previously, she held leadership positions at Lufthansa, Swiss Re, UBS, and Renault, among others.

Stefan Vasic He has been Head of Marketing at Swiss since July 2021 and is responsible for implementing all marketing initiatives as part of the global Lufthansa Group strategy. Previously, he headed the Sponsorship & Events department at Swiss, among other roles, and also served as the airline’s media spokesperson for several years.

David Schärer: Mister Advertising

David Schärer has won the title of «Advertiser of the Year» for 2021/22. As a co-founder of the agency Rod Kommunikation, he and his team are, among other things, implementing the COVID-19 campaigns with the FOPH. m&k Werbewoche.ch congratulates the winner and «spotlights» him.

David Schärer
David Schärer is "Advertiser of the Year" 2021/22. (Image: Chris Reist)

It is his victory. He has worked hard for it. The Basel native has already been nominated four times for Advertiser of the Year. "I'm the Leonardo Di Caprio of advertising," is his comment when Petra Dreyfus wins the race in 2019. But just as Di Caprio eventually won the Oscar for "The Revenant," Schärer is now winning the "Egon," the statue that originally got its name from the word ego, based on the rumor that advertisers have a very large one. But these are old stories. And they have nothing to do with David Schärer. Because if anyone is on fire for the cause and puts his own ego behind him, it's David Schärer.

A look behind the scenes

As passionately as he talks about campaigns, philosophy and politics, he never puts his own person in the spotlight. The role of a communications consultant is fundamentally different from communicating as a private person. He felt this, he says, when he appeared on the TV show Arena, at the beginning of the pandemic. "The role of consultant is easier for me," he says. What made him the advertiser he is today? David became fascinated with advertising at an early age. Graphics and design seem like a way into the industry for him; but after two years, he drops out of design school and turns to public relations. An internship at Theater Basel and then seven years at Jung von Matt Limmat followed.

"There is sometimes something objectionable about the term advertising; I think it's unwarranted."

With Regula Bührer Fecker and Oliver Fennel, he founds the Rod communications agency in 2007. No sooner had they moved into the new office than Rod became the agency for Sanitas, which it served for four years in all communications disciplines. A successful start, which David Schärer does not regret to this day. "We have now been connected for more than a decade, not only in business, but also as friends." For him, this is one of the main reasons that Rod has been able to position itself so successfully on the market.

This year, the "Egon" goes to David Schärer.

The Spin Doctor

This designation suits him, says David. Because the communications professional is passionate about developing campaigns that are close to his heart. But without media reach, even the best campaign is of no use. And so David Schärer is a master of public relations. He understands what makes people tick, is empathetic, accessible and, when required, uncompromisingly honest. The task of working with the FOPH to shape Corona's communications is and has been challenging. "It's like flying on sight, we're always anticipating what's important in the next two weeks." He by no means describes his work as creative art in this regard. "What we do is purpose-driven, so it should be an answer to a communications problem."

Deserved victory

The members of the jury, composed of former Advertisers of the Year, people from academia and the nominees of previous years, as well as representatives from French-speaking Switzerland, nominated David Schärer of Rod, Andrea Bison of Thjnk and Maurizio Rugghia of SiR MaRY as candidates for Advertiser:in of the Year in August this year. (Werbewoche.ch reported). From these three people, each jury member had to vote for one candidate, submit this in writing to the editors. The weighting of the jury is 50 percent. The other 50 percent of the voting took place online. For one week, the readers of the Werbewoche newsletter voted for their favorite. The result was clear: David Schärer dominated both the jury voting and the online voting.

We congratulate David Schärer on winning the title of "Advertiser of the Year 2021/22". Next year we will suspend the election. In 2023, the next election will take place. This traditionally again in March. Due to the Corona pandemic, we are out of rhythm.


Laudation by Adrian Kammer, Head of Campaigns at the Federal Office of Public Health

David Schärer: office worker and strategist, amplifier and seducer


March 2020. The Corona threat is drawing ever closer. Pictures of the hearses of Bergamo arouse fears. The Federal Council urges the population to stay at home. And outside: glorious spring weather beckons.

Only shortly before, the Federal Office of Public Health (FOPH) commissioned the Rod agency to jointly manage the pandemic campaign. It was the only one of those approached that was able to activate the necessary competencies and resources from the outset. Right at the front: David Schärer. And what does he do at this tipping point? He is getting on the nerves of all weather stations in Switzerland, so that they also take their responsibility and let everyone know: This Easter is taking place inside and at a distance.

The anecdote is not very spectacular. It is intentional. Because David doesn't just turn up the speaker to Volume 10 when he promises a "Bigger Bang for the buck", but tinkers with the question of how the message learns to run with bite and verve. Amplification is the magic word.

The Swiss advertising world has known for some time that David is a virtuoso in this art. And although you are also a gifted communicator in your own right, I was amazed at how unpretentious your performance is when I was tracking you down. You manage to deliver razor-sharp analysis and pointed announcements without being pejorative or hurtful. It pops, but it doesn't hurt.

Swiss master in generating attention you were called or also "the string puller". You find spin doctor a fitting description yourself, advertiser too. After all, "attracting attention is our core business."Advertising is more than just pitching or imposing. Advertising is seduction. And therefore an art, because the seduced person does not want to be seduced, but wants to feel seen and taken seriously.But you don't want to be an artist. Because "what we do is purposeful". Yes, contrary to all clichés, you do not commit yourself to the beautiful appearance, but to the real effect of your work.

As a client, it is also our duty to get the greatest possible reach out of every tax penny invested. You make that easy for us. But not easy. Time and again, you confront, probe, drill deeper. Yes, dear David, you deserve the title of "Advertiser of the Year" also thanks to your courage to be an imposition at times.

The pandemic has changed campaign work. During our nightly - mostly virtual - fireside chats, we not only shared observations, sketched out ideas and cooked up strategies, but also consciously reflected on what it means when the lines between client and client become visibly blurred. That was our only chance in this completely new kind of crisis. We had to inform the population so well that they would behave in a way that was good for Switzerland. The fact that "One Campaigning Team" can be lived in real terms is something I have never experienced before - and extremely appreciated.

In your youth you were a punk. I think the punk in you is still alive. Of course, he has grown up. Drinks Bordeaux from a goblet instead of beer from a bottle. But he is still a moving one. And a moving one. Versatilely engaged. With a strong urge to keep his finger on the pulse of society. To develop it further. Not restless. But also never completely satisfied with what is. Because much more could be.

14 years after Rod was founded, you are today receiving your "Egon", the Advertiser of the Year award. I congratulate you from the bottom of my heart - and know that your modesty will not be corrupted even by this award.

"So machemers."


Also nominated were ...

Andrea Bison, Co-Founder Thjnk Zurich

Five years ago, Andrea Bison founded thjnk together with Alexander Jaggy. Previously, she worked in Hamburg at Jung von Matt, Springer & Jacoby, kempertrautmann and thjnk. This is already her second nomination as advertiser:in of the year. In the online voting, she was in second place behind David Schärer. To be among the three nominees at all is an unmistakable sign of being perceived as outstanding by the industry, advertising clients and readers of the trade press. "We've managed to create great campaigns for some very exciting brands that have really made a difference. That's our primal drive, to accompany brands on their journey and give shape to them through ideas and end up touching people with them." And they do.

Thjnk has just won gold with the Denner ad "Alles da. Immer nah" in the category "Commercials up to 90 seconds". Who doesn't know the commercial in which the baby in diapers runs to the Denner to fill the empty refrigerator at home? It is children who inspire Andrea Bison, because they "don't have scissors in their heads yet". Children would see no limits and have a free spirit. Asked whether she sees herself more as a service provider or a seductress, she remains pragmatic. "Even the greatest seductress wants to achieve a good result in the end." In that respect, she says, you can't pick it apart. The Swiss by choice is a mother of three and lives with her family in Zurich.

Maurizio Rugghia, Co-Founder Sir Mary

Maurizio Rugghia has been leading the Sir Mary agency as co-founder and co-owner since 2016. Previously, he was Managing Director and Partner of the digital agency Serranetga for five years. There he met his current business partners, Daniel Zuberbühler and Florian Beck. After five years at Serranetga, it was time for something new; the others felt the same way. And since none of them wanted to continue alone, they decided to "build" a modern agency model from "scratch".

Sir Mary was launched in 2016. Rugghia feels the foundation is a "piece of cake." The trick, he says, is to keep the thing going. Letting it grow. Loving the process. Growing from every challenge. It's "management of madness" - in the most positive sense! "But every day is different for us. We do everything we can to keep reinventing ourselves. Never standing still and always staying hungry. You really have to want to do that," he says. Does that correspond to his lifestyle? Yes, it does, without hesitation. He loves creating new things, seeing ideas manifest and come to life.

In addition, there is an aversion to authority. A what? He laughs. "I have the urge inside me to determine my own day and activities. And ultimately, I'm fascinated by people. I want to work with people who inspire me and are smarter than me. By starting up, I get to live all of that out. I get to be an entrepreneur and I get to combine it with my passion for exciting communication. And work with the most exciting personalities I know."

Maurizio Rugghia is married, father of two children and lives with his family in Zurich.

Creativity is not democratic

Why Pretests Don't Fill Stadiums.

KreativitätNo, I don’t even want to get into that. It’s too absurd. All right… let’s indulge in this line of thought: The Stones are holding a group discussion with a small, select portion of their audience, debating what a song is called or which one will make it onto the new album. Scene change: Dalí is discussing with his fans whether it makes sense for clocks to melt like wax. The hand-picked small groups are bribed with apple spritzer, sandwiches, and 50 francs. Absurd, exactly.Admittedly, there may have been a brief discussion among the Stones—internally, of course—but more so to make Charlie (R.I.P.) and Ron feel like they had a say. In the end, though, it was probably Keith and Mick who made the decision. One thing is certain, however: the audience was definitely not asked which song would make it onto the next album.

Pretests in Advertising

Of course, advertising can’t be compared to art in every respect. And yet there are overlaps: first and foremost, of course, creativity—ideally, the creation of something truly new, something that, at its best, touches people, makes them laugh, and/or provides a “aha” moment in a surprising way. The truly crucial point, however, is that people choose to look at art because they think it’s awesome. And that, in my view, is exactly where advertising needs to return.

Instead, in pre-tests, people are forced to view the campaigns and offer their opinions and evaluations. This is where the crucial mistake lies: One of the most important disciplines and tasks of creative advertising is to capture attention—or, as it’s called these days, «stopping power.».

Anyone who doesn't even bother to look at the poster, the movie, or whatever else «out in the wild» won't form an opinion about the brand, product, or service. And therefore won't form a positive one either.

The Courage to «Let Things Happen»

My conclusion isn’t new, but I’d like to reiterate it here on behalf of many fantastic colleagues: Creative—and therefore effective—advertising takes courage. But not just the courage to do something bold, but also the courage to trust your intuition—the courage to let someone with a lot of experience (or, as they say these days, a “track record”) take the lead up to a certain point. Of course, this must be done in very close collaboration with the clients, because there are at least as many fantastic experts on the so-called client side as there are on the agency side.

More Keith and Mick

This kind of courage requires mutual trust. That’s why I’m appealing to everyone: How about if agencies and clients just acted a little more like Keith and Mick? Of course, we could certainly debate who ends up being which of the two. But the satisfaction on both sides would surely be much greater. And the audience would be thrilled.


* Manuel Wenzel, Creative Director at TBWA\Zurich, will be “Wenzel-ing” us in the upcoming print issues of m&k. What does that mean? We’re not quite sure yet, which is exactly why we love it. The advertising industry has a skewed image among the general public—and Wenzel believes that needs to be set straight. We’re excited to see what happens.
This article first appeared in the m&k Print Edition 10/2021.

Michael Conrad: Can advertising still be saved?

Michael Conrad was Chief Creative Officer at Leo Burnett Worldwide, President of the Cannes Lions International Festival of Creativity, and a businessman. How does he view today’s communications industry? And what needs to change for it to remain viable?

Michael Conrad
Michael Conrad was Chief Creative Officer at Leo Burnett Worldwide, President of the Cannes Lions International Festival of Creativity, and a businessman. (Illustration: Silvan Borer)

m&k: Michael Conrad, let's begin this conversation with a question that echoes the title of a bestseller by Howard Luck Gossage: Can advertising still be saved?

Michael Conrad: I think advertising can always be saved. The question is whether our industry can be saved. 

 

That's a bold statement. Could you elaborate on that?

When I look at how the agency business works today—and how many specialists advertising companies often have to work with these days; how much coordination that requires—I ask myself: Where has the primacy of the simple idea gone, the one that directs and drives all the elements? You know, one of my most effective approaches for establishing companies, brands, and then their products has been a one-word strategy. A single word that describes a company’s focus or sums up what it aims to achieve. This could be a phrase like «Vorsprung durch Technik,» which my friend John Hegarty used back then to help Audi redefine itself—or «Safe,» which still symbolizes the Volvo brand. Once you’ve distilled your mission down to that essence, you have a solid foundation … rather than the unnecessary fragmentation so common today.

 

Was everything really better in the advertising industry a few years or decades ago, or is there a bit of nostalgia at play here?

No, this isn’t nostalgia. Take a look at the structures we had back then in leading agencies around the world: Almost everywhere, strong creative minds were at the helm—people who also thought like entrepreneurs. And on the other side were clients who were willing to pay a fair price for exceptional work. We were able to generate very impressive revenue, but we didn’t pocket it (laughs)—instead, we used to reinvest it in the agency and our clients to boost our competitiveness. Incidentally, many creatives at the helm of agencies also followed a one-word strategy when it came to their personal branding: Hegarty’s guiding principle was usually «Irreverence»—a healthy dose of «disrespect» with which he rejuvenated brands. Bogusky’s «Baked-In» brought clients« products to life in their communications. And mine: »Thought-provoking.”.

 

Are such top-tier creative professionals a dying breed?

As I said, the question is really more about who is willing to pay for their work today. Is outstanding creativity—and the time it takes—still valued, even in a prosperous country like Switzerland? I’ve been thinking about what I liked in Swiss advertising over the past year, and I brought the ADC book with me (points to a stack of papers). It’s so thin—it’s never been this thin before! By the way—what wasn’t included, and that surprised me, was the film by Wirz for «My Switzerland.».

 

You mean the campaign with Roger Federer and Robert De Niro?

Yeah. Brilliant. Absolutely brilliant. You can watch that thing over and over and over again. How many times has that YouTube video been viewed? Over 50 million times!

 

The most successful campaign Maestro Federer has ever done as a brand ambassador …

Brilliantly written, down to the last detail. Just look at De Niro standing at the window in his underwear, gazing out at the skyline! And then there’s that one-word strategy again: In the clip, Switzerland is positioned as «boring»! It takes courage to label something like that. That’s exactly what creativity is all about—the courage to go beyond the norm. I have to take a risk here. I can’t back all of this up with research beforehand.

Michael Conrad became a «water taster» for Haig whiskey—and appeared on «Tagesschau.».

How can the advertising industry—including in Switzerland—encourage clients to allocate larger budgets again, which can then be used to support outstanding creativity?

There are examples that work and point the way forward. Take R/GA in New York, for instance—they combine consulting and design and are highly sought-after as service providers, especially among startups. That’s a clever idea anyway: Consulting firms have become a real problem for the advertising industry—consultants with access to the CEO come in and say they’ll handle communications directly. They’re then given a mandate, but what do they really know about communication? (laughs) Advertising agencies shouldn’t let this business be taken away from them.

 

I’d now like to talk a little about your own path into the industry. You entered the world of advertising more by chance and out of curiosity—after an eventful youth marked by experiences of fleeing your home country and economic hardship. Did this real-life experience later make you a better advertising professional?

Nope.

 

Not a good question?

Well, that’s a good question. It’s something to think about. But I’ve actually been set up for success my whole life, and here and there—often without even realizing it—I’ve scored a goal. For example: I once asked my mother why we left Leipzig in 1952. She replied that, as a child, I had told her how we’d learned the phrase «Bow your heads, think of Stalin» at school. And then she said, «We have to get out of here.» If she hadn’t left—and many people did stay in the GDR—how would my life have turned out? Maybe I would have done advertising for Honecker; I have no idea. (laughs)

«What would my life have been like in the GDR? Maybe I would have done advertising for Honecker.»

 

Are advertisers, by their very nature, suited to be propagandists?

Of course. Propaganda is our business. I wouldn’t even distinguish between the two. Advertising means promoting something or someone. What’s the difference between that and propaganda? That said, after the «Lürzer, Conrad» European campaign for the German FDP in the 1970s, we stopped doing political advertising—and we later established that policy globally at Burnett as well. Communication with the party leadership—and especially with then-Secretary General Verheugen—wasn’t of the quality we would have liked. Strategically, we found him lacking, a point that Count Lambsdorff later confirmed to me—rather angrily—over lunch in Chicago. In 1979, we had proposed a set of principles to the FDP that, two years later, led to the formation of the Green Party—as you can see, the two parties are now engaged in coalition talks (laughs).

 

It's interesting that you say that. Because one might think that advertising exerts a very real influence in the political sphere—and that that can be fascinating?

But then populism also plays a role … and we’ve seen what happened with Trump. It’s truly appalling how people can be manipulated.

Conrad Success for «Wasa»: Eating and Living More Consciously.

As Burnett’s global creative director, you lived in Chicago for a long time. When you look at the U.S. today, do you still recognize the country? Is this still «your» United States?

The two camps—Republicans on one side, Democrats on the other—have actually always existed. But it wasn’t as confrontational. The whole Trump affair really irritated me. I could never have imagined that something like that was even possible. It was, after all, a level of thuggery unlike anything else. When the pandemic started, the guy told the country, «Don’t take this so seriously!» And in the same breath, he advised his friends on Wall Street to pull out of the stock market before it crashed because of the pandemic. That this politically incompetent person, who tried to apply his business practices to an entire nation, was able to stay in office for so long…

 

Would you say that populism works so well because populists are able to convey simpler messages?

Absolutely. We’re sitting here together in Zurich now, but you only need to look at the AfD in Germany. Take a look at how they operate, and how they’re allowed to operate: In 2020, nearly 17 billion euros were spent on integration in Germany, but how was that communicated to the public? How much was spent on integration communication? Very little to nothing, I think. This gives the populists of the AfD the opportunity to claim, virtually unchallenged, that migrants are endangering the common good.

 

From a campaign strategy perspective, should right-wing populism be countered with left-wing populism?

In any case, you have to be competitive. How to achieve that isn’t so easy to answer. To be a little more specific: Would I have a problem calling an opposing policy “anti-social” if I’ve branded my own policy as “social”? No—under certain circumstances, that might even be a good idea. At the very least, it gets people thinking. Because it gives them something to take issue with.

A new color every month: «Campaign of the Year.».

Can advertising use humor to make people think—without veering into the infamous «Sauglattism»?

Jokes are good, but they must always serve to convey a message—to point toward a deeper insight.

 

What advice would you give to young people who are interested in a career in advertising today?

I would recommend to them exactly what Walter Lürzer advised me back then: reading three books. Howard Luck Gossage’s *Can Advertising Be Saved?*, Ogilvy’s *Confessions of an Advertising Man*, and Rosser Reeves’s *Advertising Without Myths*, which established the concept of the Unique Selling Proposition. And then maybe you should do what I did back then—and try out different things with a real enthusiasm for the new. Also, as mundane as it may sound: you should try to have fun.

«I never went into advertising with the goal of becoming a creative director one day.»

 

And how can agencies tell if potential employees have real potential?

I once had a very interesting conversation about this with Gene Kranz, who led the Apollo 13 mission. They had that problem in space, of course. And Kranz’s team recreated the situation down on the ground in a capsule, overcame the challenge, and then told the crew in space what the solution was. I asked Gene Kranz: How do you go about selecting people? What are your criteria?’ He said, «Look, I’m presented with people who’ve been screened—they’re all technically capable of doing the job. But then I want to know: Does this person want to do something, or does this person want to be something? And then I make my decision.»

 

For people who want to make a difference.

Yes. And that’s what I’d tell the young people. If you’re excited about advertising, what exactly excites you about it? The company you’re applying to—what excites you about it? Why do you want to work there? Do you know exactly what they do, and do you have any idea why? I never went into advertising with the goal of becoming a creative director one day. I was just happy if I could even finish the jobs I was given. (laughs) And then I just happened to end up doing some crazy stuff—working outside the norm.

«Villiger» campaign by Lürzer, Conrad for *Der Spiegel*: Conversations over a cigar.

Which campaigns have particularly excited you?

I had a lot of fun right at the start of my career when I was involved in a campaign for Haig whiskey. First, we asked ourselves: How do Germans actually drink their whiskey? Well, they like to dilute it with water. Okay, but how good is that water? People use tap water, after all. So we ran a campaign that highlighted how Haig has been around for over 300 years—that a lot of passion goes into it—and we didn’t want Germans to ruin all that hard work with bad tap water: «A Haig must stay just the way it is. So send us samples; we’ll taste the water and let you know whether you can use it or not.»

 

So what happened then?

About 600 samples came in. And I also got a call from ZDF. They asked, «Are you the water taster?» Of course, I said yes. Then they wanted to film me—I agreed to that idea as well. They didn’t realize at all that we were just pursuing an advertising concept; they thought we were completely serious about it.

 

And then the TV crew came by?

Yeah, I hung up and my first thought was: «Shit, what do I do now?» (laughs) We then went with the TV crew to Walter Lürzer’s penthouse—he was on vacation at the time—where there was a really bizarre tower clock, and there was a long table that we’d set with glasses. I tested a water sample from Heidelberg very thoroughly—including a control test and lengthy explanations of what I was doing and why. At the end of the ZDF news broadcast in which this segment aired, anchorman Hajo Friedrichs said: «Isn’t it great that we still have people on Earth who look after our daily well-being? We’re now switching over to Houston, Texas, to cover the moon landing.»

«The opportunity to make a difference in the industry is still there—even from Switzerland.»

 

If there was ever a prime example of «earned media» …

We hadn't planned on it at all, but that's how things sometimes turn out when you take a path beyond the ordinary.

 

You were really «fired up» about this campaign, weren't you?

We often went to the train station at night to pick up the newspapers in which our ads were published. Mind you, we’d spent three weeks working on them—the typography, the images, everything that went into them. We couldn’t wait to see them in front of us—just like the first TV commercial. Today, print media has pretty much fallen by the wayside. But there are still many people who read the newspaper every day. That’s a powerful psychographic target audience. Ignoring them is advertising nonsense.

Conrad working for Ogilvy: «The only things I let touch my skin are water and CD.»

If you were to start an agency all over again, how would you go about it?

In 1978, a survey was conducted to identify the best agencies in Germany, and we—as «Lürzer, Conrad,» before our merger with Leo Burnett—took first place in three categories. We were recognized for having the most creative solutions and the most dynamic management… and we’d only been in the market for three years! That’s when we realized: Many other agencies in the German-speaking world at that time were structured in a more commercial, more standardized way. And that’s still the case today. That means the opportunity to really make a difference in the industry—it’s always there. Even if you want to launch a business from Switzerland. If I were to start something today, it would be an interdisciplinary venture. I’d have brilliant leaders in a team of eight or ten who really know how media planning works today, who understand consulting, and who can handle data. And among them would be excellent creatives. It would have to be a group of exceptional people who can solve any problem over a weekend. Just like our Burnett agency back then, led by Spillmann and Felser. That was something else.


Michael Conrad was born in Leipzig in 1944 and fled to the West with his mother in 1952. After completing an apprenticeship as an industrial clerk and holding various positions, the self-taught professional joined Young & Rubicam in 1968, later moving to Ogilvy Mather. In 1972, he helped found TBWA in Frankfurt; this was followed in 1975 by the founding of Lürzer, Conrad. In 1980, the company merged with Leo Burnett, where he rose to the position of Global Chief Creative Officer. Michael Conrad is married, has three children, and has lived in Zurich since 2000. He is a co-founder of the Berlin School of Creative Leadership, an Executive MBA program for creative executives.

This interview first appeared in the m&k Print Edition 10/2021.

Smart media makes the difference

No other area of marketing sees as much money flowing into it as media. Yet it is often given little attention. Media is not only responsible for ensuring that advertisements reach their target audiences, but above all for ensuring that they have an impact.

Smarte Media
(Image: unsplash.com)
Media strategy is the most underrated lever in the marketing mix. With the right strategy, the effectiveness of your advertising increases far more significantly than it would through the lowest purchase prices. Of course, no advertiser wants to pay too much. A good «pay factor» is therefore more in demand than ever, but that alone doesn’t tell the whole story. Far more important is the cost per effective advertising contact with potential customers.

Real advertising impact instead of big numbers

The quality of good media planning isn’t measured by contact opportunities, engagement, interactions, likes, loves, and shares. Media quality is demonstrated by how effectively the campaign generates advertising-effective contacts. To be clear, this includes contacts with people who are at the stage in the buying process that the ad is targeting.

But before an advertisement can have an impact, it must first be noticed! But be careful: don’t confuse «noticing» with «seeing»! Just because a target audience can technically “see” something doesn’t mean the ad has actually been noticed. That’s why, among other reasons, the actual noticeability of online or billboard ads is lower than their “technical” reach.

«Media quality is reflected in how well the campaign succeeds in generating effective advertising contacts.»

Quality in media planning is evident when media professionals understand what the campaign is about and how its goals can be achieved efficiently. The quality of the media mix and detailed planning plays a crucial role in this. Those who seek only the cheapest exposure will have to accept a reduction in advertising impact and, consequently, in marketing success.

Custom TV Campaigns

In television, quality is reflected, among other things, in the choice of programming context and the mix of channels. The better the program and its audience align with the campaign, the greater the chance that the ad will be noticed and have an impact. Special placements for the spots or shorter commercial breaks are also helpful. Well-planned TV campaigns are characterized by a channel mix tailored to the situation and corresponding primetime shares, smart scheduling, and, above all, carefully selected programming contexts.

Digital advertising must be effective and should not be intrusive

The same principle applies to online advertising: quality is reflected in integration. The better the ad blends into its surroundings, the greater its impact. The more disruptive the ad is, the more likely it is to be skipped. For «programmatic» campaigns, this means that ad placements should be limited to relevant websites for each campaign and topic (include lists). Otherwise, your campaigns will get lost in the vastness of the internet and end up on questionable foreign sites. Advertisers will then rightly face questions about brand safety and the funding of radical groups.

«Expect both quantity and quality from your partners when it comes to media planning. It's worth it.»

So don’t let yourself be swayed solely by high metrics. Get a sense of how likely your campaign is to actually reach your target audience. And most importantly: demand both quantity and quality from your partners when it comes to media planning. It’s worth it!


The SWA regularly organizes webinars on this and other specialized topics. In addition, the association assists its members with individual inquiries. Advertisers, for example, can have the quality and quantity of their media planning reviewed through an independent second opinion or a media audit. The SWA Office is happy to share the relevant contact information.

*PMC Average Prices implements campaigns focused on quality and advertising impact across all media. Its areas of expertise include online and TV campaigns, which are developed, planned, booked, and monitored in-house.

 

This article first appeared in the m&k Print Edition 10/2021.

Between poster and pixels

Traditional out-of-home (OOH) advertising and digital out-of-home (DOOH) advertising have something in common: they attract attention in public spaces. But they also differ fundamentally. Can the two formats be compared? A side-by-side comparison.

Klassische Aussenwerbung (OOH)
(Image: Unsplash / Jazmin Quaynor)

It is the oldest medium in the world—and at the same time one of the most modern of all. No matter where you go, you’re confronted with it—on the street, on the bus, on the mountain, at the train station, at the airport, or at the point of sale: Outdoor advertising catches your eye the moment you step outside. At least for now—because starting in 2025, billboards will no longer be visible in public spaces, at least in Geneva. Advertising will then be banned within the city limits—the vacant spaces will be made available to creative citizens, among others. It remains to be seen what this step means for the future of outdoor advertising—in any case, posters and the like are certainly well-received by many consumers: According to the study «Top Media Channels 2020» by dieMarktforscher.org, street posters are not only among the most viewed media but also among the most appealing.

«Both genres share the same goal: to reach a relevant target audience as effectively as possible.»

Yet outdoor advertising is no longer limited to analog formats. It flickers across an ever-increasing number of screens in public spaces, benefiting from longer viewing times and high levels of attention—and offering advertisers tremendous flexibility. Depending on the weather or location, it can be displayed in different ways, even controlled programmatically, and is constantly evolving. Outdoor advertising and digital outdoor advertising: Can these two formats even be compared?

What DOOH and OOH Can and Cannot Do

«Of course,» says Marc Goetti, CEO of Excom Media. «Both media formats pursue the same goal: to capture the attention of a relevant target audience as effectively as possible.» Maria Brinkmann, Managing Director at Publicis Media, agrees: “Both advertising formats are suitable for both brand awareness and driving sales, and they complement each other perfectly. What makes the significant difference is the flexibility and the opportunities for advertisers, which are far greater with DOOH.” In other words, DOOH stands out with shorter booking processes, significantly greater flexibility, shorter turnaround times, and targeting capabilities that allow for the immediate display of up-to-date content. During the pandemic, for example, Excom Media supported the Federal Office of Public Health with its COVID-19 campaigns. “We often received current content the night before it had to be displayed the very next day,” says Goetti. “That would be virtually unthinkable with traditional posters.”.

«Both channels have their advantages. How can advertisers decide?»

«The key advantage of DOOH,» says Maria Brinkmann, «is the use of moving images, which makes the advertising message significantly more emotionally engaging: Just think of the images of New York’s Times Square, dominated by colorful, glowing advertising screens.» Another plus: Combining DOOH with other media is easier. «You can usually adapt existing source material very well. That nicely rounds out a cross-media campaign,» says Marc Goetti. Visibility is guaranteed at any time of day thanks to high-resolution screens. And: «The target audience can be engaged in a directly visible digital interaction,« adds Ariane Piccinno of Richnerstutz, the expert who implements »everything for spatial communication.« However, traditional outdoor advertising also has advantages that its digital counterparts cannot offer. Coverage with analog billboards in Switzerland remains significantly higher, giving them greater reach. They can be deployed with pinpoint regional accuracy, for example near supermarkets. Added to this is location exclusivity: »This results in a higher share of voice, because DOOH advertising is played in a loop for a specific duration,« explains Maria Brinkmann. And they stand out: »With megaposters or other analog advertising formats in 3D or large format, there’s less risk of being overlooked, because they’re permanently eye-catching and visible,” says Ariane Piccinno.

Focus on Campaign Goals

In other words, both channels have their advantages—so how can advertisers decide? It depends on the marketing strategy and the campaign objectives. And on where the target audiences are. «The focus should be on the target audience’s behavior: It’s probably easier to reach drivers in the metropolitan area while they’re shopping at the supermarket than at the main train station or through TV ads. Sensors and data make it possible to identify a target audience in new settings and reach them in unexpected places,» says Benjamin Wey, who—in the midst of the COVID-19 crisis last year—founded Adtrac —founded Adtrac, a startup that connects media and advertising agencies with providers of digital out-of-home advertising space and aims to make the booking, analysis, and billing of campaigns more efficient and simpler. Why was the time right for this? «The outdoor advertising market is still very conservative,» says Wey. «With Adtrac, we want to bring efficiency and real-time data to this attractive, high-value market, streamline processes, and automate them.»

Swiss Post is also preparing its business for the digital future. With the acquisition of Livesystems—which, according to Swiss Post, operates a network of more than 8,000 advertising screens in public, high-traffic locations—Swiss Post aims to bring the distribution of physical advertising into the digital future, according to a press release. Swiss Post calls the acquisition a «logical step.» What does this mean for outdoor advertising? «The future is digital!» says Benjamin Wey of Adtrac. «Data and automation enable completely new approaches. To harness the full potential of digitalization, we all need to rethink our approach.» One challenge that apparently still remains is the issue of comparability and measurability of media performance. For example, the AM4DOOH research project—an international consortium supported by APG|SGA, Clear Channel, Exterion Media, and JCDecaux, with the World Out of Home Organization as a sponsor—was integrated into SPR+ data at the end of 2019. «However, the barriers to entry are very high for many DOOH networks, or AM4DOOH does not provide measurement data for them (e.g., indoor networks). A universal measurement approach for DOOH would be desirable,» notes Marc Goetti.

What does the future of outdoor advertising look like? The world is becoming more digital, and programmatic DOOH is also gaining importance. But traditional formats still have their place. Media expert Maria Brinkmann sums it up: «In an era of ad fraud and brand safety scandals, the ongoing fragmentation of media consumption, and the decline in reach across traditional media, outdoor advertising has a decisive advantage: the medium is naturally integrated into people’s lives and will remain a part of them as long as mobility exists.» That’s certainly a promising outlook.


INTERVIEW

«Outdoor advertising in traditional formats isn't going to disappear anytime soon»

What does OOH have that DOOH doesn't—and vice versa? An interview with Dragan Dojcinovic, CEO of Livesystems.

M&K: Dragan Dojcinovic, you specialize in DOOH, but you also offer traditional OOH solutions. Both are forms of outdoor advertising—can these two media be compared?
Dragan Dojcinovic Yes and no. The context is the same, but the way you reach customers differs in that one is digital and the other is analog. You can draw a comparison because the performance metrics are the same, but you can’t because digital platforms offer different creative possibilities.

 

What advantages do the respective genres have that the other does not?

DOOH clearly has the advantage of offering more creative possibilities. Moving images also generally attract more attention than analog advertising. The advantage of analog advertising, however, lies in the fact that the space is occupied continuously; with DOOH, the ads rotate in a loop with other content.

 

What are the major challenges DOOH will face in the near future?

In my opinion, the biggest challenge is that digitalization isn’t progressing fast enough, and that technologies are evolving very rapidly. On the other hand, having too many digital displays in a small space can reduce their effectiveness. Today, a digital screen stands out much more because there aren’t very many of them.

 

A Look into the Future: How will the landscape of the outdoor advertising market change—will traditional offerings continue to exist, even though digital media offer entirely different possibilities?

Traditional outdoor advertising isn't going to disappear anytime soon. However, the share of digital advertising will increase significantly in the coming years. As a result, the traditional market will tend to decline, but it will remain in place for some time to come.

get_footer();