Penalty order against journalist Binswanger for defamation

Tages-Anzeiger journalist Michéle Binswanger has been found guilty by the Basel Public Prosecutor’s Office, via a summary judgment, of defaming former Zug cantonal councilwoman Jolanda Spiess-Hegglin. The journalist was sentenced to a suspended fine of 45 daily rates of 200 francs and a fine of 1,500 francs. Binswanger plans to appeal the ruling.

Monday's penalty order, which was available to the Keystone-SDA news agency, is not yet legally binding. Earlier, CH Media had reported on the verdict.

Spiess-Hegglin, who works as managing director for the Netzcourage association against hate on the Internet, had reported Binswanger for defamation and libel in her canton of residence, Basel-Stadt. The reason for the criminal complaint was a tweet by Binswanger on May 4, 2020.

Binswanger had written that Spiess-Hegglin had been accusing an innocent man of rape for five and a half years. The background is the Zug Landammann celebration of 2014, after which Spiess-Hegglin's canton council colleague Markus Hürlimann had come under suspicion for a possible sexual offense. Criminally, the incidents were concluded without convictions.

Binswanger had published the "incriminated tweet" against his better knowledge, the criminal order stated. This was despite the fact that the accusation of false accusation had already been conclusively investigated by the prosecution authorities and refuted in favor of Spiess-Hegglin.

Tamedia will appeal the verdict and submit evidence against the accusation of defamation, as Nicole Bänninger, Head of Communications at Tamedia, said on request. The Basel public prosecutor's office had issued a penalty order against Binswanger without hearing her in advance. Tamedia is not commenting further on the proceedings at this time.

ETUC criticizes communication of Spiess-Hegglin

Spiess-Hegglin and Binswanger have been in a legal dispute for about a year: Binswanger was most recently working on a book about the Landammann celebration, but it may not be published for the time being.

Last September, the Zug Cantonal Court had confirmed a superprovisional injunction issued in May 2020. Spiess-Hegglin had justified her request for a ban by saying that she wanted to prevent Binswanger from writing about her in a way that would violate her personality.

After various private social media posts by Spiess-Hegglin - namely a "Like" under a Twitter entry of the online platform "Megafon" of the Reitschule Bern, which showed Binswanger with his head cut off - the Federal Office for Gender Equality (EGB) intervened two weeks ago. It supports the Netzcourage association with an amount of 192,000 Swiss francs.

The ETUC criticized in particular deficiencies in Netzcourage's communication and the lack of separation between Spiess-Hegglin's role as a private person and as managing director. It therefore sent the association a reminder, asking it to submit a communication concept and a code of conduct on social media by August 31.

In response, the co-president of Netzcourage, Greta Gysin (Greens/TI), wrote on Twitter that Netzcourage had taken note of the EBG's warning. They are aware that the partial financing of their victim support service also entails obligations and that "the association must adapt organizationally to the new requirements. (SDA)

More articles on the topic