In Workshop.02, the BSW is looking for fresh communication talentBy Luca Aloisi 25 ambitious career changers with a good background are to be introduced to the advertising and communication industry in a BSW workshop. The BSW hopes that this forward-looking measure will improve the image of the industry.
Budget cuts, downsizing, bankruptcies - the advertising industry has seen better times. But the industry association Schweizer Werbe- und Kommunikationsagenturen (BSW) is not burying its head in the sand and is embarking on a cleverly orchestrated "search campaign" in Switzerland and abroad: In full-page advertisements, it is looking for "talents for advertising", for potential career changers who want to discover their hidden skills at the first seven-day BSW Talent Workshop. The BSW is convinced that the inexpensive offer - CHF 1,600 entry fee - will bring fresh blood into the industry and at the same time have a positive effect on its reputation, which is not always flawless.
Skeptics suspect a diversionary tactic
The association proved how important the campaign is to it with its star-studded line-up at the Info Day: BSW President and Chairman TBWA Hanspeter Detsch said that the chances of finding talented people are greater now than in times of overemployment. René R. Hürlimann, Board Member Euro RSCG Switzerland, piled up key figures from better times and projected them into the future. Publicis CCO Jean Etienne Aebi, on the other hand, talked wittily about the fascinating business of ideas and concluded with a great Nike spot cascade, which is likely to devour almost the film budget of an entire Swiss advertising year. And Euro-RSCG CEO Frank Bodin explained why he has dedicated himself to top-class sports advertising. Afterwards, an equally prominent panel of three, moderated by workshop coach Urs Beer, outlined the ideal advertising starter.
Only just under 70 curious people attended the Werbergilde's presentation until the end. The subdued response probably reflects the interest in a crisis-ridden industry that has been discussing a door-opening course for years and now - at the worst possible time - suddenly wants to introduce it.
Behind closed doors, critical voices are therefore raising doubts about the effectiveness and seriousness of the course, which they see as nothing more than image polishing. But even this is of questionable value because it would require continuity, which is anything but certain with the Talent Workshop. The suspicion that the association wants to feign healthy industry dynamics and divert attention from internal quarrels - namely the decreasing willingness of many agencies to adhere to BSW pitch rules - is probably not entirely unfounded.
The new offer also seems strange because the job market for talented career changers is anything but dry at the moment, and because in small Switzerland, creative minds have almost always managed to get into advertising either directly or via detours - even without a stable smell. Frank Bodin and Dominique von Matt, co-owner and Managing Director of JvM/Limmat, are living proof of this.
BSW wants to send anti-cyclical signals with the workshop Detsch sees the project as a long-term task that is independent of the cycle. "We are investing in the future," he emphasizes. The aim is to make the advertising industry more attractive "for people with a good background" in order to attract them to a career in an agency.
Of course, the question of timing was discussed, admits the BSW President. "However, the Board of Directors decided that we would do it now more than ever." After all, it's about the quality of potential employees. And Cornelia Harder, Managing Director Publicis, adds: "The current economic situation and the tense competitive situation in the agency business do not release us from our obligation to promote high-quality young talent."
The ongoing economic downturn, which is causing the communications industry far more problems than stingy clients, was almost ignored at the Info Day. Most of the agencies' HR departments have prepared themselves for this scenario, as an ad hoc survey revealed: most BSW agencies currently have no need for additional staff. Those in charge note dismissively that they are "of course always looking for good people".
In contrast to such nice-sounding phrases, the BSW has made a binding commitment in the advertisement text: "The BSW agencies will not miss the opportunity at the end of 2002 to bring fresh and promising talent into their companies". However, BSW President Hanspeter Detsch does not want the full-bodied wording to be understood as a commitment on the part of the agencies. "We still have normal fluctuations. In addition, agencies today are in an international competitive environment in which it is crucial to have top people on board."
Detsch admits that this new path is "unconventional", but rejects the suggestion that it is a tool to attract career changers on favorable terms in order to land internship-like positions. It is much more about offering an alternative to the traditional educational pathways into communication.
Clarifying misconceptions about advertising agencies
Ultimately, the BSW is responding to the changes in the education system, in which the universities of applied sciences have increased competition with the relevant institutes such as the Sawi. The latter have not been able to keep pace with the rapidly changing requirements of the economy, says Detsch. He mentions planning and the creative sector, in which "a different rucksack is simply required today". This does not necessarily have to do with the providers, but with the education system, he complains.
BSW Managing Director Walter Merz does not see the "special introductory program" with the "comprehensive information package" as a diploma course anyway and therefore not as a Sawi competitor. In the workshop with case study, he wants to fill the backpack differently and above all with an insight into 13 renowned agencies: With information on the role of communication and the Swiss advertising market, brand management and strategic planning through to idea generation, creation and realization - albeit not in this order or with equal weighting. So there can be no talk of a quick fix, Detsch clarifies.
The aim of the program is to make the industry attractive to people who are filtered out in the assessment and have already gained know-how and experience elsewhere. In addition, the aim is to clarify vague ideas about processes in an advertising agency and thus offer a decision-making aid. In any case, "this is an attempt" to bring new thinking into the industry.
"At the end of the workshop, the visitor has got to know 13 agencies and the areas of strategic planning, consulting, creation and media and can definitely decide whether this is their career or not," says Merz. Workshop coach Urs Beer puts it in a nutshell: "With this experiment, we want to kick-start a new process for finding talent." This is not actually a training course, as one might assume, but a taster course.
Whether there will be another BSW talent workshop next year has yet to be decided.
It all depends on the success of the first experiment, but probably also on how long the Swiss advertising volume remains in the trough.
Net advertising sales in Switzerland
(excluding production costs) in CHF million
1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 Difference
Press 00/01 in %
- Newspapers including free newspapers 1850 1850 1926 2118 2250 2150 - 4.4
- Consumer magazines 264 229 243 337 379 346 - 8.7
- Trade press 357 365 397 380 404 390 - 3.4
Total press 2471 2444 2566 2835 3032 2886 - 4.8
Cinema 37 39 40 42 45 40 -
Radio (incl. sponsorship) 106 107 114 120 139 129 - 7.6
Television (including sponsorship) 343 370 402 486 520 494 - 5.1
Teletext 13 13 14 13 14 14 14 - 3.5
Outdoor advertising 448 447 468 502 592 603 + 1.8
Address books 121 121 118 128 150 155 + 3.3
Trade fairs and exhibitions 196 207 218 220 227 235 + 3.5
Promotional items 99 104 113 121 - - -
Total values collected 3735 3747 3940 4346 4720 4555 - 3.5
Direct advertising - - - 976 1061 1109 + 4.6
Total-Total - - - 5322 5781 5665 - 2.0