Fierce flirtation with Swiss female readers
Women's Magazines: A Difficult Start for Ringier's "Edelweiss" in German-speaking Switzerland: Three German women's magazines are launching Swiss editions at once. And others are considering doing the same.
Women's magazines Difficult start for Ringier's Edelweiss in German-speaking Switzerland: Three German women's magazines are launching a Swiss split. And others are thinking about it.Swiss women's magazines are having a hard time in the Swiss-German market. With the exception of Bolero, all titles have lost a massive amount of circulation in the last ten years, and Meyer's even had to pull the plug last June. The reason for this is probably the dozen or so German titles that have entered the Swiss German market, three of which - Brigitte, Cosmopolitan and Freundin - have had a Swiss split for around 20 years.Now, however, this very market in which Edelweiss wants to launch has been moving strongly again in recent months: Tamedia launched Annabelle Business as an independent quarterly title, Schweizer Agrarmedien GmbH tried to jump into Modeblatt selig's gap with Frauenland, also a quarterly, and this week Bolero is launching Blush, the first special in a four-part special issue series. As if that weren't enough, the German magazines Joy and Shape (both Marquard Media) and Elle (Burda) will each be coming with a Swiss-German split starting in March and May, respectively. And other German titles are considering this step. For Sie from Jahreszeiten Verlag, for example, which already offers a split in Austria. "We are currently clarifying the potential in Switzerland. But there is no concrete project," says Managing Director Hans-Joachim Waldrich.
Combi, duo and trio packWhat makes the start even more difficult for Edelweiss is that the splits also offer combination options. In future, Elle Deutschschweiz can be booked with the existing Elle Romandie split at a ten percent discount at Mediapresse in Lausanne, while Cosmopolitan, Joy and Shape will be sold at Raverta Marketing in Zurich as a duo or trio pack with a 10 and 15 percent discount respectively.
It was Mediapresse and Raverta that gave the impetus for these splits. Both justify them with the needs of advertising customers. That's surprising: Because last year, the three existing splits of Cosmopolitan, Freundin and Brigitte combined a total of 236 ad pages, only 6 percent of the volume of Swiss titles (including 347 pages of Meyer's). In 2001, it was even less than 4 percent. And yet the goals are ambitious: Olivier Bloch, Director of Mediapresse, for example, expects 100 advertising pages for Elle from May to December 2003, and even 200 in 2004. Bloch's confidence is based on the fact that the two Elle splits will cover almost all of Switzerland in the future - just like Edelweiss.
Skeptical advertising client L'Oréal, one of the most important customers of women's magazines, does not seem to be eager for further splits, however. Cania Bonamy, who oversees the L'Oréal print budget at Universal McCann, will consider primarily Swiss titles - including the Swiss-German Edelweiss - just for the sake of breadth. "The splits are mainly good for optimizing or diversifying," she says.
But what prompted the German publishers to make the respective split investment? Little can be learned from them. Marquard Media merely announced that Joy and Shape had now each achieved circulations in Switzerland that made their own splits seem worthwhile. Even Franz-Joseph Frei, who represents the Freundin split and all Burda titles (except Elle) in Switzerland with his agency FJF Intermedia, is surprised by this. "The heyday of splits was 20 years ago, when we had six to eight ad pages per issue," he says. In the meantime, however, the volume is "probably modest because of television. It is possible, however, that some customers no longer have enough money for expensive TV commercials and are therefore booking print advertising again.
Martina Allenspach, Managing Director of Bolero, also makes a plausible assumption: unlike the German market, the Swiss advertising market is comparatively stable, which is why German publishers are rushing to the local market after their losses, she says. Moreover, since Swiss titles generate significant sales with German customers, the German titles are now trying to win back at least these bugs with their splits.
Allenspach does not rule out the possibility of Bolero losing readers "at the margins" to the German splits or Edelweiss, but she believes that her magazine is occupying its niche well. Bolero has not reacted directly to the new interest in the Swiss German market. Nor does Allenspach want the announced four special issues to be seen as a countermeasure.
It's a similar story at Annabelle. The fact that the magazine beat the previous leader Schweizer Illustrierte in the number of ads last year and that Annabelle Business also got off to a good start with 121 ad pages gives publishing director Caroline Thoma reason to be confident. On the other hand, she doesn't think Edelweiss has too much of a chance: "As a new and yet not independent title, competing against strong Swiss magazines and numerous Swiss-German splits is something I find very courageous.
German women's magazines are pushing powerfully into the Swiss market, among other things, because the volume of advertising in Germany continues to shrink.
Figures on German-language women's magazinesTitle Circulation D-CH Readers EV Price Advertising Price D-CH
(Mach Basic 02) in SFr. (1/1, vf, gross)
Lucky post 170128 451000 3.50 12380.-
14-daily
Annabelle 100015 328000 5.90 18750.-
Brigitte 50000 163000 4.30 9300.-
Girlfriend 50000 181000 4.-- 9960.-
10 - 12x per year
Annabelle living 102866 189000 in pack m. 13200.-
Annabelle
Bolero 27066 91000 6.90 9270.-
Edelweiss**** 60000 - 14375.-
Elle 25000 - 7.90 7400.-
Cosmopolitan 30000 182000 5.20 10460.-
Joy 33000 - 3.-- 8400.-
Shape 22000 - 5.20 7300.-
Quarterly
Annabelle Business* 45000 94000++ 7.50 9000.-
Women's land* 80000 - 5.50 4250.-
* first published in autumn 2002
** appears from 26.2.03
++ Special evaluation Wemf January 03
underlined numbers = unaudited or projected editions
Markus Knöpfli
Combi, duo and trio packWhat makes the start even more difficult for Edelweiss is that the splits also offer combination options. In future, Elle Deutschschweiz can be booked with the existing Elle Romandie split at a ten percent discount at Mediapresse in Lausanne, while Cosmopolitan, Joy and Shape will be sold at Raverta Marketing in Zurich as a duo or trio pack with a 10 and 15 percent discount respectively.
It was Mediapresse and Raverta that gave the impetus for these splits. Both justify them with the needs of advertising customers. That's surprising: Because last year, the three existing splits of Cosmopolitan, Freundin and Brigitte combined a total of 236 ad pages, only 6 percent of the volume of Swiss titles (including 347 pages of Meyer's). In 2001, it was even less than 4 percent. And yet the goals are ambitious: Olivier Bloch, Director of Mediapresse, for example, expects 100 advertising pages for Elle from May to December 2003, and even 200 in 2004. Bloch's confidence is based on the fact that the two Elle splits will cover almost all of Switzerland in the future - just like Edelweiss.
Skeptical advertising client L'Oréal, one of the most important customers of women's magazines, does not seem to be eager for further splits, however. Cania Bonamy, who oversees the L'Oréal print budget at Universal McCann, will consider primarily Swiss titles - including the Swiss-German Edelweiss - just for the sake of breadth. "The splits are mainly good for optimizing or diversifying," she says.
But what prompted the German publishers to make the respective split investment? Little can be learned from them. Marquard Media merely announced that Joy and Shape had now each achieved circulations in Switzerland that made their own splits seem worthwhile. Even Franz-Joseph Frei, who represents the Freundin split and all Burda titles (except Elle) in Switzerland with his agency FJF Intermedia, is surprised by this. "The heyday of splits was 20 years ago, when we had six to eight ad pages per issue," he says. In the meantime, however, the volume is "probably modest because of television. It is possible, however, that some customers no longer have enough money for expensive TV commercials and are therefore booking print advertising again.
Martina Allenspach, Managing Director of Bolero, also makes a plausible assumption: unlike the German market, the Swiss advertising market is comparatively stable, which is why German publishers are rushing to the local market after their losses, she says. Moreover, since Swiss titles generate significant sales with German customers, the German titles are now trying to win back at least these bugs with their splits.
Allenspach does not rule out the possibility of Bolero losing readers "at the margins" to the German splits or Edelweiss, but she believes that her magazine is occupying its niche well. Bolero has not reacted directly to the new interest in the Swiss German market. Nor does Allenspach want the announced four special issues to be seen as a countermeasure.
It's a similar story at Annabelle. The fact that the magazine beat the previous leader Schweizer Illustrierte in the number of ads last year and that Annabelle Business also got off to a good start with 121 ad pages gives publishing director Caroline Thoma reason to be confident. On the other hand, she doesn't think Edelweiss has too much of a chance: "As a new and yet not independent title, competing against strong Swiss magazines and numerous Swiss-German splits is something I find very courageous.
German women's magazines are pushing powerfully into the Swiss market, among other things, because the volume of advertising in Germany continues to shrink.
Figures on German-language women's magazinesTitle Circulation D-CH Readers EV Price Advertising Price D-CH
(Mach Basic 02) in SFr. (1/1, vf, gross)
Lucky post 170128 451000 3.50 12380.-
14-daily
Annabelle 100015 328000 5.90 18750.-
Brigitte 50000 163000 4.30 9300.-
Girlfriend 50000 181000 4.-- 9960.-
10 - 12x per year
Annabelle living 102866 189000 in pack m. 13200.-
Annabelle
Bolero 27066 91000 6.90 9270.-
Edelweiss**** 60000 - 14375.-
Elle 25000 - 7.90 7400.-
Cosmopolitan 30000 182000 5.20 10460.-
Joy 33000 - 3.-- 8400.-
Shape 22000 - 5.20 7300.-
Quarterly
Annabelle Business* 45000 94000++ 7.50 9000.-
Women's land* 80000 - 5.50 4250.-
* first published in autumn 2002
** appears from 26.2.03
++ Special evaluation Wemf January 03
underlined numbers = unaudited or projected editions
Markus Knöpfli
