The battle for the Swiss wallet is on
Twint and Paymit announced their merger just under a year ago. Shortly thereafter, Apple Pay entered the market. With the launch of the new Twint, the final showdown among mobile payment solutions is looming.

In Switzerland, many companies have already tried their hand at a mobile payment app. Many have failed. Consumers have so far made only sparse use of the payment option.
Nevertheless, a battle for dominance in the Swiss mobile payment market is raging. Swiss companies have rallied together under the Twint banner to take on the supremacy of tech giants Apple and Google. A losing battle?
Rapid consolidation in the Swiss market
Mobino, Tapit, Muume, Wally, Bellamy and Klimpr ... These names hardly mean anything to anyone these days. They are all Swiss mobile payment apps. Most of them have already disappeared. Swisscom, for example, discontinued its app Tapit after a short time due to lack of interest. The company joined the alliance around Six with its Paymit app. Paymit is supported by several major Swiss banks, including UBS, Credit Suisse, Raiffeisen and ZKB. The app allows users to send money to other people using their smartphones. The competitor was Postfinance's Twint app.
Together against Apple
In 2016, however, the two competitors announced their merger. The reason given was that a single strong standard made more sense than two. Under the name Twint, they want to help a Swiss payment technology achieve a breakthrough. The new joint app has been available since April, with ZKB making a start. Twint proudly calls itself the "new Swiss standard in mobile payment".
Such cooperation between Swiss companies is rare. But the enemy is clear and the threat great: Only two months after the merger was announced, Apple Pay also appeared in Switzerland without much notice. Android Pay is also expected in the next few years.
Different systems
"Apple Pay in Switzerland so far is simply a virtual credit card. Instead of a plastic card, you have the card on your smartphone." This is how Sandro Graf, a marketing lecturer at the Zurich University of Applied Sciences (ZHAW), describes how Apple Pay works. The smartphone transmits the data for the payment via Near Field Communication (NFC) - a technology that is already used for contactless payment. Such terminals are widespread in Switzerland. However, the number of banks or credit card issuers in Switzerland that cooperate with Apple is small; they currently see Apple as a competitor.
Twint, on the other hand, works like a debit card. Users can load money onto the app and use it to pay at cash registers. Either via Bluetooth with a Twint beacon or via QR code. The app also allows users to transfer money to other users. They can also search for and redeem coupons and discounts on Twint.
Sparse use
So far, you hardly see anyone using mobile payment when shopping. The estimated usage figures are low. Swisscom and UBS responded to an inquiry that Paymit and Twint together had been downloaded over 550,000 times and processed around 250,000 transactions per month. According to Tobias Trütsch, mobile payment expert and economist at the University of St. Gallen (HSG), most mobile payments are currently for amounts under 20 francs.
Estimating sales is difficult. One indication is provided by the number of credit card payments, Trütsch says. Contactless payments account for about 4 percent of domestic sales, he says. "A majority of those transactions and sales, I believe, are made with contactless credit cards, not smartphones." His estimates pertain only to Apple Pay. But they suggest that share is still very low. That will change, however, Trütsch is convinced. "Mobile payment figures will develop according to the S-curve," he explains. This means that the figures will increase slowly at first, but then sharply, until the growth curve flattens out again. "At the moment we are still at the beginning, but in the next five years mobile payment will increase strongly," he says.
For that to happen, mobile payment must catch up with the competition. "Among other things, this is a question of convenience: Mobile payment must be as practical as cash or a credit card with which you can make contactless payments," explains Graf. When paying, people don't usually make a conscious decision, they just follow habit. It takes time to get people used to a new means of payment and to convince them of its benefits.
A quick test shows that the current Twint is still relatively unwieldy if the user is not a customer of a partner bank. A bank transfer takes a day. Going to a recharge point to top up the account is impractical. And for direct debit, one would have to send a letter to the bank. But that's supposed to change with the new version of Twint.
Mobile payment has advantages for consumers and merchants
However, providers, merchants and experts all agree that mobile payment does have advantages. One advantage, for example, is security. "On a physical credit card, you see the credit card number, the name, the expiration date and the security code. In some cases, this data is already sufficient to make a transaction," says Graf. "With Apple Pay, that's not the case. A third party would have to go to great lengths to hack the smartphone or get the user's fingerprint to misuse a payment."
Mobile payment in the sense of Twint combines some features of credit cards and cash. Users can pay an amount down to the centime. There is no need to go to an ATM. In addition, they can easily transfer money to other people. Customer and stamp cards are also directly integrated into the app, as UBS spokesman Marco Tomasina explains.
Sarah Pally, media spokesperson for Twint, also sees advantages for retailers. With Twint, it is possible to collect money with a smartphone in stores, on the go, but also online, at vending machines and at other unattended points of sale. In addition, merchants could use Twint for marketing by offering coupons and discounts.
The new Twint
In April, an update was released for Twint that combines Paymit and Twint. Similar to Paymit, banks have the option to release their Twint app under their own name. The great interest on the part of the banks in this is also a reason why the new app has been delayed, says Pally. Because Twint is an open solution, banks that have not been involved before can also participate. That should boost trust in the solution. People trust their local bank more than an international corporation or start-up, Graf confirms.
The new version allows direct debiting from the account. It is no longer necessary to top up the account beforehand. Twint plans to add more features over the course of the year. These include linking credit cards to Twint as a payment option. Twint says it also plans to offer bill pay. Users could then scan a payment slip to pay the bill directly.
Twint is probably in a better position than before thanks to the merger with Paymit. New functions are to be added soon. In addition, the largest Swiss banks are backing the solution. Not a bad starting position, actually. But is that enough against Apple?
Switzerland is made for Apple Pay
Apple sold 78 million smartphones worldwide in the last quarter of 2016. And all devices have Apple Pay preinstalled. The company already uses it to process transactions worth billions of euros.
Switzerland is an iPhone country, the majority of smartphone owners have an iPhone. Terminals with contactless payment options are widespread in Switzerland. Abroad, it is also possible to pay with Apple Pay. The only obstacle to Apple Pay could be the Swiss love of cash. But Twint also has to overcome this hurdle. So Switzerland seems predestined for Apple Pay to succeed.
"Twint is more than a virtual credit card"
Asked how Twint could stand up to international competition, Pally says: "Twint is much more than a virtual credit card. Users can use it to pay, send or request money. They can connect their bank account directly and benefit from offers and customer loyalty programs in the app. Twint is also a Swiss solution. That means it is tailored to the Swiss market and takes into account the needs of banks, retailers and, of course, users."
Graf from ZHAW is not sure if that is enough: "From a business perspective, Twint may not be worth it. Apple Pay earns millions of transactions in several countries. Twint, on the other hand, only serves the Swiss market, which is much smaller. However, a Swiss solution can exist if it is easy to use and widely available." Apple's assessment of the Swiss market was pending at press time.
At the moment, Swiss banks are resisting Apple Pay. They prefer their "own" solution, which they can influence. But how long can they oppose the development if more and more consumers use Apple Pay? Aside from dwindling influence, banks worry that they could disappear from the equation. After all, if tech companies apply for a banking license, they would no longer have to rely on UBS and Co.
Messenger as a threat
Perhaps the biggest competitors for Twint are not Apple or Android Pay. It's the instant messaging services like Whatsapp or Facebook Messenger. For consumers, the biggest advantage of Twint over Apple Pay is probably the ability to easily send money to others.
The Chinese messenger Wechat allows its users not only to chat, but also to send money. The function is extremely successful in China. Wechat is now also used to pay in stores. It is very likely that Facebook will copy this success. In the USA, customers can already send money with Facebook Messenger. Whatsapp is probably the most popular messenger app in Switzerland. If the app were to suddenly allow money transfers, there is a high probability that most people would rather use the app they already have installed anyway.
Sooner or later, mobile payment will also become a widespread means of payment in Switzerland. It may still take a few years until then, but it is likely to change the way money is handled, and not just in Switzerland. Who will come out on top in the end? Twint, Apple, Facebook or Google? We will be curious to see. (Adrian Schawalder/NetWeek)
This article was taken from Netzwoche.

