Publishers Tamedia is setting its flagship on the Pfnüsel coast on a collision course with the Zürichsee-Zeitung Following its experiments with local newspapers at the end of the 1990s, the newspaper landscape on the left bank of Lake Zurich is once again in turmoil. Last week, the publisher of the Tages-Anzeiger announced that it would operate its own local editorial office in the district of Horgen - in other words, in the middle of the home territory of the dominant Zürichsee-Zeitung - from next March and produce a separate regional section for the area from Kilchberg to Richterswil as well as for the Sihl Valley. There is talk of six pages a day with journalistic articles, regionally acquired advertisements and official publications, which will appear either as an additional newspaper bundle or as a tabloid supplement. "We want to go in-depth locally," says Daniela Decurtins, who as deputy editor-in-chief of the Tages-Anzeiger will later also be responsible for regionalization in other areas.
The Tagi really does need a local presence, because the paper can only grow at present by establishing itself more firmly in the agglomerations of "downtown Switzerland". After the failure of the national growth strategy with the target circulation of 300,000 copies that was never reached, Tamedia's attempt to integrate the four Zurich regional newspapers Unterländer, Oberländer, Zürichsee-Zeitung and Landbote in one way or another also failed.
NZZ shoulder strengthenedThe project is a direct attack on the Zürichsee-Zeitung and the declared attempt to trim the inclined readership in the Horgen district towards the Tagi in the medium to long term. Tamedia has good cards: "We already have more than 32,000 readers in the Horgen district," says Decurtins. The intruder could initially be successful with the so-called double readers, who read the Zürichsee-Zeitung for its local reporting but turn to the Tages-Anzeiger for everything else.
The Zurich offensive is being taken seriously at the headquarters of the Zürichsee-Zeitung in Stäfa. "Until now we have been neutrally positioned, but that is now over. If Tamedia really gains a foothold, we will move closer to the NZZ and certainly not lean towards the Tagi," explains Theodor Gut, Chairman of the Board of Directors of Zürichsee Presse AG, which publishes the Zürichsee-Zeitung. Gut believes that Tamedia, unlike NZZ, has no interest in strong and independent regional newspapers that directly compete with its flagship. Gut wants to counter the attack with as yet undefined alternative offers to readers and advertisers and, if necessary, also selectively strengthen the left-bank editorial team.
Tagi poaches journalistsMeanwhile, the tug-of-war for journalists and editors with local experience has also flared up. The newcomer in the region is dependent on writers with a broad network of contacts. Attempts to poach staff from its competitor show that Tamedia is prepared to dig deep into its pockets. So deep, in fact, that the Zürichsee-Zeitung can only hope for the loyalty of its staff. The new editorial office is to be staffed similarly to that of the Zürichsee-Zeitung, which covers the district with around 900 full-time equivalents.
"We are serious. We have made long-term and serious plans," says Decurtins. The regionalization project should therefore not fall asleep again like previous expansion attempts. Specifically, they want to give themselves between five and ten years to win over the Tagi's audience and outdo the Zürichsee-Zeitung.
The looming war of position is therefore likely to last much longer than the one between Stäfa and the former Baublatt publisher Ueli Schück from Rüschlikon at the end of the 1990s. After the Zürichsee-Zeitung consolidated the left bank of the lake and swallowed up four local papers, Schück cleverly exploited the public's resentment at the loss of local press identity. He launched the revolt from below with four new local newspapers, which were discontinued after a year and a half. A former editor believes that the experiment might have had a better chance with Publicitas as an advertising agency.
Weak point Thalwil
But where the Zürichsee-Zeitung used to be Goliath, it is now David. Nevertheless, its editor-in-chief Benjamin Geiger trusts in the conceptual advantages of his paper, which deliberately focuses on what the future Tages-Anzeiger in the district can only offer as a supplement. And he is counting on a well-connected editorial team, with whom he intends to continue working as a first priority.
However, there is a blind spot on the strategic map of the Zürichsee-Zeitung. In the Thalwil constituency, the newspaper of the same name has around 6000 subscriptions. The Zürichsee-Zeitung recently seconded an editor to carry out preliminary journalistic work with a view to a takeover. Stäfa has a right of first refusal on the loss-making paper. However, as long as its ageing owner does not want to part with his life's work, the Zürichsee-Zeitung cannot convert the Thalwiler subscriptions and has to defend an area in which it has hardly any presence. The Tages-Anzeiger will certainly exploit this weakness.
Necessity as a virtue: As the Tages-Anzeiger can only grow in the region, it attacks the Zürichsee-Zeitung.
Equalizing pressure with the NZZThe NZZ succeeded in doing what the Tages-Anzeiger did for a long time.
The increased cooperation with PubliGroupe, which is expected to contribute 22.5 percent of Zürichsee Presse AG (Zürichsee-Zeitung) and 40 percent of Ackeret AG in Bassersdorf (Zürcher Unterländer) to the NZZ subsidiary Neue Presse Holding and take over the NZZ's advertising business in return, will bring the two regional newspapers closer to the NZZ while remaining independent.
However, the deal has not yet been finalized. Theodor Gut, Chairman of the Board of Directors of Zürichsee Presse AG, does not intend to exercise his pre-emptive right to buy PubliGroupe's stake in his company.
Rumors recently circulated that he might give in to pressure from the left bank of the lake at the last moment and pass it on to Tamedia.
If the pressure continues to increase, "we will support the existing structures", says Beat Lauber, Head of Regional Newspapers at NZZ. (rw)
René Worni