User-initiated social media activities entail significant risks

Thanks to social media, consumers have more and more opportunities to create brand content on their own. This often happens without any prior prompting from the brand owner. For marketers, the question is how such user-generated brand messages affect brand perception and sales.

A recent study by INSEAD Business School and McKinsey comes to the conclusion that the negative effects clearly outweigh the positive ones. Facebook posts, YouTube videos or tweets with a negative tone have a much stronger impact than posts that focus on the positive aspects of a brand.

The effect of user-initiated social media activities was examined by the researchers using a marketing mix response model for two areas: the market for flat-screen televisions and the market for broadband connections. The model included the sales effects of user-generated brand messages as well as the impact of traditional marketing instruments (e.g. print, TV or outdoor advertising). Macroeconomic parameters such as general consumer confidence and seasonal sales fluctuations were also taken into account.

The example of the flatscreen TV brand in question initially shows the immense impact of a traditional customer approach originating from the provider: 45.4% of brand sales depend on provider-driven activities. These include advertising on the Internet (11.6%), in stores (11.5%), on TV (7.0%), in print media (6.9%), on the radio (5.7%) and outdoors (2.7%). Compared to supplier-driven advertising, the impact of consumer-initiated social media activities on sales is low overall. The net effect is only 0.6%.
 
A more detailed analysis of the tone of social media posts shows that positive comments on social media increased sales of the flat screen brand by 7.0% in the period under review. Neutral posts had hardly any effect, increasing brand sales by 0.5 percent. Negative social media posts, on the other hand, reduced sales by 6.9%.

It is revealing when you also consider how many social media ratings of the respective tonality are responsible for these effects. The number of positive ratings (14,762) significantly exceeds the number of negative ratings (3320). One thousand positive social media ratings therefore result in a sales effect of 0.47 percent, while one thousand negative ratings result in a sales effect of -2.08 percent. In other words, a negative social media rating has 4.42 times more impact than a positive one.

The analysis of a provider of broadband connections shows fundamentally similar results. In this case, the strong effect of established marketing instruments is also clear: TV (24.4%), internet (20.6%) and print advertising (7.2%) together account for more than 50% of new and renewed customer contracts. However, positive and neutral social media posts do not have a statistically significant effect on customer acquisition. Negative posts are different: they have a stronger effect.

In the period under review, negative social media ratings reduced the number of new and renewed contracts by 10.2%. From the researchers' point of view, this pattern is typical for offers with rather low customer involvement. Positive experiences have hardly any effect, while negative ones can have a substantial negative impact. Firstly, it can be concluded that traditional provider-driven marketing activities continue to trigger significantly stronger sales effects than user-generated brand messages in social media. Secondly, it can be stated that user-initiated social media activities certainly hold opportunities, but even greater risks. Great sensitivity is therefore required when interacting with consumers.

Clemens Koob

More articles on the topic