Advico Young & Rubicam scooped two top disciplines at the 25th ADC SwitzerlandBy Luca AloisiThe air at the top is getting thinner. The lavish dice shower at the ADC 2001 was only concentrated on the biggest agencies. To the annoyance of some gold jurors, the iron broom wiped even very good work off the table too early. Strict selection and "over-regulation" led to heated discussions.
The ADC jury 2001 was not only characterized by the best advertising, but also by "over-regulation", as ADC Chairman Andreas Prokesch put it in his trenchant way. The Art Director Club's efforts to optimize the difficult judging process were clearly expressed in a number of dissonances. However, not all of the improvements could be put into practice.
The composition and size of the gold jury was reduced from twelve - corresponding to the number of category groups - to eight under the new mode, as only one jury president per agency was allowed to have a say in the final round. This made the eight-member panel seem almost informal, but this was only seemingly conducive to unity and clear decisions.
As in any good family, the members knew how to argue and make up in the best possible way. The first argument was not long in coming. For a start, two works that had won silver in several categories had to be withdrawn, as otherwise they would have violated the new rule that a work can only win one prize. This was a problem that caused tempers to flare.
While one camp had strictly adhered to the new statutes and now saw equal opportunities at risk, the others defended themselves with the argument that the term "work" was unfortunate because it did not specify whether idea or work was meant. The latter gave in after all and benefited from the open loophole - no rule without exception: all works that enter the race in the overall campaigns may also compete individually for cubes in the corresponding categories.
The ADC is also experiencing the difficulties of success
However, before it got that far, Andreas Prokesch emphasized in his introduction: "As long as I am chairman, the press will always be there." This is to counteract the rumor that the ADC jurors would only roll the dice in their own interests under the cloak of discretion. Only transparency and media presence - this year only perceived through WerbeWoche - can give the lie to such claims, he explained.
It is therefore not without a certain irony that the rain of dice, which was anything but abundant and homogeneous, was diametrically opposed to his ambition. Despite the well-intentioned open policy, this year's Würfelspiegel confirms the impression that only the elite or only those agencies that actually submitted their advertising work had any chance of winning an award at the Swiss Advertising Championships. This is something that is all too often forgotten: The ADC cannot in fact provide a comprehensive representative cross-section of the most creative advertising work in Switzerland, as only the entries are judged.
The club's chairman accepts that the ADC may be elitist, "but this should not be confused with arrogance". The fact that the association of leading creatives will have to live with such labels even more in future can hardly be avoided, considering that only those who have won bronze at least once in the last three years will be allowed to take part in the jury.
The 82 jurors in the bronze round now had to judge not only their own category, but several categories at once. "We hope that these more qualified and larger juries will result in a more representative and fairer judgment," explains Prokesch. Lobbying is largely ruled out at this level due to the evaluation with a points system on its own and without discussion, he says.
AY&R shines with
Tourism and hygiene
The ADC awarded 285 out of 1157 entries - 220 with bronze, 56 with silver and nine with gold. This means that the success rate among entrants remained the same: 43 of 141 entrants received an award. Of these, more than half are not represented in the ADC. In this way, the club wants to prove that you don't have to be an ADC member to win an ADC award.
The emphatic reference to the fact that numerous new names appear on the list of winners - "and from smaller agencies" - can only be read as an image correction. (Perhaps the aftermath of the ADC festival in 1999, when the advertising guild presented itself as a mafia clan in a self-ironic and complacent manner). If you take a closer look at the cube review, especially the gold and silver ranks, you will notice that hardly anything has changed in the Olympus of the most creative. Fewer agencies succeeded in setting new standards last year than in the past.
This year, Wirz Werbung (five silver and 14 bronze) and Wyler Werbung (eight bronze) no longer won gold. WHS, on the other hand, rejoined the ranks of the glorious gold diggers thanks to the audience ads for the web security company Open Systems. Publicis took two, McCann-Erickson and Guye & Partner one each of the coveted gold cubes. Advico Young & Rubicam (AY&R) was the most successful gold hamster of the year with a total of four gold cubes.
The Gockhausen team scooped precious metal in the supreme disciplines: Advertising film and public ad for Hakle and overall campaign for Kuoni. AY&R shone once again for both clients: last year, the agency won gold in the overall campaign category for Kuoni subsidiary Helvetic Tours and Hakle has since established itself as an ADC perennial favorite. Thanks to its visual language and dramaturgy, which only offers one level of interpretation, as well as its humor, most of the gold jurors also believe that the Hakle spot "Scheibenwischer" has a good chance of winning at Cannes.
Not everything is shiny,
what is silvery
In contrast to categories in which works were awarded gold with a clear conscience and even with clear majorities, the gold jury in other disciplines such as direct advertising, photography/illustration/graphics or specialist advertisements was visibly dismayed or even shocked by the meagre silver selection. From "completely overrated" to "discrepant differences between the categories", the judges commented on some of the works that made it into the gold round.
Chairman Prokesch, who values a clearly recognizable level between the individual ranks, found this most difficult. "Many are mistaken if they believe that ADC gold jurors are calibrated to one opinion," he says in defense of the judging process. The fact that promising works were thrown under the bus at an early stage and caused additional head-shaking is nothing new.
In one case, the jury nevertheless felt compelled to reject a silver work by means of an exemption clause because it had also been entered in another category and had already been silver-plated there. Not enough of the inconsistencies: In the personal use category, a work was awarded a silver cube that had already achieved bronze in 1998. "It often happens that I receive 'posthumous' letters drawing attention to plagiarism and breaches of the rules. But it's rarely possible to investigate this properly because we have no means of doing so," says Andreas Prokesch. However, he knows from experience that those involved very quickly come to an agreement in private. Which saves everyone embarrassing situations.
ADC 2001: The gold winners
Publicity ads (individual motifs): AY&R with "Waage" for Hakle, Publicis with "The 300 richest Swiss" for Bilanz.
Public displays: WHS with "Immune System" for Open Systems.
Outdoor advertising (individual motifs): Guye & Partner with "Superman" for Arena.
Advertising film: AY&R with "windshield wiper" for Hakle.
Radio spots: Publicis, Zurich, with "Testfahrer Walti" for Sportplausch Wider.
Sales promotion: AY&R with "literature" for VBZ.
Public Service: McCann-Erickson, Geneva, with "Cindarella" and "Nutcracker" for the Zurich Opera House.
Overall campaign: AY&R with "Holidays where you forget everything" for Kuoni.
ADC 2001: Advertising agency ranking
Rank Submitter Awards Gold Silver Bronze Points Rank00 Rank99
1 AY&R 46 4 13 29 67 (2) (3)
2 Publicis 50 2 6 42 60 (1) (1)
3 WHS 29 1 7 21 38 (3) (2)
3 Guye & Partner 30 1 6 23 38 (5) (4)
5 McCann-Erickson 29 1 5 23 36 (4) (5)
6 Wirz Advertising 19 0 5 14 24 (7) (8)
(Gold = 3 points, Silver = 2 points, Bronze = 1 point)
The Facts Press Awards 2001
For the fifth time, a press jury - independent of the ADC jury - examined all magazine advertisements and presented the awards as follows:
Gold: Wyler Werbung with the "Rüebli" image campaign for the Aargauer Zeitung.
Silver: McCann-Erickson for Rama (Lipton-Sais).
Bronze: Lowe Lintas GGK with "VW New Beetle" for AMAG.