Press Council: No obligation to report objectively
A reader had complained that the Swiss media had been falsely claiming for years that alcoholic beverages consumed in moderation are healthier than abstaining from alcohol entirely.
The Press Council states in a statement that no professional ethical obligation to "objective reporting" can be derived from the rights and duties of journalists. Furthermore, editorial offices are not obliged to report on a specific topic, group or person. In the specific case, a reader had complained that the Swiss media had been falsely claiming for years that alcoholic beverages consumed in moderation were healthier than abstaining from alcohol altogether. He also expressed the suspicion that the Tages-Anzeiger, for example, would not report freely on the alcohol problem because it is a member of the Alliance Against Advertising Bans and because it is dependent on the alcohol industry for advertising. The Press Council pointed out to the complainant that, according to its practice, it could only be justified - if at all - in very exceptional cases to derive a violation of professional ethical standards from a medium's failure to report on a certain topic. In addition, the Press Council is only able to assess complaints about the dissemination of alleged false information if a complaint is directed against specific, verifiable media reports from named media. It is not the task of the Press Council to comment on different positions.
In addition, the Swiss media report on the dangers of excessive alcohol consumption in a balanced manner. The newspapers had also warned against using individual research results as an opportunity to campaign for moderate alcohol consumption. For these reasons, the Press Council rejected the complaint.
In addition, the Swiss media report on the dangers of excessive alcohol consumption in a balanced manner. The newspapers had also warned against using individual research results as an opportunity to campaign for moderate alcohol consumption. For these reasons, the Press Council rejected the complaint.
