SVP National Councillor Mörgeli: Complaints against SRF
Christoph Mörgeli plans to file complaints with the SRG Ombudsman’s Office against three SRF programs, as he stated Thursday at a press conference in Zurich. The Zurich National Council member and medical historian feels he is the victim of a smear campaign.
Mörgeli also explained to the media how he had been bullied as curator of the Medical History Museum at the University of Zurich because of his disagreeable political statements. Mörgeli was dismissed from the University of Zurich last fall with immediate effect. The "Rundschau" report from March 27, 2013 about his work as a doctoral supervisor contained "66 factual misstatements", said Mörgeli on Thursday. He is also complaining to the ombudsman's office about a "10 to 10" program from 28 March and a "Rundschau" report from 3 April on the same topic.
According to the "Rundschau", around a dozen doctoral theses supervised by Mörgeli had mainly involved the transcription of historical texts. An anonymously quoted witness who had made accusations in the program had not submitted a doctoral thesis to him at all, i.e. had not received a doctorate for merely transcribing an old text, said Mörgeli. In a second case, a doctoral student had not simply translated a text from Bulgarian, but had first written it in Bulgarian and then translated it. Weltwoche also reports on the two "key witnesses" in its current issue.
In a press release, "Rundschau" states that the doctor Mörgeli and Weltwoche reported on was not the doctor who had testified in the television program. And the second witness was quoted correctly.
Making yourself untrustworthy as a scientist
Mörgeli accuses the "Rundschau" of having tried to cast doubt on him as a scientist in a character assassinating manner and to make him untrustworthy. It was wrongly suggested that he knew "exactly" about the fraud committed by a doctoral student who ultimately failed. Mörgeli went on to criticize the fact that the 14-minute report did not contain a counter-position. And he, who was able to comment live in the "hot seat", had only been given rudimentary information about the allegations before the broadcast.
In Mörgeli's opinion, the SRG program charter was "criminally trampled underfoot" with the "Rundschau" report.
Already other complaints against "Rundschau" article
According to ombudsman Achille Casanova, the SRG ombudsman's office for German-speaking Switzerland had not yet received Mörgeli's complaints by Thursday, but had received four other complaints directed against the "Rundschau" report. If the ombudsman's office considers complaints to be well-founded, it forwards them to the Independent Complaints Authority for Radio and Television (UBI).
However, Mörgeli has little faith in the UBI. Its president, Roger Blum, tweeted shortly after the "Rundschau" program that the "Schavan case" was a piece of cake compared to the dissertations supervised by Mörgeli. Annette Schavan had been forced to resign as German Education Minister due to accusations of deliberate deception in her doctoral thesis. Blum has confirmed a statement from Blick-Online that he will step down if the UBI has to rule on the Mörgeli case. He describes the linking of the two cases as "risky". He believes that Schavan is right to take legal action against the University of Düsseldorf's revocation of her doctorate. And he also considers it appropriate for the University of Zurich to clarify where the bar might be set too low for medical dissertations. (SDA)
Teaser image: Keystone
