With its special supplement on Switzerland, *Der Spiegel* magazine is perpetuating many—far too many—clichés. It’s probably mainly Germans who want to read it. You couldn’t write more out of touch with the target audience—that’s the quick and unanimous verdict on the first and, for now, only issue of a Swiss supplement to the «magazine of all magazines» from Hamburg. The Matterhorn on the cover, Christoph Blocher under the axe of his Hodler-style lumberjack, Zurich’s Paradeplatz (illustrating the bastion of banking secrecy), the Swiss Guard in Rome (featuring the madman—already printed a thousand times—who tries in vain to leap onto the popemobile), DJ Bobo as a UN ambassador in Ethiopia, a belching (methane-emitting) cow on Uri soil: the accumulation of clichés is downright oppressive when you first flip through the pages. The title “Switzerland: World Power” may give those locals a sense of (belated) satisfaction who, until now, have tended to see themselves portrayed by the German magazine as reactionary, stiff, and overly proper. It’s possible that the editorial team itself realized that the distant little country of Switzerland, on the periphery of the EU, has never before made it to the front page of *Der Spiegel* with a feature story.Professional as AlwaysDespite all the clichés, the supplement is presented with the Spiegel’s customary professional understatement; the texts are carefully researched and authentic. In the editorial, the authors—much like expedition leaders in a dangerous jungle—also comment on the circumstances surrounding their investigations. (Editor Mathieu von Rohr, for example, had to show up at seven in the morning for an interview with early riser Blocher), yet the issue lacks the hallmark of *Der Spiegel*—a surprising revelation. With its Swiss debut, the editorial team is cautiously—and, so to speak, on unfamiliar ground—working toward international understanding. It picks up where the *Blick*’s series—launched at the beginning of the year—left off, with an exclusive survey on the “invasion” of Germans in Switzerland, concluding that the cliché about the poor relationship between the Swiss and the Germans isn’t all that bad. After all, 88 percent of Swiss people consider Germans to be hospitable. A two-page infographic illustrates what has made this small Alpine country an international economic power. Spiegel correspondents have tracked down and profiled Swiss citizens living abroad in Rwanda, North Korea, China, Israel, the U.S., Russia, and northern India—and, of course, the experiences of Swiss expatriates in Germany are also featured.
Nor is there any shortage of opinion leaders, primarily from the business world. Top executives speak quite candidly about the pros and cons of Switzerland as a business location in an international context (Vasella, Brabeck, Hayek, Jacobs, Ospel)—in a way they might not necessarily do so with the Swiss print media. The supplement, which can also be read as a sort of handbook for Germans in Switzerland, naturally also addresses the topic of banking secrecy. Why, however, the Swiss Guard is being brought up again remains incomprehensible, given the seemingly endless series of local media articles already published to mark its anniversary. The role of Russian billionaire and investor Viktor Vekselberg—along with his nimble advisor and former ambassador Thomas Borer—here in Switzerland, on the other hand, is a classic *Spiegel* story, the kind one is more accustomed to seeing in the main magazine. Whether the «Culture» section—featuring a self-portrait by actress Yangzom Brauen (practically copied word for word from the “A Day in the Life of” column in the Tages-Anzeiger magazine)—is sufficient remains to be seen.
A One-Time Trial? The publishers have remained largely tight-lipped about their intentions in the Swiss print media landscape and describe the “Swiss Split”—a 50-page removable insert in the middle of the magazine—as a one-time trial for now. The content is primarily provided by the Swiss contingent of the Hamburg editorial team (Samiha Shafy, Beat Balzli, Sebastian Ramspeck, and Mathieu von Rohr) as well as various foreign correspondents.
Of the 50 pages, seven are devoted to advertisements (Mobiliar, Coop, Ernst & Young, TV 3plus, Neue Zürcher Zeitung, Clariant, and Orange), and it can be assumed that—provided the test was successful—the Swiss edition of *Der Spiegel* will primarily serve to better tap into the local advertising market. Now that talks about possible cooperation models between Facts and *Der Spiegel* have fallen through and the Tamedia news magazine has just been quietly laid to rest—and given that the business newspaper *Cash* had already been forced to fold earlier—the outlook for the Hamburg-based publication on the Swiss market will never be more favorable than it is right now.
After all, 45,148 disappointed subscribers to Cash and 54,164 equally disappointed subscribers to Facts are waiting for some meaningful explanation.
René Worni
Spiegel Disappoints Swiss Media: The Swiss media reacted cautiously to the Swiss edition of *Spiegel*. For the *NZZ* and the *Tages-Anzeiger*, the issue was a disappointment. It was aimed more at German readers than at Swiss ones. While the selection of articles might be interesting for Germans, «they have already been covered multiple times by local newspapers,» according to the Tages-Anzeiger. For the Bund, it is clear that the supplement is no substitute for Facts. The cover image, it said, resorted to the most clichéd of all clichés.
Overall, the special edition for Swiss readers is amusing but offers little of substance, the federal government added. In general, the various publications agree that *Der Spiegel* still lacks its own Swiss editorial team to produce a serious Swiss edition.