Federal Supreme Court: More favorable official inspection for media
According to the Federal Supreme Court, members of the media should not be required to pay—or at least not in full—to access official documents. The judges in Lausanne ruled in favor of a journalist from K-Tipp.
In 2010, the journalist had asked the Swiss Federal Office of Energy (SFOE) for information regarding the testing of energy labels on electrical appliances as part of an investigation. After he was not satisfied with the answers provided by e-mail, he submitted a request for access to the relevant documents for CHF 250. The SFOE informed him in advance that it would charge a fee of CHF 250 for his efforts. The journalist received a corresponding invoice after the inspection. He challenged the fee order before the Federal Administrative Court, which rejected his appeal last November. The Federal Supreme Court has now overturned this decision and partially ruled in favor of the K-Tipp editor. According to the court, the Public Access Act obliges the Federal Council to take the special needs of the media into consideration when regulating the procedure for access to official documents.
No explicit exemption
In the corresponding ordinance, the Federal Council did not explicitly provide for an exemption from fees for media professionals. However, it nevertheless assumed that fees could be waived in individual cases. In particular, it should be taken into account that the media are regularly dependent on access to official documents in order to perform their function and that an accumulation of inspection fees for certain media could have the effect of restricting access.
Scope for authorities
However, the authorities would have a certain amount of leeway: they could either generally refrain from charging fees to journalists or reduce the fee appropriately. Instead of this somewhat vague regulation, it would be preferable, according to the Federal Supreme Court, for the Federal Council to clarify the matter clearly. In this specific case, the SFOE must now make a new decision. As the K-Tipp editor's inquiry clearly concerns a topic of public interest, the Federal Supreme Court has ruled that the SFOE must grant a particularly favorable fee rate or waive the fee altogether. (SDA)
Image: Keystone
