Competitions become a lottery
If a contest exhibits all the characteristics of a lottery, it is illegal. By Ueli Grüter, LL.M., attorney at law, Grüter Schneider & Partner AG, Zurich; lecturer in communications law and co-editor of the book *Kommunikationsrecht.ch*. Once a month, he provides insights on practical legal issues in advertising in *Werbewoche*. Questions for the *Werbewoche* legal expert can be sent to [email protected].
The most spectacular case of a competition objected to by the Lotteries and Betting Commission (Comlot, www.comlot. ch) was probably when Migros wanted to offer its customers something special for the tenth anniversary of the Cumulus customer card in 2007 and gave away thousands of tickets for a concert by the legendary Rolling Stones organized by Migros. To take part in the competition, you had to be in possession of a Cumulus card and make a purchase at Migros for a certain amount in a certain period. In return, you received stamps that you had to stick on an entry card. The conditions of entry for the competition also stipulated that a certain amount would be deducted from the winners' Cumulus account for the purchase of the tickets. This meant that only Cumulus customers of Migros who shopped directly with the company were eligible to take part.
For Comlot, this competition was illegal because it had all the characteristics of a lottery, but Migros had not applied for a license for a lottery because no such lottery was intended. According to Article 1 of the Lotteries Act (LG), a lottery has four characteristics that must be present cumulatively: Payment of a stake or conclusion of a legal transaction, pecuniary advantage as a prize, regularity in the execution and determination of the winners by chance, e.g. by drawing.
This actually makes it clear how to prevent a conflict with the Lotteries Act and Comlot when organizing a competition: You make sure that one of the characteristics of a lottery is not present in the competition. As a rule, it is easiest to guarantee all interested parties free participation in the competition. However, this must be clearly communicated and be available without obstacles or simply. In addition, all participants must have the same chances of winning, even if they participate for free.
Comlot is not to be trifled with. The Lotteries Act contains penal provisions, and Comlot does not shy away from filing criminal charges against organizers of illegal competitions. Just at the end of the year, Coop and Migros felt the effects of Comlot's now tough stance with their games "Simsala Win" and "Mega Win". Comlot complained that the free participation actually provided for in these promotions was not equal opportunity because, unlike in-store customers, such participants could only obtain a limited number of tickets and free participation was very complicated.
The competition is probably one of the most popular advertising measures. The rules of the Lottery Act are clear, and advertising agencies and advertising departments should be sufficiently sensitized by now. It is therefore surprising that even large providers repeatedly come into conflict with the Lottery Act and Comlot. Our experience shows that advertisers and marketers are becoming increasingly tricky when developing competitions and prize draws in the system, which is why it is often difficult to realize a meaningful and simple free participation. In order to minimize the risk of legal disputes, it would therefore be advisable to consult external or internal lawyers, especially if there is a risk that competition and game documents will be stomped out or, in the worst case, that a competition or game will be discontinued, thus damaging the company's image.
Ueli Grüter
