Generation powerlessness

In her guest column for m&k Werbewoche.ch, this year’s Screenforce Day speaker, Ines Imdahl, draws on study findings to explain what makes Gen Z tick.

(Image: Roland Breitschuh)

No other generation is currently influencing our society as strongly as Gen Z, none is so loved by marketers and courted by employers, none is researched as frequently as they are. Nevertheless, there are many myths, individual facts and a lot of contradictory information circulating about those born between 1997 and 2010. They are said to be work-shy or unable to have relationships, go on strike for the climate and walk around in designer clothes.

We at the Rheingold Salon market research institute wanted to know: Isn't there something consistent, something coherent, a kind of basic psychological structure that characterizes this young generation? And is it a real generation at all - or is it just the birth years of an age cohort?

Of course, a generation should never be completely lumped together. There are always subcultures. However, a group can be described as a generation if it deals differently with growing up than previous generations and at the same time reacts differently to current issues such as digitalization or crises that affect everyone else.

With a total of five representative in-depth psychological studies that we conducted from 2016 to 2023, we can show that there is a basic psychological structure that characterizes this generation. During this period, we conducted over 150 in-depth interviews and surveyed panels of more than 4,100 people.

Gen Z itself does not feel like it is in the "driver's seat" despite its seemingly great influence. Youthful words such as "lost" (2020) and "bottomless" (2022) reflect the basic feeling. One 17-year-old puts it in a nutshell: "The worst thing that can happen to me in my life? If I lose control of my life."

The feeling of loss of control on various levels can be identified as the core of the basic psychological structure. A distinction can be made between the physical-personal level and the cultural-social level.

  1. Feeling of loss of control on a physical and personal level: Growing up has always been difficult, because physical changes such as pimples, greasy hair or the smell of sweat, as well as burgeoning sexuality, convey a sense of loss of control. In addition, young people today do not simply become men or women, their search for identity is made more difficult by the discussion surrounding gender identities: "Am I perhaps a lesbian or trans after all?" Despite the greater tolerance that can be seen as positive, such questions tend to represent an additional uncertainty for most young people that is difficult to control.
  2. Feeling of loss of control on a cultural and social level: Gen Z has grown up in perceived crisis mode: financial crisis, refugee crisis, climate crisis, corona, wars and inflation. Although they live in a comparatively safe country, the feeling of a constant threat of loss of control is omnipresent.

How do young people deal with this core problem? Because: nobody can bear a feeling of powerlessness so fundamentally. Two mechanisms in particular can be highlighted here:

The feeling of powerlessness becomes a personal fantasy of omnipotence:

Gen Z turns the feeling of loss of control into big life plans, often with almost megalomaniacal expectations. For example: "I want to study biology, work in cancer research and win the Nobel Prize." Nevertheless, many young people do not believe that they can make a difference on a social level.

When it comes to climate, war and crisis, there is almost a no-future mentality. Gen Z is not very politically active, and movements such as "Fridays for Future" tend to be media hypes. Gen Z is also the least sustainable. Millennials, for example, are already more involved in recycling efforts and are more likely to reduce their single-use plastic consumption - and they also do this less than the even older groups in comparison. (Waste avoidance is the main topic when thinking about sustainability in all target groups, at over 80%).

Your own body becomes a control zone

So if the big picture can't be dealt with, what could be more obvious than devoting oneself to one's own body in order to regain control? Gen Z is very focused on "shaping" their own bodies in order to regain control. Beauty treatments and gyms give them a sense of security and control. Two thirds are extremely interested in beauty and cosmetics, and 42 percent of young men wear make-up. Cosmetic surgery is also widespread among 18 to 19-year-olds. Accordingly, over 60 percent of Gen Z also believe that you can tell a person's character from their appearance. This is because it shows the same attitude and desire for control.

In addition to body control, Gen Z seeks happiness above all else. They are constantly checking whether something is fun. Everything has to be immediately funny or touching, which is why video formats are getting shorter and shorter. "Instant happiness" is in demand, and Gen Z breaks off if something doesn't make them instantly happy. Nevertheless, they are rarely happy. Last year, the happiness index fell the most among Gen Z. An above-average number of young people are undergoing psychotherapy for anxiety and depression or would like to.

Parents and employers are not doing Gen Z any favors by constantly catching them. This prevents them from acting on their own responsibility and growing up. Less of a safety net could be a first step. Understanding yes, but also letting things slide sometimes and not always being the best friend. Allow real mistakes and failure, let young people experience consequences. This is the only way Gen Z can grow up and become a generation that feels truly self-confident.


* Ines Imdahl is a qualified psychologist, entrepreneur, speaker, book author and TV presenter. The mother of four researches, advises and speaks on topics such as Gen Z, media and advertising impact psychology and brand experience. At Screenforce Day 2024, she gave insights into facts, prejudices and the psychological structure of Gen Z.

More articles on the topic