Regional press The Landbote is about to cooperate with the Thurgauer Zeitung. The Zürcher Landbote is to cooperate with the Thurgauer Zeitung on an editorial level. Discussions between the editors-in-chief have been concluded and a rough concept has been drawn up. "Now we are just waiting for the decision of the Board of Directors," explains Landbote Editor-in-Chief Colette Gradwohl. The exact content of the concept is not known and those responsible do not want to say anything about it. If the aim is to exploit synergies between regional newspapers - which primarily means savings - then a jacket section with joint supra-regional departments is the rule. "I can imagine that we will get clarity this year on how to proceed," says Andreas Netzle, Editor-in-Chief of the Thurgauer Zeitung.
Landbote expanded its positionBut why should the Landbote cooperate? "The Landbote is not in a bad position," says Gradwohl. A good year after the total restructuring of the paper from a dusty city newspaper to a modern forum paper, the Landbote was able to maintain and slightly expand its position. Job cuts are therefore apparently not an issue. "There is no need for action at the moment," says Gradwohl. "But that could change." However, the editor-in-chief is convinced that a cooperation with the Thurgauer Zeitung makes sense.
However, it is not really clear why a regional newspaper in Winterthur should focus more on eastern Switzerland instead of the cantonal capital of Zurich, where the commuter flows go. On the contrary, one could get the impression that the Landbote is increasingly being sidelined in the crossfire of interests.
It is clear that the Tages-Anzeiger publisher Tamedia, with its 20 percent stake in Winterthur and the 100 percent stake in Thurgauer Zeitung, is looking for synergies to refinance the high purchase price of TZ, officially CHF 56 million, and is therefore trying to push ahead with the cooperation using the most diplomatic means possible. Because there are obstacles.
Tamedia prints the Landbote and the Landbote publisher Ziegler Druck AG in turn prints the magazine and other commercial publications. These contracts remove an important means of pressure for Tamedia, as a corresponding contractual clause prohibits it from launching a regional edition of the Tages-Anzeiger in Winterthur, a flaw in Tamedia's regionalization strategy for the Tagi. Nevertheless, the statements made in Winterthur by the bustling Tagi publishing director and ex-Mister-20-Minuten Rolf Bollmann must seem like threatening gestures: As the responsible regional strategist, Bollmann emphasizes at every opportunity that there are too many newspapers in the greater Zurich area.
This takes on a bizarre double meaning, especially when Bollmann intends to print a large print run for the Tagi and the regional editions, but the print jobs for the Tages-Anzeiger, 20 Minuten and other regional newspapers, including the Landbote, bring Tamedia's rotation to the edge of its capacity.
After all, the millions are not flowing so freely in the joint Tagi Plus advertising combination between Tages-Anzeiger and Landbote, which Gradwohl's predecessor and former editor-in-chief Rudolf Gerber, for example, had raved about. Tagi Plus is not affiliated with the Metropool, so the national connection in the media triangle of Basel, Berne and Zurich is no longer available. This may explain why the initial euphoria about Tagi Plus has given way to widespread disappointment. In the advertising combi 1, the residual product of the former north-east combi with six regional newspapers, the Landbote, together with the Thurgauer Zeitung and the Schaffhauser Nachrichten, is the partner with the highest circulation and is now the only Publicitas title in the region.
The Thurgauer Zeitung only recently broke away from the advertising giant and is marketing itself in the same way as its parent company Tamedia. However, this should not have any impact on Kombi 1, through which the Landbote also enters the national advertising business. The strong position in Kombi 1 could at least be a small argument in the negotiations with Tamedia.
On the other hand, the former allies, the three Zurich regional newspapers Zürichsee-Zeitung, Unterländer and Oberländer, have joined forces to form the Zürcher Landzeitung with a joint cover and have been cooperating even more closely since the beginning of October. This also severed the last links between the three papers and the Landbote, which until the end of September still claimed the same Federal Parliament correspondent.
In the past, i.e. until the takeover of the aforementioned share package from Tamedia in Winterthur and the associated affiliation of the Landbote with the Zurich group, the regional newspapers regularly exchanged editorial information. The Winterthur newspapers were once regarded as a secure value in the group, which also manifested itself physically with the founding of the joint printing center in Oetwil and whose departure was a severe blow to the regional publishers.
From a journalistic point of view, a cooperation would still make more sense today than connections to Thurgau. Even the media experts who flew in from Hamburg had to realize that Winterthur and Frauenfeld are not neighboring communities and that the savings potential of a cooperation between Landbote and the Thurgauer Zeitung was probably somewhat overestimated.
For the time being, Winterthur is keeping quiet. "We are seriously considering a cooperation with TZ, but the matter is still too immature for us to comment," says Lothar Dostal, Managing Director of Ziegler Druck.
René Worni