The new Zurich-North-Eastern Switzerland TV coverage area, which now includes the cantons of Zurich, Thurgau and Schaffhausen with a total of 1.6 million inhabitants and provides for two window solutions, already has at least three interested parties. Not surprisingly, the media group Tamedia immediately announced on Wednesday via its TV station Tele Züri that it intends to apply for a license. The press release regrets that the area in the west follows the cantonal border exactly and no longer extends into Aargau or almost as far as Zug. In principle, however, Tamedia welcomes the Federal Council's decision. The second interested party is the Glatttal local station Züri Plus, which actually has an area in mind that extends from Glarus via Zurich to Schaffhausen - as was envisaged in the original proposal. In order to cover this area, Züri Plus had joined forces with Ringier, SchaffhauserTV, Tele Südostschweiz and Goldbach Media. Although the canton of Glarus is no longer part of the Zurich-North-Eastern Switzerland coverage area, "we will still apply for the license - just without Tele Südostschweiz", said Züri Plus Managing Director Peter Steinmann. However, he qualified that he had not yet been able to consult with his partners following yesterday's decision by the Federal Council.
Tele Top, which currently covers Schaffhausen and St. Gallen in addition to its core area of Winterthur/Frauenfeld, also announced its intention to apply very quickly. Top boss Günter Heuberger was "very satisfied" with the Zurich-North-Eastern Switzerland coverage area, but would also like to add St. Gallen: He will therefore also apply for the second Eastern Switzerland concession, which includes St. Gallen, the two Appenzells and Upper Thurgau, knowing full well that - if awarded the contract - he would then have to compete against two strong, even overpowering opponents: Tele Züri in the west and Tele Ostschweiz in the east - both of which had already made it clear earlier that they would continue broadcasting without fee splitting and a performance mandate if necessary.
On Wednesday, however, Hanspeter Klauser, Chairman of the Board of Directors of Tele Ostschweiz, was reluctant to comment on such a scenario. Instead, he referred to the "good performance figures" of his station, which differed "strikingly" from the figures of Tele Top in the St. Gallen area. "In any case, we will apply and believe we have a good chance," he said.
Norbert Neininger, publisher of Schaffhauser Nachrichten and head of Schaffhauser Fernsehen, was dissatisfied with the Federal Council's "somewhat unusual decision". As a member of the executive committee of the publishers' association, he had presented a concept at the time that envisaged 14 coverage areas, including a separate one for the canton of Schaffhausen. He regrets that there is now to be a "large concession" for the cantons of Schaffhausen, Zurich and Thurgau. The cantonal government of Schaffhausen echoed this sentiment on Wednesday. It now expects, it wrote, that the Schaffhausen window solution will at least include Schaffhausen television.
It is not least this clear partisanship that puts Neininger in a special position: his station is now likely to be particularly heavily courted and thus to a certain extent tip the scales. He also seems to be savoring this situation, as he sees four options for action. The focus is on a continuation of the Züri Plus project with window solutions for Schaffhausen and Thurgau, he said. However, he also wants to keep open cooperation talks "with other potential applicants for the Zurich-North-Eastern Switzerland supply area". Thirdly, Neininger does not rule out the possibility of his station continuing to operate without fee-splitting and a performance mandate, although he adds that this is not his preferred solution. And finally, he reserves the right to appeal yesterday's Federal Council decision to the Federal Administrative Court.
Not only in Schaffhausen, but also in Winterthur, Uster, Kloten, Frauenfeld and Weinfelden, the authorities took sides in favor of a broadcaster - but there for Tele Top. The five municipalities welcomed the Federal Council's decision because it gives Tele Top the chance "to obtain the license for this broadcasting area with a good concept." They will now work to "ensure that the broadcaster to be selected is given good starting conditions so that the concentration in the newspaper sector does not spill over into the electronic media." The Media Forum in Köniz, which describes itself as an "independent interest group of Swiss media consumers", expressed similar sentiments.
Markus Knöpfli